Who won the Democratic debate? Our panelists' verdict

  • In World
  • 2020-01-15 06:57:47Z
  • By The Guardian

'So boring - save for a gross exchange between Sanders and Warren'

This was a debate where people talked about "literal tornadoes made of fire" and it was so utterly lacking in charisma that billionaire Tom Steyer was able to add a little flair to the proceedings by dressing like a human tape dispenser. His tie, as awful as it was, was the most interesting thing up there on that stage. It's almost fascinating how boring it all was, given how we almost went to war with Iran just a week ago, and how close we are to procedurally removing a president from office.

Look. We're all tired of this. Every time they broadcast one of these debates the viewership drops by a lot. The candidates are tired of this, of being asked to explain within 40 seconds complicated policy and ideology. The viewership is clearly tired of being asked to decide the future of our country based on 40 seconds of information. The only people who are excited are the moderators, who get to have their big moment on cable television. What fun it must be for them to talk over someone explaining how we might lower insulin prices enough so that people don't have to ration lifesaving treatment to ask how they feel about the latest Trump tweet.

The only real energy of the night was unfortunate. Once CNN moderator Abby Phillip got the opportunity to ask Bernie Sanders whether or not he said, as dubiously reported this week, a woman could not be elected president - which he strongly denied - she immediately turned to Elizabeth Warren to ask how it felt to be told by Bernie Sanders that a woman could not be president.

It was gross, like something from a new West Wing script. All that was missing were the stringed instruments bringing a sentimental surge to Warren's answer. It was also the only part of the evening where anyone felt present. Biden might as well have been wandering the stage aimlessly, Buttigieg was vacant and hesitant, and Sanders never does well when asked to pander with diversity language. We'll have to wait and see if the moment landed with the electorate, or if it played as cheap to voters as it did in my living room.

We all thought that with fewer candidates on a smaller stage, we might be able to hash out some real topics with some real seriousness. Tonight proved it's just electioneering all the way down.

  • Jessa Crispin is the host of the Public Intellectual podcast

'Joe Biden has reason to smile'

The Democrats' seventh debate won't likely move the needle but Joe Biden has reason to smile. At the end of the night he was untouched.

Overall, the debate was an exercise in somnolence. Once again, Elizabeth Warren was forced to defend the practicability of her version of Medicare for All, Pete Buttigieg sounded like the smartest kid in the room, and the former vice-president showed his discomfort standing behind a lectern.

As for Bernie Sanders, he was evasive when it came to addressing the cost of his plan to turn the economy on its head. Socialism is expensive. Most telling, was the post-debate awkwardness between Sanders and Warren. There are definitely hurt feelings on the left.

Amy Klobuchar's discussion of education and the job market was illuminating. Her take showed a concern for realities larger than political orthodoxies, and was a reminder of why she is one of the Senate's most popular members.

Watching the debate one could almost forget that by the end of the week the Senate will be in the midst of an impeachment trial, a fact that the Democratic presidential field did not appear overly eager to discuss even as the president seethes, rages and tweets.

  • Lloyd Green was opposition research counsel to George HW Bush's 1988 campaign and served in the Department of Justice from 1990 to 1992

'Elizabeth Warren held a command of the stage'

Elizabeth Warren masterfully handled her dust-up with Bernie Sanders over the electability of a woman at the close of the first hour of the debate, as she has over the past couple days. She pointed out that the men on the stage had lost 10 elections among them, while she and Amy Klobuchar never lost. For her part, the Klobuchar Dutch aunt routine begins to wear. Just saying no is no way to ignite a fire with despairing Iowa Democrats.

Biden maintained his position, as did Sanders (who sits atop the latest Iowa Poll). You could feel the spotlight dimming on Pete Buttigieg. Steyer moved no needle. Warren regained some traction in the final debate before the 3 February caucuses. She was able to explain her moderated healthcare plans in detail, called for removing all combat troops from the Middle East amid a flare-up in tensions, and held a command of the stage over the other candidates.

  • Art Cullen is the editor of the Storm Lake Times in north-west Iowa, where he won the Pulitzer prize for editorial writing. He is a columnist for Guardian US, and is author of the book Storm Lake: Change, Resilience and Hope in America

Warren probably won, while Biden sat above the fray

All the candidates, but in particular Bernie Sanders, were peppered with leading questions, and the most potentially interesting moment of the entire debate was confusingly mishandled.

Sanders was asked about a conversation that allegedly happened between him and Elizabeth Warren about whether a woman could beat Trump. He responded by saying that he did not, and would not, tell Warren that a woman was unelectable. Warren was then asked how she responded to being told by Sanders that a woman could not be elected president. The discrepancy between the two accounts was not addressed. And clearly not all is well, judging by what appeared to be an argument between the two, caught on tape right after the debate ended.

The foreign policy and trade focus of the debate was welcomed, but all the candidates were allowed to vaguely posture as anti-war and skeptical of free trade without any specifics.

The night's bigger winner is probably Warren for avoiding a big gaffe after a difficult week. And Bernie didn't do anything to disillusion his stalwart base. But I imagine that Biden is happy to be avoiding the fray and sitting comfortably with his lead and his reliable base of older Democrats.

As for Trump, he must be looking at the field and thinking that each and every one of them are beatable.

  • Bhaskar Sunkara is the founding editor of Jacobin magazine and a Guardian US columnist. He is the author of The Socialist Manifesto: The Case for Radical Politics in an Era of Extreme Inequality

'Discord between Sanders and Warren benefits Biden'

Viewers waited all day for clarity surrounding Senator Elizabeth Warren and Senator Bernie Sanders' 2018 conversation. Rather than ask for veracity or context, CNN's moderator asked Sanders whether he said that a woman could not win this presidential bid. After Sanders vehemently denied that he did, the moderator asked Warren what she thought when Sanders made the comment - the one he just denied making. Both candidates received applause after they affirmed their support for women candidates during elections.

This controversy is troublesome because it sows unnecessary discord between two relatively progressive campaigns. Sanders' comments, if made at all, were likely about the sexist voting habits of people who refuse to support women candidates, and not about whether individual women could successfully win an electoral race.

The biggest threat to both campaigns is Vice-President Joe Biden, who intervened to acknowledge his diverse voter base. He reminded us again that he was President Obama's vice-president, even when his former political commitments clash with his current talking points. For example, he condemned Trump's assassination of Gen Qassem Soleimani, but couldn't quite reconcile that with President Obama's multiple military killings without specific congressional approval.

All of that may be irrelevant for Biden. In some polls he is leading, even with black voters. That's despite being called out for siding with racist politicians against school integration. And after tonight's performance, neither Warren nor Sanders did anything to dent his lead.

  • Derecka Purnell is a social movement lawyer and writer based in Washington, DC


More Related News

Meghan McCain Confronts AOC: How Do You Defend
Meghan McCain Confronts AOC: How Do You Defend 'Bernie Bros'?

"I'm really glad that you decided to come and talk to us," Meghan McCain said when it was her turn to question Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) on The View Wednesday morning. "I feel like you're the boogie woman of the right and I'm the bogey-woman of the left so it's interesting to be talking

Bernie Sanders and Mike Bloomberg are both 78. And both, it turns out, have had heart operations.
Bernie Sanders and Mike Bloomberg are both 78. And both, it turns out, have had heart operations.

Former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg turned 78 years old last Friday. That makes him the same age as his top rival for the Democratic presidential nomination, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), and six months older than former Vice President Joe Biden.> Today is @MikeBloomberg's birthday; he's turning 78 years old. > > Yesterday, a voter told me he was interested in Bloomberg because "Biden & Bernie are too old."@JoeBiden is 77. @BernieSanders is 78.> > - Maura Barrett (@MauraBarrettNBC) February 14, 2020Everybody is expected to pile on Bloomberg in Wednesday night's Democratic debate in Nevada, and Sanders tested out his salvos in a CNN town hall on Tuesday night....

Medicare for All Would Save $450 Billion and 68,000 Lives: Study
Medicare for All Would Save $450 Billion and 68,000 Lives: Study

Bernie Sanders' Medicare-for-All plan would save the country about $450 billion a year on total health care spending while preventing nearly 70,000 deaths, according to a study published over the weekend in The Lancet.In the analysis, a team of epidemiologists led by Alison P. Galvani of the Yale School

NBC News/WSJ poll: Sanders opens up double-digit lead nationally
NBC News/WSJ poll: Sanders opens up double-digit lead nationally

Sen. Bernie Sanders's lead in the Democratic race comes as former Vice President Joe Biden's standing has dropped 11 points since the Iowa and New Hampshire contests.

Limbaugh: Trump Told Me to
Limbaugh: Trump Told Me to 'Never Apologize' for Homophobic Buttigieg Remarks

Conservative talk radio host Rush Limbaugh on Tuesday addressed the controversy over his homophobic attacks on Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg, revealing that President Donald Trump called him and advised him to "never apologize" for the remarks.Last week, Limbaugh-who earlier this month

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: World