Facebook claims hate speech visibility dropped 50 percent in nine months




 

Facebook is responding to whistleblower Frances Haugen's testimony by attempting to shift the narrative on hate speech. Integrity VP Guy Rosen has posted a defense of the social network's anti-hate measures where he argued the declining visibility of hate speech mattered more than the mere existence of that content. The "prevalence" (aka visibility) of hate on Facebook has dropped nearly 50 percent in the past three quarters to 0.05 percent of content viewed, Rosen said, or about five views out of every 10,000.

The executive contended it was "wrong" to focus on content removals as the only metric. There were other ways to counter hate, Rosen said, and Facebook had to be "confident" before it removed any material. That meant erring on the side of caution to avoid mistakenly removing content, and limiting the reach of people, groups and pages that will probably violate policies.

There is a degree of truth here. Facebook has occasionally run into trouble for mistakenly flagging content as hate speech, and an aggressive removal system might lead to further accidents. Likewise, hate will only have limited impact if few people ever see a given post.

However, there's little doubt Facebook is engaged in some spin. Haugen in her testimony asserted that Facebook can only catch a "very tiny minority" of offending material - that's still an issue if true, even if only a small fraction of users ever see the material. Rosen's response also doesn't touch on Haugen's allegations that Facebook resisted implementing safer algorithms and other efforts to minimize hateful and divisive interactions. Facebook may be making significant strides in limiting hate, but that's not Haugen's point - it's that the social media firm isn't doing enough.

COMMENTS

More Related News

Facebook to
Facebook to 'squash' metaverse, says Axie Infinity co-founder

Jeffrey Zirlin, Axie Infinity co-founder, said a battle over the future of the internet was underway, following Facebook's rebrand as 'Meta'.

Iowa legislators target books and teachers for upcoming session
Iowa legislators target books and teachers for upcoming session

Two Iowa Republican leaders said they want to pursue legislation that makes it a felony offense for school officials, including teachers, to provide "obscene...

Better research into Instagram, WhatsApp effects on young users needed, academics say
Better research into Instagram, WhatsApp effects on young users needed, academics say

Meta should make public its research and collaborate on studies to better understand mental health effects of Instagram on kids, experts say.

Jack Dorsey dials in on his dream job - bitcoin missionary
Jack Dorsey dials in on his dream job - bitcoin missionary

While Elon Musk has shitposted his way to crypto sainthood, Jack Dorsey has been spreading the blockchain gospel far more earnestly than most. As CEO of...

From NFTs to Apple and the metaverse: Here
From NFTs to Apple and the metaverse: Here's what you can expect in 2022

This year has been filled with NFTs, the metaverse and blockchain. Here's a look at what the new year may hold for the entertainment tech you use.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Economy