Fact check: Baseless conspiracy theory about Hurricane Ian, COVID-19 pandemic circulates




  • In Health
  • 2022-10-05 19:58:38Z
  • By USA TODAY
 

The claim: The government engineered Hurricane Ian as part of a pandemic-related scheme

Hurricane Ian barreled into Florida's Gulf Coast where it wreaked havoc on homes and businesses before advancing to South Carolina. Some social media users are circulating a conspiracy theory that this wasn't a natural phenomenon.

"The 'storm of the century' as it is being called is unfortunately another one of many examples of how the government engineers weather to completely destroy places and as always they will use predictive programming to show you they're going to do it in advance," reads part of a Sept. 29 Instagram post's caption.

The post claims the government tricked people who were opposed to pandemic-related mandates into moving to Florida amid the COVID-19 pandemic so that they could then be devastated by Hurricane Ian.

"Sure seems like it all just a set up now!" reads text included in the post. "That's how Satan works. He is the ultimate deceiver."

The post garnered over 500 likes in less than a week.

But the claim is baseless.

Weather experts told USA TODAY it is not possible for anyone to engineer a storm. Hurricane Ian has no relationship to the pandemic, either.

USA TODAY reached out to the social media user who shared the claim for comment.

Hurricane Ian was not a 'set up'

No one has the ability to create a storm, especially not a tropical cyclone on the scale of Hurricane Ian, according to Jase Bernhardt, a hurricane preparedness researcher at Hofstra University.

Charles Konrad, the director of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Southeast Regional Climate Center, agreed.

"A hurricane has just an incredible amount of energy connected with it," said Konrad. "It's equivalent to like a 10-megaton nuclear bomb that goes off every 20 minutes. And that's just a typical hurricane, and of course Ian was a very strong hurricane. There's no way that you could bring that much energy in."

Furthermore, several atmospheric and marine conditions must be met for a tropical cyclone to form, Maria Torres, a National Hurricane Center spokesperson, told USA TODAY in an email. A cyclone starts after a pre-existing disturbance of showers and thunderstorms grows in time over a warm open ocean.

Fact check: Biden's comment about hurricane preparedness, vaccination predates Hurricane Ian

"If the winds in the mid-levels of the atmosphere are low, the disturbance can strengthen and develop into an organized area of low pressures with winds greater than 40 mph," Torres said. "As winds increase up to 74 mph and the center becomes more defined, this is when the storm is classified as a hurricane."

Bernhardt said that Hurricane Ian initially began as a cluster of thunderstorms over the Atlantic Ocean, strengthened over the warm waters of the Caribbean Sea, became a hurricane near Cuba and reached peak intensity over the warm Gulf of Mexico waters just before striking Florida.

PolitiFact also debunked this claim.

USA TODAY has debunked other claims related to Hurricane Ian, including baseless assertions that President Joe Biden advised people to get vaccinated in preparation for hurricane season on Sept. 27 and that an image shows Daytona International Speedway flooded by Hurricane Ian.

Our rating: False

Based on our research, we rate FALSE the claim that the government engineered Hurricane Ian as part of a pandemic-related scheme. Experts said it is not possible for anyone to engineer a storm, especially at the scale of Hurricane Ian. There are several atmospheric and marine conditions that must be met for a hurricane to form.

Our fact-check sources:

  • PolitiFact, Sept. 30, Hurricane Ian was a natural disaster, not a political conspiracy to devastate Floridians

  • USA TODAY, Oct. 3, Ian's death toll climbs to 68; record flooding possible in Virginia; 600K without power in Florida: Live updates

  • Charles Konrad, Oct. 3, Phone interview with USA TODAY

  • Jase Bernhardt, Oct. 3, Email exchange with USA TODAY

  • New York Times, Sept. 30, How Hurricane Ian Became So Powerful

  • Maria Torres, Oct. 3, Email exchange with USA TODAY

  • USA TODAY, Sept. 27, Hurricane Ian nears Florida threatening storm surge. Graphics explain the deadly weather event.

  • USA TODAY, Sept. 30, Fact check: Biden's comment about hurricane preparedness, vaccination predates Hurricane Ian

  • USA TODAY, Feb. 4, 2021, What is QAnon? What to know about the baseless, far-right conspiracy theory connected to Marjorie Taylor Greene

  • USA TODAY, Oct. 3, Fact check: Image shows Daytona speedway after heavy rain in 2009, not after Hurricane Ian

  • USA TODAY, April 28, 2021, Fact check: False QAnon-related conspiracy theory claims Arizona ballots are secretly watermarked

  • USA TODAY, April 20, Fact check: False claim that Putin rescued 35,000 imprisoned Ukrainian children

Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.

Our fact-check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Fact check: Baseless Hurricane Ian conspiracy theory spreads online

COMMENTS

More Related News

How Dan Lanning, Mario Cristobal, Joe Moorhead graded as head coaches on new teams in 2022
How Dan Lanning, Mario Cristobal, Joe Moorhead graded as head coaches on new teams in 2022

Have you paid attention to Joe Moorhead's year at Akron? How does Dan Lanning's 2022 season compare to Mario Cristobal's? Check out these latest coaching grades.

Many nursing homes are poorly staffed. How do they get away with it?
Many nursing homes are poorly staffed. How do they get away with it?

President Biden has promised tougher standards, but USA TODAY found the government rarely enforces existing guidelines.

Disasters caused total of $122 billion in insured losses in 2022 - Swiss Re
Disasters caused total of $122 billion in insured losses in 2022 - Swiss Re

Hurricane Ian and other natural catastrophes have caused an estimated $115 billion of insured losses so far this year, well above the 10-year average of $81 ...

Fact check: Cyber Command watched for foreign threats on Election Day
Fact check: Cyber Command watched for foreign threats on Election Day

U.S. Cyber Command actively protected election infrastructure on Election Day, but a fabricated news story suggests it discovered domestic fraud.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Health