Anti-abortion activists' Supreme Court dreams are coming true




  • In Politics
  • 2021-10-23 11:15:04Z
  • By Axios
 

This is the moment the conservative legal movement has been building toward for decades: The solidly conservative Supreme Court is about to hear two major abortion cases within a month of each other.

Why it matters: All of this is likely to end with significant new restrictions on abortion and a clear path for Republican-led states to win the next big abortion cases, too - the culmination of a long and bitter fight for control of the judiciary.

Stay on top of the latest market trends and economic insights with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free

Driving the news: The court on Friday agreed to hear part of a challenge to Texas' highly unusual abortion ban. Oral arguments will be Nov. 1 - a dramatically accelerated timeline that compresses into just a few days a process that normally takes months.

  • One month later, on Dec. 1, the court is set to hear arguments in a separate case, challenging Mississippi's ban on abortion after the 15th week of a pregnancy.

The big picture: Mississippi's law and Texas' law are structured quite differently, and the two cases raise different legal questions. But between them, they present the court with a whole lot of ways to rule in favor of tighter abortion restrictions.

  • And with such a staunch conservative majority, the court seems virtually certain to take at least one of those options.

"This is the most significant moment in two generations," said Mallory Quigley, a spokeswoman for the Susan B. Anthony List, an anti-abortion advocacy group.

That moment has arrived largely because conservative state legislatures kept passing new anti-abortion bills year after year, even when they were mostly being struck down in the courts, to keep the controversy alive - while Republicans in Washington maintained a laser focus, especially during the Trump administration, on taking control of the judiciary.

  • "The court that we have now is the result of the long-game political strategy of the pro-life movement," Quigley said.

Details: Roe v. Wade and subsequent Supreme Court precedents say that states cannot ban abortion before the point at which a fetus is considered "viable," typically around 22 weeks. Mississippi, however, banned abortion after 15 weeks.

  • The state has asked the court to uphold that ban, and also to go further and overturn Roe.

  • Texas banned abortions after the detection of a fetal heartbeat, which typically happens at around six weeks - before some women even know they're pregnant.

While Mississippi's law is a straightforward government regulation, Texas allows any private citizen to sue any other private citizen who helps facilitate an abortion.

  • Even many conservative legal experts believe the court will ultimately strike down Texas' ban simply because of its vigilante enforcement structure. The Nov. 1 hearing will focus only on whether the Justice Department can challenge Texas' law, not on the merits of that challenge or the merits of a six-week abortion ban.

Between the lines: The high court has twice refused to stop Texas' law from taking effect while it works its way through the courts. The first time was a 5-4 decision, with Chief Justice John Roberts joining the court's liberals.

  • Roberts has voted to uphold states' abortion restrictions in the past. He may well join a ruling in Mississippi's favor. But the other conservative justices can win without him, if he's not on their side - or even if he is, but wants to move more incrementally than they do.

What might now look like the mildest option on the table - upholding Mississippi's 15-week ban, but declining to overturn Roe, and ruling against Texas - would be an enormous loss for abortion-rights advocates, because it would open the door for states to start proposing earlier and earlier bans, ultimately making them extremely hard to obtain in most GOP-led states.

COMMENTS

More Related News

Factbox-World
Factbox-World's toughest abortion laws
  • US
  • 2021-12-06 15:03:37Z

There are 24 countries where abortion is prohibited altogether. Unsafe abortions are more common in countries with restrictive laws, and around 40% of women...

An expert draws 7 lessons about US gun laws from the murder of Ahmaud Arbery and the Rittenhouse verdict
An expert draws 7 lessons about US gun laws from the murder of Ahmaud Arbery and the Rittenhouse verdict
  • US
  • 2021-12-06 13:40:18Z

A Kenosha, Wisconsin, jury found Kyle Rittenhouse not guilty of murder on Nov. 19, 2021. His trial sparked a national debate over gun rights and self-defense...

Reeves seems obsessed with Texas, Florida, Tennessee. Are they fair comparisons to our state?
Reeves seems obsessed with Texas, Florida, Tennessee. Are they fair comparisons to our state?

Mississippi outpaces many Southern states in personal income growth, adjusted for inflation, for the calendar year 2020. Is that enough to compete with other...

GOP senator on abortion: "It
GOP senator on abortion: "It's time to turn it back to the states"

GOP Sen. Mike Braun said on Sunday that given the difficulty of achieving political consensus on the issue of abortion, it should be left up to the states to...

Mississippi governor vows to enforce abortion ban
Mississippi governor vows to enforce abortion ban

Asked by CNN's Jake Tapper if he would enforce the "almost total abortion ban in Mississippi that exists" if Roe is overturned, the Republican governor said ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • zeyu604
    (2021-10-23 12:51:48Z)

    เพลิดเพลินไปกับ ทางเข้าเล่น
    BMCLUBVIP CASINO ONLINEอัพเดทใหม่ล่าสุด 2021 เดิมพันง่ายด้วยระบบฝากถอน AUto
    เว็บแท้ส่งตรงคาสิโนหลัก BMCLUBVIP ไม่ผ่านคนกลาง ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ เข้าเล่นง่ายผ่านทางระบบ BMCLUBVIP มือถือ

    REPLY
  • Do Assignment For Me online
    (2021-10-23 15:04:51Z)

    Your pursuit to Cheap Essay Help has reached a conclusion with our scholastic composing organization Assignmentsquare.co.uk. Go ahead and get in touch with us whenever it might suit you.

    REPLY

Top News: Politics