Judge Robinson could impose not much punishment, if any, on Deshaun Watson

  • In Sports/Football
  • 2022-06-30 20:24:43Z
  • By ProFootball Talk on NBC Sports

On one hand, Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson has had 24 different women accuse him in civil court of sexual misconduct during massage therapy sessions. On the other hand, Watson was never charged with a crime.

In the middle resides the NFL. Because the Watson case has become the first one to be processed under the league's new procedure for determining Personal Conduct Policy violations, no one knows what will happen.

The league wants a minimum suspension of one year. (The ongoing dearth of news regarding the proceedings actually has resulted in reporting that the NFL still wants a minimum suspension of one year, the legal equivalent of Chevy Chase's periodic updates regarding the health of Generalissimo Francisco Franco.) Watson wants no punishment at all.

Retired federal judge Sue L. Robinson has presided over three days of hearings. She'll make the decision based on the facts, as sufficient proven (or not) by the league.

What are the facts? It's known that the NFL focused on five claims against Watson. It's known that no one is claiming that he committed violence or used physical force, against anyone. It's believed by some that he had a habit/fetish of seeking massages and hoping they would turn sexual.

Given that the Personal Conduct Policy prohibits "assault and/or battery, including sexual assault or other sex offenses" and creates a six-game baseline suspension for "sexual assault involving physical force or committed against someone incapable of giving consent," where is the basis for punishing Watson for sexual assault, or any kind? Surely, the NFL Players Association has been making that point, all week.

That said, the policy has two important catch-all provisions: (1) "conduct that poses a genuine danger to the safety and well-being of another person"; and (2) "conduct that undermines or puts at risk the integrity of the NFL, NFL clubs, or NFL personnel." The argument by the league would (or could) be that Watson's apparent habit/fetish falls under both broad categories. Any maybe it does.

But here's the problem: Patriots owner Robert Kraft received no punishment at all for a massage that allegedly became something more than a massage. Even though the two cases entail VERY different facts, there's a common thread of massage-that-became-more. If that behavior wasn't something that triggered punishment for Kraft, how can it trigger punishment for Watson - especially since the Personal Conduct Policy expressly provides that owners are held to a higher standard?

No one knows how this is going to play out. However, it makes sense to be thinking about the possibility that Judge Robinson will apply the policy as written, that she will apply it strictly, that she will expect the NFL to have credible evidence of one or more violations, and that she won't be inclined to punish Watson simply for having a habit/fetish of hoping private massages turn sexual when an owner had no league scrutiny after a massage allegedly turned sexual. Put simply, there's a chance Judge Robinson will impose not much punishment, if any, on Watson.

Of course, if Judge Robinson imposes any punishment at all on Watson, the league can then appeal the decision to the Commissioner, who can increase the punishment. Judge Robinson's factual findings, which are binding on the appeal process, could paint the Commissioner into a corner.

In other words, if she imposes little or no punishment, the decision likely will come with specific written findings that will make it very difficult to justify increasing the punishment.

Judge Robinson could impose not much punishment, if any, on Deshaun Watson originally appeared on Pro Football Talk


More Related News

Browns announce they plan to start Deshaun Watson on Friday
Browns announce they plan to start Deshaun Watson on Friday

The Browns announced they plan to start Deshaun Watson in the preseason opener at Jacksonville on Friday. It's now up to appeals officer Peter Harvey to determine if that will happen. The NFL wants an immediate suspension of Watson, and the NFLPA hasn't ruled out the possibility as both sides wait for a ruling from [more]

Deshaun Watson expected to start Cleveland
Deshaun Watson expected to start Cleveland's first preseason game

Deshaun Watson is scheduled to start Cleveland's preseason opener Friday night against the Jaguars.

Daniel Barker sees Michigan State football as next step to NFL. But he must do this first
Daniel Barker sees Michigan State football as next step to NFL. But he must do this first

Daniel Barker exited the draft process and left Illinois after four seasons, hoping a transfer to Michigan State football will boost his NFL stock.

NFL wants immediate suspension of Deshaun Watson, NFLPA doesn
NFL wants immediate suspension of Deshaun Watson, NFLPA doesn't rule it out

Earlier today, we raised the possibility of appeals officer Peter Harvey ruling in the next two days that Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson should be suspended for a full year, and that it should begin immediately. We have an update. Yes, the NFL has asked for a one-year suspension starting now. If implemented before Friday night, [more]

Cruise ship crime: What to know if you
Cruise ship crime: What to know if you're sexually assaulted on a cruise. Resources, laws.
  • US
  • 2022-08-10 09:01:58Z

There is a "prevalence" of cruise ship related sexual assault allegations. Here is what to know about your resources and rights if you are a victim.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Football