Why Ranked-Choice Voting Is Having a Moment

  • In Politics
  • 2020-02-11 19:59:03Z
  • By The New York Times
Why Ranked-Choice Voting Is Having a Moment
Why Ranked-Choice Voting Is Having a Moment  

Presidential election years always raise big questions about the way we vote, in part because the process can get kind of messy.

Caucuses in particular have been derided as old-fashioned, opaque or inaccessible. Their critics got a significant boost last week, when Iowa's caucus was plagued by technological and human mistakes, delaying results and plunging the first official voting of the 2020 campaign into chaos.

But even before Iowa, a new idea was catching on for 2020: ranked-choice voting. At least four states that have relied on caucuses to choose their Democratic presidential nominees - Alaska, Kansas, Hawaii and Wyoming - will use the method to select their delegates this year.

Ranked choice changes the very act of voting by allowing people to shift their support from losing candidates to more viable options as the field narrows, essentially doing on paper what caucusgoers have typically done in person. Versions of it had two high-profile real-world examples over the weekend: the Irish election, and the best picture at the Academy Awards.

It has a complicated history and comes in many forms, but ranked-choice voting has been gaining converts across the United States in recent years. Several cities now use it in municipal elections. Maine uses it for some state and federal elections, though many Republicans there wish it weren't so. And presidential hopefuls Andrew Yang, Michael Bennet, Bill Weld and Sen. Elizabeth Warren have warmed to the idea.

How does it work?

On a ranked-choice ballot, voters can rank the candidates they like rather than choosing only one. The process varies; a ranked-choice presidential primary and a ranked-choice mayoral election would be structured differently.

But here's a simple version: In a single-winner election, if no candidate receives a majority of first-choice votes, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those who marked that candidate as No. 1 get their second choice counted instead.

That can go on for several rounds until a candidate emerges with a majority.

With ranked choice, voters can support outsider candidates without worrying about wasting their ballots. And candidates can win only with support - or at least tolerance - from a majority of the electorate, which can help prevent polarization.

That's in contrast to the plurality or "first past the post" elections that are typical in the United States, in which candidates can win even if most voters oppose them, as long as the opposition is fractured.

Where did this idea come from?

Ranked-choice voting has lately gained a reputation as a new, progressive reform. But its history is long.

The multiseat version, in which candidates are elected to fill multiple open seats, was promoted by philosopher John Stuart Mill in 1861. A single-winner version was developed about a decade later by William Ware, a professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

There was a wave of interest in ranked-choice voting in the United States about a century ago, helped along by the contentious 1912 presidential election, when Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft essentially split the Republican vote, and Woodrow Wilson, the Democrat, won.

That helped strengthen the case for electoral reform, and an array of cities, including Ashtabula, Ohio; Kalamazoo, Michigan; and New York City, experimented with forms of ranked-choice voting.

The practice fell out of favor in many places once it was no longer useful to those in power. But now several cities, including San Francisco; Cambridge, Massachusetts; St. Paul, Minnesota; and Santa Fe, New Mexico, use ranked-choice voting. Even New York City joined that bandwagon (again) in a ballot referendum in November.

Jack Santucci, an assistant teaching professor of politics at Drexel University, said that ranked-choice voting starts to look attractive when an electorate is confronted with the right mix of polarization and fragmentation - for example, when a party or candidate maintains control with support from only a plurality of voters, while opposition groups are fractured.

Something like that appears to be unfolding now in the United States, where President Donald Trump's base of support is strong but not especially broad, and where Democrats are grappling with some internal division.

Versions of ranked-choice voting are also used in national elections in Malta, Ireland, Papua New Guinea and Australia.

Ranked choice can make politics a little more stable and even "a bit boring," said Ben Reilly, a professor of social sciences at the University of Western Australia. "Even in an electorate where there is a wide diversity of viewpoints, the winner will be a candidate who can hit that middle ground."

What are the arguments for and against?

Proponents of ranked choice say it can make campaigning less divisive. Ranked-choice elections sometimes beget campaign videos in which smiling opponents stand side by side and encourage people to vote for both of them.

Candidates are more civil when they have an incentive to appeal to voters as a second or third choice, said David O'Brien, a staff lawyer with FairVote, an organization that promotes ranked-choice voting.

"Coming out of a primary, you end up having a nominee who has more support, and the primary itself probably hasn't been as vicious and bitter as you might have seen otherwise," he said.

FairVote also says ranked-choice voting can increase turnout, open up the political playing field and mitigate the power of money in politics.

Vicki Hiatt, chairwoman of the Kansas Democratic Party, said she expected higher turnout in this year's presidential primary in the state. She added that people were happy they would be able to cast their ballot without strategizing about electability.

"Sometimes they're voting for the lesser of two evils," she said. "So most people have said to me: 'This is great. Now I can vote for who I really want.'"

Critics of ranked choice say it can upend electoral politics in unpredictable ways, cost money or dampen turnout. And in some states and cities where ranked choice has come up for a vote, opponents argued that the cause was supported by dark money or other outside funding.

In 2018, Paul LePage, a Republican governor of Maine who had won two terms in office without a majority, called ranked-choice voting "the most horrific thing in the world" and questioned its constitutionality. Republicans in Maine are still fighting it today.

And in New York in November, members of the NAACP and the City Council's Black, Latino and Asian Caucus spoke out against ranked-choice voting. They were partly worried that it could hurt candidates of color, and that a more complicated ballot could reduce turnout.

"It's not just this fluff about your first choice, your second choice and your third choice, like you're playing hopscotch," said Adrienne Adams, a Democrat who represents portions of southeast Queens. "This is so much more intricate than that."

She added that ranked ballots could introduce opportunities for candidates to game the system. "Ranked-choice voting just has the potential to erode that voting power that we've worked so hard for," she said.

Jason McDaniel, an associate professor of political science at San Francisco State University, said that while ranked-choice voting might have intuitive appeal to people who favor reform, it was not a panacea.

"The Democratic Party position now is that we need to remove barriers to voting, and I think ranked-choice voting is counter to that," he said. "My research shows that when you make things more complicated, which this does, there's going be lower turnout."

How does ranked-choice voting affect results?

Researchers are still trying to figure out whether it is easier for political outsiders to win under ranked choice, and what that might mean for diversity in political representation.

McDaniel said that because ranked-choice voting "usually advantages people who are incumbents or well known, or who have a lot of campaign funds," there was no guarantee that it would shake up the status quo, or that candidates from racial or political minority groups would benefit.

There are also concerns about whether the system could enable new forms of foul play. Santucci said it was possible that in the single-seat version of ranked-choice voting, a lone candidate of color could be edged out of a race by opponents who conspire to do so. He and Reilly have also argued that multiseat ranked-choice voting could be implemented in ways that are poorly conceived and deeply unfair.

But some research suggests that ranked-choice elections might promote diversity among political representatives. One study in 2018 found that in the Bay Area in California, there were better outcomes for women and candidates of color under the system.

Sarah John, an author of that study and a researcher with the University of Virginia and the Sunlight Foundation, said ranked choice was still a fairly novel system in the United States.

"It will take some time for researchers to come to definitive answers about its effects," she said. "Until then, the jury is still out, as it were, on whether ranked-choice voting will improve or hurt turnout and descriptive representation."

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

© 2020 The New York Times Company


More Related News

Tight inventories set the stage for U.S. auto industry rebound
Tight inventories set the stage for U.S. auto industry rebound

U.S. automakers are facing a problem most forecasters and industry executives did not expect when the pandemic slammed the economy this spring: Strong demand and lean inventories at dealerships. Automakers report September U.S. sales on Thursday, and forecasters expect the annualized sales pace will exceed the August rate of 15.2 million vehicles. Consumer demand for high-profit SUVs and pickup trucks has recovered rapidly since the spring.

U.S. appeals at WTO to place Canada lumber case in legal void
U.S. appeals at WTO to place Canada lumber case in legal void

The United States is appealing at the World Trade Organization against a ruling that largely favoured Canada in a long-running dispute over lumber, putting the case into a legal void. A three-person WTO panel determined in August that U.S. duties, designed to counter Canadian subsidies on softwood lumber, breached global trading rules. The United States notified the WTO on Monday that it had decided to appeal.

US threatens to close Baghdad embassy unless Iraq halts militia attacks
US threatens to close Baghdad embassy unless Iraq halts militia attacks
  • World
  • 2020-09-28 13:47:12Z

The United States has warned Iraq it will withdraw its diplomats from Baghdad unless Iraqi authorities rein in militia attacks on the US embassy. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo told President Barham Salih in a phone call on Saturday that the US would close the embassy unless Iraq stopped Iran-backed militias from striking American installations. Attacks on US targets in Iraq have increased since the United States killed top Iranian general Qassem Soleimani in an audacious drone strike in Baghdad in January. The capital's heavily fortified Green Zone has been targeted in at least 19 rocket and mortar attacks this month, while convoys serving the US-led international coalition against...

New US citizen refugees excited for first presidential vote
New US citizen refugees excited for first presidential vote
  • World
  • 2020-09-28 09:00:06Z

They came fleeing war and persecution in countries like Myanmar, Eritrea and Iraq, handpicked by the United States for resettlement under longstanding humanitarian traditions. Now, tens of thousands of refugees welcomed into the U.S. during the Obama administration are American citizens, voting the first time in what could be the most consequential presidential contest of their lifetimes. With some states already sending out early ballots, the first-time voters from Arizona to Florida are excited but mindful of their responsibility in helping to choose the country's next leader.

Huawei CFO Meng back in Canadian court fighting U.S. extradition
Huawei CFO Meng back in Canadian court fighting U.S. extradition
  • World
  • 2020-09-28 07:18:17Z

Huawei Technologies Chief Financial Officer Meng Wanzhou will be back in a Canadian courtroom on Monday as her lawyers resume their fight to block the United States' efforts to extradite her. Meng, 48, was arrested in December 2018 on a warrant from the United States charging her with bank fraud for misleading HSBC about Huawei's business dealings in Iran and causing the bank to break U.S. sanction law. Huawei lawyers will argue that the U.S. extradition request was flawed because it omitted key evidence showing Meng did not lie to HSBC about Huawei's business in Iran.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • free vpn for pc
    (2020-07-20 08:50:13Z)

    In the past few years, the popularity of free vpn for pc downloads has steadily increased, but for obvious reasons, this growth rate will accelerate sharply by 2020 and more and more people want to work and play at home. Is free VPN the answer? And if so, where should you go? [url=https://www.freevpndetective.com/]https://www.freevpndetective.com/[/url] https://www.freevpndetective.com

  • dna test kit
    (2020-07-20 09:12:10Z)

    DNA testing can improve or quickly understand your family history – through a close relative identification of the earliest ancestor. Some tests claim to reveal your “breed”, although this is a controversial and difficult subject. dna test kit Certain services can reveal your genetic susceptibility to disease and physiological traits, from the color of your eyes to your tolerance to cilantro.[url=https://www.dnatestguides.com/]https://www.dnatestguides.com/[/url] https://www.dnatestguides.com

  • order checks
    (2020-07-22 07:28:06Z)

    "In addition to saving money, you will also find more custom
    order checks and useful attachments. When conducting research, I ensure that safety is my top priority. Since entering your personal banking information can put pressure on you, I only trust companies that can win my trust.[url=https://www.ordercheckstoday.com/]https://www.ordercheckstoday.com/[/url] https://www.ordercheckstoday.com/"

  • car insurance
    (2020-08-05 02:55:59Z)

    Plastic inflatable dolls came about in 1968, when it became legal to sell car insurance via mail. By the 1980s, they were in sex shops. With the continual development of Artificial intelligence , the level of companionship has entered a new realm where the entire landscape of sexual toys car insurance[url=https://www.sexdolls.today/]https://www.sexdolls.today/[/url] https://www.sexdolls.today

  • sex toys
    (2020-08-06 06:15:09Z)

    Plastic inflatable dolls came about in 1968, when it became legal to sell sex toys via mail. By the 1980s, they were in sex shops. With the continual development of Artificial intelligence , the level of companionship has entered a new realm where the entire landscape of sexual toys < a href=" ">https://www.sexdolls.today/ [url=https://www.sexdolls.today/]https://www.sexdolls.today/[/url] https://www.sexdolls.today

  • dental insurance
    (2020-08-11 01:36:32Z)

    The preferred insurance plan for your dental insurance should not just save money but also provide you peace of mind, with the knowledge that you’ll be covered as needed. Your smile and teeth rely on regular visits to your dentist, and a solid dental insurance plan will ensure your teeth stay white for years to come. [url=https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com/]https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com/[/url] https://www.dentalinsuranceguides.com

  • escort radar detectors
    (2020-08-31 01:34:03Z)

    Everything you Need – High Definition video coverage of your drive, partnered with long range accurate radar protection creating one of the safest and most well informed driving experiences on the road
    Fast, Precise, & Reliable Alerts – Compatible with escort radar detectors app for real-time crowd sourced speed trap notifications, preloaded with red light and speed camera location which trigger GPS based laser precise alerts for iPhone and Android
    High Resolution Dash Camera for Cars – In-car video management on smartphone through direct WiFi connectivity to view, share, and edit videos. Full HD 1080p and continuous loop recording provide for high quality video capabilities
    [url=https://www.escortradardetector.com/]https://www.escortradardetector.com/[/url] https://www.escortradardetector.com

  • Dyson Vacuum Cleaners
    (2020-09-01 02:41:59Z)

    The dyson air purifier fan automatically removes 99.97 percent of allergens and pollutants as small as 0.3 microns such as pollen, bacteria and pet dander from your home. The 360 degree, vacuum-sealed glass HEPA filter removes indoor air pollutants while a second layer of activated carbon captures household odors and potentially harmful toxins such as paint fumes. Purifies all year round cools you as a fan in summer.

  • bissell vacuum cleaners
    (2020-09-01 08:07:14Z)

    We’ve always been a family-owned business, so we know all the quirks (and maybe a few hard-to-reach dust bunnies) of a house that is home to a family. We know the peace of mind that comes with having a clean home for those you hold closest to your heart, whether they have two legs or four. That’s why we have a complete collection of innovative products at your disposal—from < a href=" ">https://www.bissellvacuumcleaners.com/ [url=https://www.bissellvacuumcleaners.com/]https://www.bissellvacuumcleaners.com/[/url] https://www.bissellvacuumcleaners.com
    bissell vacuum cleaners to carpet deep cleaners, cleaning solutions we’ve formulated ourselves specifically for real messes we all make to pet hair removal products. We’ve got you covered. Each product is designed to help you take care of your favorite spaces and the surfaces in them. After all, what’s the point of having a floor, or a sofa, or a carpet if you can’t play on it?

  • Bissell Vacuum Cleaners
    (2020-09-22 00:46:54Z)

    "Single sound bar provides better sound quality compared to your TV.The
    Bissell Vacuum Cleaners is an easy solution, with advanced technologies that deliver the clear audio your TV can’t.
    Dialogue mode to make every word and detail stand out
    Bluetooth connectivity to wirelessly stream music from any of your devices
    One connection to your TV. Optical audio input (digital); Coaxial audio input (digital); 3.5 mm aux input (analog)
    Universal remote controls TV, bass, Bluetooth connections and more
    Speaker:2.6 H x 21.6 W x 3.4 D (3.73 lbs), Remote control:4.1 H x 1.6 W x 0.4 D (5 oz)"


Top News: Politics