Closing arguments expected to begin in Harvey Weinstein rape trial

  • In US
  • 2022-11-30 06:00:10Z
  • By The Guardian
Photograph: Reuters
Photograph: Reuters  

Closing arguments are set to begin on Wednesday in the Los Angeles rape trial of Harvey Weinstein, following weeks of emotional testimony that saw multiple women take the stand, including the wife of California's governor.

Jury deliberations are expected to begin this week, as the second trial against the former film producer in as many years nears its conclusion.

Weinstein was convicted of rape and sexual assault in New York in 2020. In Los Angeles, he faces seven additional charges of rape and sexual assault he is accused of committing in California.

Weinstein pleaded not guilty to the charges and has staged an aggressive defense, with his attorneys attacking the credibility of the women testifying against him and labeling his most prominent accuser, Jennifer Siebel Newsom, a documentary filmmaker who is now married to the governor of California, as a "bimbo".

During the six-week trial, the jury has heard painful, graphic testimony, including from four women who say Weinstein raped or assaulted them in hotels in Los Angeles and Beverly Hills. The trial also included testimony from four other women, who were brought in by prosecutors to establish a pattern of Weinstein's alleged behavior, though Weinstein is not facing criminal charges in Los Angeles related to their testimony. Those women backed up the California accusers' accounts with testimony about similar assaults by Weinstein elsewhere, including in Toronto, Puerto Rico and London.

The two women who are accusing Weinstein of forcible rape both repeatedly broke down on the stand as they testified, with the first accuser crying so intensely that the judge ended court for the day.

Though Weinstein, 70, appeared pale and shrunken in stature in the courtroom after years in prison, his legal strategy had not appeared to change much since his New York rape trial, and his attorneys engaged in grueling cross-examinations of his accusers, putting their memory and their morals on trial.

Weinstein's defense attorneys have argued that some alleged victims made up the attacks, and that others had consensual sexual encounters with Weinstein to advance their careers, and only began to describe their encounters with him as rape or assault in the wake of the #MeToo movement.

Weinstein's accusers in Los Angeles include an Italian model who says Weinstein showed up at her hotel room door late at night during a film festival in 2013, forced her to perform oral sex and then raped her. That woman, who has been identified in court only as "Jane Doe 1", testified the attack left her with intense feelings of shame and guilt for deciding to open the door, and that it made her want to "destroy" herself.

Weinstein's defense attorneys responded by showing the jury upbeat Instagram selfies the woman had posted from the hotel room in the days after the alleged attack.

Jennifer Siebel Newsom
Jennifer Siebel Newsom  

Jennifer Siebel Newsom, the first partner of California, also testified that Weinstein assaulted and raped her during what she thought would be a business meeting in a hotel in 2005, when she was a young actor and producer still trying to find her way in the industry. Judge Lisa Lench made clear that Siebel Newsom's husband, Gavin Newsom, could not be in the courtroom with her when she testified.

In a grueling cross-examination, Weinstein's attorneys asked Siebel Newsom about the graphic details of her testimony, including the sounds she made during the alleged rape, and showed the jury dozens of friendly business emails that she had sent seeking meetings with Weinstein or asking for his advice in the months and years afterward. Attorneys also questioned Siebel Newsom about political donations Weinstein had made to her husband's campaigns.

A third woman, who also testified during Weinstein's New York trial, said she had met Weinstein at a hotel in 2013 for what she thought was a business meeting to pitch a script, and that Weinstein led her into a bathroom, took off his clothes, and started masturbating and groping her, even though she kept saying "no".

A fourth woman, a massage therapist who specialized in celebrity clients, said that when she went to a bathroom to wash her hands after giving Weinstein a massage, he followed her into the room, masturbated in front of her and groped her.

Weinstein has been publicly accused of sexual misconduct by more than 90 women, who have said he used his status as a Hollywood powerbroker to rape, assault and harass women in the industry, from aspiring actresses to some of his production company's most famous stars, and that for decades the people around him enabled and covered up his behavior.

The trial comes as She Said, the film dramatizing how dozens of women finally chose to speak out about sexual assault by the powerful producer, is generating Oscar buzz.

Weinstein, who is currently serving a 23-year prison sentence for a rape and sexual assault conviction in New York, pleaded not guilty to the California charges and did not testify during the trial. He has continued to maintain that all his sexual encounters were consensual. If convicted of the new charges, Weinstein faces years of additional prison time.

In his New York trial, Weinstein's sentence came after he was convicted of just two of the five charges brought against him, with the jury finding him not guilty of the most serious charges of predatory sexual assault and first-degree rape. Legal experts said the conviction was notable because the jury found Weinstein guilty of raping one woman and sexually assaulting another even though both women testified to having continued relationships with Weinstein after being assaulted.

New York's highest court recently agreed to hear an appeal of his conviction there.

In Los Angeles, a jury of nine men and three women will deliberate on the charges against Weinstein. During the jury selection process, one of the women on the jury said she was "on the fence" about the #MeToo movement, noting: "I believe most women but not necessarily all."

Another of the jurors, an older man, expressed skepticism during the selection process about whether he could find a guilty verdict in a sexual assault case with no DNA evidence, as the prosecutors are asking for in this trial.

"It's kind of an ambiguous question," that juror said. "It all depends on the type of assault."

The Associated Press contributed reporting


More Related News

Video adds to questions about police shooting of a double amputee holding a knife
Video adds to questions about police shooting of a double amputee holding a knife
  • US
  • 2023-01-30 03:54:01Z

As they do every week during football season, the Lowe family gathered Sunday morning to watch the NFL games on two big flat screens in the South Los Angeles...

New York pregnant woman dies after car driven by beau slams into electrical pole: police
New York pregnant woman dies after car driven by beau slams into electrical pole: police
  • US
  • 2023-01-30 02:36:51Z

A Staten Island, New York pregnant woman died on Saturday morning after her beau, who was allegedly drunk, drove into an electrical pole, causing the vehicle...

Seven More Women Say "Scrubs" Producer Eric Weinberg Sexually Assaulted Them After Asking Them To Come To His Home For Photo Shoots
Seven More Women Say "Scrubs" Producer Eric Weinberg Sexually Assaulted Them After Asking Them To Come To His Home For Photo Shoots
  • US
  • 2023-01-29 20:05:23Z

The alleged assaults took place between 1998 to 2017; the TV producer was described as a potential serial rapist by a judge last year.View Entire Post ›

'Worst place to be a woman.' What rape, death of LSU student exposes about Louisiana.
  • US
  • 2023-01-29 17:56:58Z

The shocking, tragic death of Madison Brooks underscores the disparities women face in the state, from violence to maternal mortality to the pay wage gap...

Questions, worries loom over Benedict Canyon shooting that left 3 dead, 4 wounded
Questions, worries loom over Benedict Canyon shooting that left 3 dead, 4 wounded
  • US
  • 2023-01-29 13:30:57Z

Residents were left shocked after a fatal shooting during a gathering in the quiet cul-de-sac of Benedict Canyon, a neighborhood north of Beverly Hills.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: US