Twitter lifted its ban on COVID misinformation - research shows this is a grave risk to public health




  • In Health
  • 2022-12-01 13:58:48Z
  • By The Conversation
The restraints on COVID-19 misinformation on Twitter are off.
The restraints on COVID-19 misinformation on Twitter are off.  

Twitter's decision to no longer enforce its COVID-19 misinformation policy, quietly posted on the site's rules page and listed as effective Nov. 23, 2022, has researchers and experts in public health seriously concerned about the possible repercussions.

Health misinformation is not new. A classic case is the misinformation about a purported but now disproven link between autism and the MMR vaccine based on a discredited study published in 1998. Such misinformation has severe consequences for public health. Countries that had stronger anti-vaccine movements against diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTP) vaccines faced a higher incidence of pertussis in the late-20th century, for example.

As a researcher who studies social media, I believe that reducing content moderation is a significant step in the wrong direction, especially in light of the uphill battle social media platforms face in combating misinformation and disinformation. And the stakes are especially high in combating medical misinformation.

Misinformation on social media

There are three key differences between earlier forms of misinformation and misinformation spread on social media.

First, social media enables misinformation to spread at a much greater scale, speed and scope.

Second, content that is sensational and likely to trigger emotions is more likely to go viral on social media, making falsehoods easier to spread than the truth.

Third, digital platforms such as Twitter play a gatekeeping role in the way they aggregate, curate and amplify content. This means that misinformation on emotionally triggering topics such as vaccines can readily gain attention.

The spread of misinformation during the pandemic has been dubbed an infodemic by the World Health Organization. There is considerable evidence that COVID-19-related misinformation on social media reduces vaccine uptake. Public health experts have cautioned that misinformation on social media seriously hampers progress toward herd immunity, weakening society's ability to deal with new COVID-19 variants.

Misinformation on social media fuels public doubts about vaccine safety. Studies show that COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy is driven by a misunderstanding of herd immunity and beliefs in conspiracy theories.

Combating misinformation

The social media platforms' content moderation policies and stances towards misinformation are crucial for combating misinformation. In the absence of strong content moderation policies on Twitter, algorithmic content curation and recommendation are likely to boost the spread of misinformation by increasing echo chamber effects, for example, exacerbating partisan differences in exposure to content. Algorithmic bias in recommendation systems could also further accentuate global healthcare disparities and racial disparities in vaccine uptake.

There is evidence that some less-regulated platforms such as Gab may amplify the impact of unreliable sources and increase COVID-19 misinformation. There is also evidence that the misinformation ecosystem can lure people who are on social media platforms that invest in content moderation to accept misinformation that originates on less moderated platforms.

The danger then is that not only will there be greater anti-vaccine discourse on Twitter, but that such toxic speech can spill over into other online platforms that may be investing in combating medical misinformation.

The Kaiser Family Foundation COVID-19 vaccine monitor reveals that public trust for COVID-19 information from authoritative sources such as governments has fallen significantly, with serious consequences for public health. For example, the share of Republicans who said they trust the Food and Drug Administration fell from 62% to 43% from December 2020 to October 2022.

In 2021, a U.S. Surgeon General's advisory identified that social media platforms' content moderation policies need to:

  • pay attention to the design of recommendation algorithms.

  • prioritize early detection of misinformation.

  • amplify information from credible sources of online health information.

These priorities require partnerships between healthcare organizations and social media platforms to develop best practice guidelines to address healthcare misinformation. Developing and enforcing effective content moderation policies takes planning and resources.

In light of what researchers know about COVID-19 misinformation on Twitter, I believe that the announcement that the company will no longer ban COVID-19-related misinformation is troubling, to say the least.

This article is republished from The Conversation, an independent nonprofit news site dedicated to sharing ideas from academic experts. It was written by: Anjana Susarla, Michigan State University. Like this article? subscribe to our weekly newsletter.

Read more:

  • Countries with lower-than-expected vaccination rates show unusually negative attitudes to vaccines on Twitter

  • Social media fuels wave of coronavirus misinformation as users focus on popularity, not accuracy

Anjana Susarla does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

COMMENTS

More Related News

California law aiming to curb COVID misinformation blocked by judge
California law aiming to curb COVID misinformation blocked by judge
  • US
  • 2023-01-26 18:08:23Z

A U.S. judge has blocked a California law that sought to penalize doctors who spread "misinformation or disinformation" about COVID-19 while he considers a...

Science has finally cracked the mystery of why so many people believe in conspiracy theories
Science has finally cracked the mystery of why so many people believe in conspiracy theories

Fall for conspiracy theories isn't driven by ignorance, or isolation, or insanity. It's something far more common - and way, way scarier.

Andrew Tate appears for day two of forensic device searches
Andrew Tate appears for day two of forensic device searches
  • US
  • 2023-01-26 09:11:13Z

Andrew Tate, the influential internet personality who is detained in Romania on suspicion of organized crime and human trafficking, appeared at prosecutors' ...

Amid Record Profits, Here
Amid Record Profits, Here's What Elon Musk Told Investors About Tesla's Rollercoaster 2022

He couldn't help but tout how man Twitter followers he had.

Trump hosts conservative influencers behind
Trump hosts conservative influencers behind 'Libs of Tik Tok' and Babylon Bee for dinner

Former President Donald Trump hosted the conservative influencers behind 'Libs of Tik Tok' and Babylon Bee at his Florida estate Mar-a-Lago.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Health