Arizona becomes first state to sue over Biden vaccine mandate, even though the text isn't out yet

  • In Politics
  • 2021-09-15 10:15:11Z
  • By Business Insider
Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich
Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich  
  • Arizona's attorney general is suing Biden's administration over his vaccine mandate.

  • It is "unconstitutional" he said in a statement, even though the exact text is yet to be published.

  • The AG also claimed that the mandate is unfair because it doesn't apply to undocumented migrants.

  • See more stories on Insider's business page.

Arizona's Attorney General Mark Brnovich filed a lawsuit against the Biden administration over its vaccine mandates, the first of several threatened cases from Republicans.

In the complaint submitted Tuesday, Brnovich called the policy is "unconstitutional," appearing to focus his argument on the claim that it unfairly does not apply to migrants who enter the US illegally.

President Joe Biden on Thursday announced sweeping vaccine mandates for federal employees and federal contractors, and mandatory vaccination or weekly testing for all businesses with more than 100 employees.

However, officials did not publish the text and details of the rule, only giving a broad summary. It is unclear when the full text - against which any lawsuit would have to argue - is due to be published.

Brnovich's office said the suit was the first to attack the mandates.

Other states like Georgia, South Dakota, Oklahoma, and Wyoming, as well as the Republican National Committee (RNC), have expressed their intent to challenge Biden's mandates.

Biden on Friday in response said those who want to contest the policies should "have at it."

Brnovich argued that the mandates favor "migrants who cross the southern border illegally " who "are not subject to any vaccination requirements."

"This reflects an unmistakable-and unconstitutional-brand of favoritism in favor of illegal migrants," Brnovich's office said in a statement.

He argues that the move violates the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment, his office said.

The Equal Protection Clause states that a government body cannot deny people equal protection under its governing laws, according to the Cornell law Legal Information Institute.

The argument - though in tune with GOP messaging focused on US border crossings - was not one predicted by legal scholars.

Those discussions focused more on potential government overreach and discrimination between different groups of US citizens, rather than between them and others. The scholars generally predicted that challenges to the mandates would fail.

The mandate is "one of the greatest infringements upon individual liberties, principles of federalism, and separation of powers ever attempted by an American President," Brnovich's office said.

The suit is against Biden, Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary of Homeland Security, the United States Department of Homeland Security, Troy Miller, acting commissioner for U.S. Customs and Border Protection, and Tae Johnson, acting Director for U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

According to CNN legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin, the move may be rushed.

The Labor Department and Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the agency tasked with enforcing the mandate for employers of over 100 people, have yet to come up with the rule to enforce Biden's mandate.

"I don't think that this issue is a slam dunk either way. But it is a slam dunk that you can't file a lawsuit against a regulation that doesn't exist yet," he said, CNN reported.

Brian Dean Abramson, a vaccine law expert previously told Insider's Erin Snodgrass that the mandates are likely to be challenged, but he doesn't expect the rule will be suspended.


More Related News

Biden admin sends
Biden admin sends 'negative sign' by keeping sanctions on Tehran, says new Iranian foreign minister
  • World
  • 2021-09-24 08:31:00Z

Iran's foreign minister says his government will return to nuclear talks "very soon" after it finishes a review of previous negotiations.

NY hospitals fear staff shortage as vaccine deadline looms
NY hospitals fear staff shortage as vaccine deadline looms
  • US
  • 2021-09-24 05:30:47Z

Hospitals and nursing homes in New York are bracing for the possibility that a statewide COVID-19 vaccine mandate for health care workers could lead to staff...

Hand count in Arizona affirms Biden defeated Trump in 2020 election, audit draft report says
Hand count in Arizona affirms Biden defeated Trump in 2020 election, audit draft report says

A monthslong hand recount of the count in Arizona's largest county once again confirmed President Joe Biden won the 2020 election over Donald Trump.

Buckle up: Arizona Republicans to show 2020 recount results
Buckle up: Arizona Republicans to show 2020 recount results
  • World
  • 2021-09-24 04:47:32Z

Ten months after Donald Trump lost his 2020 reelection bid in Arizona, supporters hired by Arizona Senate Republicans were preparing to deliver the results...

House passes larger defense budget than Biden administration requested
House passes larger defense budget than Biden administration requested

The House of Representatives passed the Department of Defense's 2022 budget, giving them a much larger sum for the next fiscal year than the Biden...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Politics