Who Will Get Citgo? Mao's Defeat in U.S. 67 Years Ago Holds Clue





(Bloomberg) -- A dispute over a $626,860 deposit at Wells Fargo & Co. during the Chinese Revolution offers a glimpse into who may eventually control Citgo Petroleum in the current Venezuelan power struggle.

Juan Guaido, the head of the National Assembly, is trying to wrest ownership of Houston-based Citgo away from the current Venezuelan regime led by the autocrat Nicolas Maduro. The move forms a key part of his strategy to topple Maduro and install an interim government that would call new elections. To obtain Citgo, Guaido has said he plans to name a new board of directors for both the state-owned oil company Petroleos de Venezuela and Citgo, its U.S. subsidiary.

That would produce a nightmarish legal situation: One company having two parallel boards of directors, each claiming to be the true management. And making it even more tortuous, Citgo is a U.S.-registered corporation but is owned, at least indirectly, by a foreign government. If that weren't complicated enough, Citgo's assets are eyed by a long list of Venezuela's creditors including bondholders, Russia's state-run oil company Rosneft, ConocoPhillips and defunct Canadian miner Crystallex.

So U.S. courts will likely be called upon to settle the matter.

Here's where the decades-old dispute has striking similarity. The Bank of China found itself with two board of directors -- one led by the communist Chinese who had taken over the mainland under Mao Zedong, the other controlled by directors previously appointed by the Nationalist government, which had retreated to Formosa, known today as Taiwan.

In late 1949, the bank's old management attempted to transfer $626,860 of Chinese money out of what was then called Wells Fargo Bank & Union Trust Co. The U.S. bank refused, citing conflicting claims of corporate authority. The dispute ended up in a California district court.

Lawyers for the Taiwan directors argued that the Nationalist Government was the only government of China recognized by the U. S. For that reason, they said, the court should not recognize Bank of China's new management.

Taiwan Wins

After waiting for the Chinese political situation to become clearer, the court ruled in favor of the Taiwan directors in early 1952, giving them control over the account. The opinion said it wasn't up to the courts to decide which government best represents the Chinese state. That was a judgment left to the U.S. government.

"The Court should justly accept, as the representative of the Chinese State, that government which our executive deems best able to further the mutual interests of China and the United States," the court ruled.

While other legal issues are likely to come into play -- such as Citgo's corporate structure and Venezuelan law -- the opinion bodes well for Guaido, who the Trump administration has recognized as interim president in a bid to bolster his chances of toppling Maduro's authoritarian regime.

"The court will defer to what the State Department says and I think the State Department in the U.S. has made it really clear who they think is the proper representative of the Venezuelan people," said Mitu Gulati, a law professor at Duke University.

Removing Americans?

The legal battle is already starting to unfold. On Saturday, Reuters reported that PDVSA is taking steps to remove at least two American executives from Citgo's board. A PDVSA spokesperson didn't respond immediately to a request for comment.

If Guaido ultimately prevails, he may inherit a Citgo that would need to find new ways to thrive, especially if the daily operations of corporate parent PDVSA remain in Maduro's hands in Caracas. With new U.S. sanctions banning the Maduro regime from receiving the money generated by oil exports to the U.S., the steady flow of crude that PDVSA sends to Citgo is already drying up, which has forced the refiner to search for alternative sources of oil.

--With assistance from Fabiola Zerpa.

To contact the reporter on this story: Davide Scigliuzzo in New York at dscigliuzzo2@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Nikolaj Gammeltoft at ngammeltoft@bloomberg.net, ;David Papadopoulos at papadopoulos@bloomberg.net, Larry Reibstein

For more articles like this, please visit us at bloomberg.com

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.

COMMENTS

More Related News

Ukraine Set to Elect TV Comic as President in Runoff Clash
Ukraine Set to Elect TV Comic as President in Runoff Clash

Volodymyr Zelenskiy, a 41-year-old TV comic who's tapped into fury at the political class, will comfortably defeat incumbent Petro Poroshenko at a runoff on Sunday, according to opinion polls. "People are disillusioned with the old elite, which hasn't proved itself after the revolution," Yuriy Yakymenko, an analyst at the Razumkov Center for Economic and Political Studies in Kiev, said by phone. "Zelenskiy positioned himself as a populist politician opposed to the old authorities.

Lyft
Lyft's Fast-Slumping Stock Quickly Leads to Investor Lawsuits

For Lyft Inc., whose stock has tumbled sharply since its March 28 launch, it took less than three weeks for disillusioned shareholders to sue the company over claims they were taken for a ride. Such lawsuits are a rite of passage for newly public companies, and have become even more common after the 2008 financial crisis, according to Cornerstone Research. Lyft was accused in two nearly identical complaints filed April 16 of exaggerating in its prospectus when it said its U.S. market share was 39 percent.

N. Korea Says Bolton Comments on Third Summit Are Foolish: KCNA
N. Korea Says Bolton Comments on Third Summit Are Foolish: KCNA

"We never expected anything logical from Bolton, but as national security adviser, he should at least know the context of dialogue that took place between the two leaders regarding a third summit before he says anything," North Korea's Foreign Ministry diplomat Choi Sun Hee was quoted by the news agency as saying.

Butina Shouldn't Serve Any More Time in Prison, Her Lawyers Say
Butina Shouldn't Serve Any More Time in Prison, Her Lawyers Say

Attorneys for the 30-year-old Russian told U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington on Friday that she has spent more than nine months in detention and cooperated before and after her arrest and guilty plea. Butina arrived in Washington as an American University student in 2016 and made inroads with Republican Party figures, including Scott Walker, at the time the governor of Wisconsin, and officials at the National Rifle Association.

Venezuela
Venezuela's Guaido calls for 'largest march in history' to oust Maduro

Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido on Friday called on supporters to take to the streets on May 1 for what he called "the largest march in the history" of the South American country to keep the pressure on President Nicolas Maduro to leave power. Guaido, the head of the opposition-controlled National Assembly who in January invoked the constitution to assume an interim presidency on the basis that Maduro's 2018 re-election was illegitimate, reiterated his call for the country's armed forces to take his side in the three-month power struggle. "They will need to listen to the people saying: enough," Guaido told a crowd gathered at a plaza in eastern Caracas, setting the date for the...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Economy

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.