Russia's artillery is faltering in some parts of Ukraine, and Moscow is using Iran's drones to fill the gap




  • In Business
  • 2022-10-05 22:29:00Z
  • By Business Insider
Ukraine airstrike Russian Iranian drone
Ukraine airstrike Russian Iranian drone  
  • Russian forces have begun using Iranian-made drones in attacks on Ukrainian forces.

  • Moscow appears to be using the drones to compensate for shortfalls in artillery and airpower.

  • Experts say the drones have limited utility but it's unclear what impact they'll have on the battlefield.

With Russia's invasion of Ukraine faltering, Moscow has turned to an unlikely savior: Iran.

Russian forces in Ukraine are using Iranian-made "kamikaze" drones that have already destroyed precious Ukrainian artillery around Kharkiv, where Kyiv launched a successful counterattack that has driven back Russian troops.

Iranian-made Shahed-136 drones appear to be compensating for Russian airpower that has proven ineffective in combat and for Russian artillery that has concentrated far to the south of Kharkiv.

"In other areas, the Russians have overwhelming artillery firepower, and they manage with that," a Ukrainian colonel in the Kharkiv region told The Wall Street Journal. "Here, they no longer have that artillery advantage, and so they have started to resort to these drones."

Aside from the initial shock of encountering Iranian drones 1,200 miles from Tehran, it's not clear what impact the drones will have on the battlefield.

A Ukrainian military photo of what Kyiv described as an Iranian Shahed drone downed near Kupiansk.Ukrainian military
A Ukrainian military photo of what Kyiv described as an Iranian Shahed drone downed near Kupiansk.Ukrainian military's Strategic Communications Directorate via AP  

"I think we are at the early stages of assessing their usability," Samuel Bendett, an expert on Russian drones at the Center for Naval Analyses, told Insider. "They can hit Ukrainian long-range artillery - highly prized Russian targets - as well stationary targets like buildings."

Ironically, it was Ukraine that initially reaped the advantage of UAVs: Its Turkish-made TB2 Bayraktar attack drones, armed with laser-guided anti-tank missiles, took a surprising toll of Russian armor in the early days of the war.

But the TB-2 is a somewhat large, clumsy drone with a 39-foot wingspan and a maximum speed of just 137 mph.

Iran's Shahed-136, and its smaller cousin, the Shahed-131, which Russia is also using, are loitering munitions that are a cross between a drone and a missile: With a camera in their nose, they orbit a target like a drone until an operator on the ground smashes them into tanks, howitzers, and bunkers just like a missile.

The delta-winged Shahed-136 has a wingspan of about 8 feet and a cruising speed of about 112 mph, according to the Ukrainian military. Iran claims the UAV has a remarkable range of more than 1,550 miles, which would make it bigger and faster than the backpack-carried Switchblade kamikaze drones that the US has supplied to Ukraine.

Bayraktar TB2 UAVs is seen during the test flight at the military base located in Hmelnitski, Ukraine on March 20, 2019.
Bayraktar TB2 UAVs is seen during the test flight at the military base located in Hmelnitski, Ukraine on March 20, 2019.  

Western analysts were quick to point out the Shahed-136's flaws.

Justin Bronk, an airpower expert at Britain's Royal United Services Institute think tank, noted several limitations of bargain-basement kamikaze drones: commercial GPS guidance that's jammable, small warheads of less than 50 pounds, commercial components vulnerable to anti-drone microwave weapons, and difficulty hitting moving targets.

For Ukraine, perhaps the best news is that the Shahed-136 isn't hard to shoot down.

"They are slow- and low-flying, which significantly limits their utility as responsive weapons against a sudden threat at range and also makes them comparatively easy to intercept with old-fashioned radar-laid anti-aircraft guns," Bronk wrote, pointing to Germany's Gepard self-propelled anti-aircraft gun, which Berlin has supplied to Kyiv.

But loitering munitions like the Shahed-136 are fairly cheap and easy to operate, which could enable Russia to employ swarm tactics that overwhelm a target with hordes of drones.

"Russia's Shahed-136s are certainly an increasing problem for Ukraine," Bronk concluded. "Air defenses cannot intercept them all, and they will cause damage to cities, bases and probably SAM radars. Western partners should increase deliveries of short- and medium-range air defenses to help."

Ukraine police Russian drone
Ukraine police Russian drone  

This suggests an emerging contest between Ukrainian air defenses and large numbers of Iranian-made kamikaze drones. "I think a lot will depend on whether Russian military can field them in large enough numbers to begin overwhelming Ukrainian air defenses," Bendett said.

One embarrassing question is why Russia - which has invested heavily in drones - can't field its own cheap loitering munitions. Another is whether Iran will continue to supply Russia with large numbers of drones.

Like Turkey, Iran has emerged as a major player in the world of drones, which are relatively easy for smaller countries to develop and acquire compared to weapons like jets and tanks. Iranian-made drones have been used in attacks on Saudi oil fields, and Tehran has sold them to Venezuela.

Russia and Iran have been in a marriage of convenience for years - in part to spite the US - with Iran buying Russian weapons like the S-300 anti-aircraft system, and Tehran may see support for Moscow now as another way to counter the US.

But Ukraine downgraded its relations with Iran over the drone sales, and with Tehran still facing heavy international sanctions and buffeted by increasing domestic unrest, picking a fight over Ukraine seems risky. Then again, Russia and Iran, already pariahs, may feel they have nothing to lose.

Michael Peck is a defense writer whose work has appeared in Forbes, Defense News, Foreign Policy magazine, and other publications. He holds a master's in political science. Follow him on Twitter and LinkedIn.

COMMENTS

More Related News

AP Interview: IMF chief urges targeted COVID policy in China
AP Interview: IMF chief urges targeted COVID policy in China
  • World
  • 2022-11-29 12:36:17Z

It is time for China to move away from massive lockdowns and toward a more targeted approach to COVID-19, the head of the International Monetary Fund said...

Uneasy calm grips Ukraine as West prepares winter aid
Uneasy calm grips Ukraine as West prepares winter aid
  • World
  • 2022-11-29 11:11:37Z

An uneasy calm hung over Kyiv on Tuesday as residents of the Ukrainian capital did what they could to prepare for anticipated Russian missile attacks aiming ...

Putin acting
Putin acting 'absolutely despicable' over defeat in Ukraine, says White House
  • World
  • 2022-11-29 10:56:00Z

It is "absolutely despicable" what Russian dictator Vladimir Putin is doing in Ukraine in the last few weeks, White House National Security Council spokesman...

New poll suggests Americans
New poll suggests Americans' support for Ukraine is softening as GOP vows to slow the massive aid effort

"We're not going to write a blank check," a top House Republican recently said about US aid to Ukraine.

NATO ministers meet to drum up more aid, arms for Ukraine
NATO ministers meet to drum up more aid, arms for Ukraine
  • World
  • 2022-11-29 08:02:10Z

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken and his NATO counterparts are gathering in Romania on Tuesday to drum up urgently needed support for Ukraine...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Business