U.S. Supreme Court lets climate scientist's defamation claim proceed




  • In Science
  • 2019-11-25 14:45:19Z
  • By Reuters
FILE PHOTO: The U.S. Supreme Court is seen in Washington
FILE PHOTO: The U.S. Supreme Court is seen in Washington  

By Lawrence Hurley

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday allowed a prominent climate scientist to pursue a defamation lawsuit against a conservative magazine and a think tank that compared him to a convicted child molester.

The justices declined to hear appeals filed by National Review magazine and the Competitive Enterprise Institute seeking to overturn a lower court's ruling that allowed the lawsuit filed by scientist Michael Mann to go forward.

One justice, conservative Samuel Alito, dissented, writing that the case raised questions "that go to the very heart of the constitutional guarantee of freedom of speech and freedom of the press."

Mann, a Penn State professor known for his research on climate change, filed suit in a local court in the District of Columbia in 2012 after online posts by the magazine and think tank that compared him to convicted child molester Jerry Sandusky, a former assistant football coach at the same university in State College, Pennsylvania.

The lawsuit seeks unspecified monetary damages.

Mann over the years has clashed with groups and individuals who have sought to discredit his work. He is best known for what is called a "hockey stick" graph that showed an increase in global temperatures in the 20th century.

Scientific organizations rejected criticism of Mann's work after investigating the matter. Criticism of Mann by conservative climate change skeptics increased after some of his private emails were leaked in 2009.

The Competitive Enterprise Institute is a libertarian think tank that has said it "questions global warming alarmism." In a 2012 post published on a CEI website, former CEI fellow Rand Simberg compared the investigations into Mann with the then-recent national controversy over Sandusky, who was arrested in 2011 and convicted in 2012 of sexually molesting 10 young boys.

"Mann could be said to be the Jerry Sandusky of climate science, except for instead of molesting children, he has molested and tortured data," Simberg wrote.

In a later post on National Review's website, conservative writer Mark Steyn quoted from Simberg's article and referred to Mann's research as "fraudulent."

CEI later removed the Sandusky comparison. The National Review refused to retract its post and instead published a response from its editor Rich Lowry with the headline: "Get Lost."

Two different judges refused to dismiss Mann's lawsuit, prompting the defendants to appeal. The appeals court ruled in favor of Mann in 2016 and in March of this year the District of Columbia Court of Appeals declined to rehear the case.


(Reporting by Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham)

COMMENTS

More Related News

'See you in court': ACLU files nearly 400 cases versus Trump
  • World
  • 2020-08-06 12:00:22Z

The day after Donald Trump's election in November 2016, the American Civil Liberties Union posted a message to him on its website: "See you in court." As president, Trump hasn't personally squared off against the ACLU from the witness stand, but the broader warning has been borne out. As of this week, the ACLU has filed nearly 400 lawsuits and other legal actions against the Trump administration, some meeting with setbacks but many resulting in important victories.

Pence criticizes Chief Justice Roberts, says court
Pence criticizes Chief Justice Roberts, says court's future 'on the ballot in 2020'

The vice president criticized Chief Justice John Roberts after he sided against conservatives on several key cases, particularly one pertaining to abortion.

Japan
Japan's climate change efforts hindered by biased business lobby - study

Japan's powerful business lobby Keidanren is dominated by energy-intensive sectors that represent less than 10% of the economy, resulting in national policies that favour coal and hindering attempts to combat climate change, a new study said. The influence of the country's electricity, steel, cement, car and fossil fuel sectors undermines Japan's attempts to meet its Paris Agreement commitments, according to the report by London-based data analysis company InfluenceMap. The Keidanren, which has close ties with the trade and industry ministry as well as other government bodies, sits on expert panels and other forums where government policies are debated.

Fear of COVID-19 will not be reason to vote absentee in November, Tennessee Supreme Court rules
Fear of COVID-19 will not be reason to vote absentee in November, Tennessee Supreme Court rules

The Tennessee Supreme Court's decision reverses a Nashville judge's injunction that allowed any voter concerned about COVID-19 to vote by mail.

Editorial: Stronger hurricanes, worsened wildfires, record heat - the climate warnings march on
Editorial: Stronger hurricanes, worsened wildfires, record heat - the climate warnings march on

After a stifling hot July that saw 25 days of 90-degree-plus weather - breaking a record that stood for nearly a century and a half - August swept into Maryland with tornadoes and torrential rain from Tropical Storm Isaias. While severe weather is not a new phenomenon, experts warn that this pattern of stronger, wetter hurricanes and tropical storms, and longer stretches of high temperatures ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Science