U.S. Supreme Court divided over Kansas immigrant identity theft case




  • In US
  • 2019-10-16 16:28:51Z
  • By Reuters

By Andrew Chung

WASHINGTON, Oct 16 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday appeared divided over the legality of Kansas prosecuting three immigrants for violating identity theft laws by using other people's Social Security numbers in a dispute over whether the state impermissibly encroached on federal control over immigration policy.

The justices heard arguments in the state's appeal of a 2017 Kansas Supreme Court ruling that voided the convictions of three restaurant workers and found that a 1986 federal law, the Immigration Reform and Control Act, prevents states from pursuing such prosecutions.

The case tests how state criminal laws can be used against illegal immigrants and other people who do not have work authorization in the United States.

President Donald Trump's administration backed Kansas in the case. Trump has made his hardline policies toward immigration a centerpiece of his presidency and 2020 re-election campaign.

The court's four liberal justices as well as conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh, a Trump appointee, asked questions that voiced concern that the state's pursuit of these cases effectively gave it a way to go after unauthorized workers, a role reserved for the federal government.

Other conservative justices appeared inclined to accept that the state's prosecutions were not immigration-related. The court has a 5-4 conservative majority.

Kansas has said the lower court's ruling would undermine the state's ability to combat identity theft. But immigrant rights groups said giving states power to prosecute employment fraud would let them take immigration policy into their own hands. Kansas is one of several conservative-leaning states that have sought to crack down on illegal immigrants.

The three men - Ramiro Garcia, Donaldo Morales and Guadalupe Ochoa-Lara - were not authorized to work in the United States and provided their employers Social Security numbers that were not their own.

A Social Security number is primarily used to identify people for employment and tax purposes. People who enter the country illegally do not get assigned Social Security numbers, which are given by the U.S. government to all legal residents.

The case centers on the employment verification process under federal immigration law requiring employers, on a form known as the I-9, to attest that an employee is authorized to work. The law also states that the form "may not be used for purposes other than for enforcement of this act."

Lawyers for the three men said that the federal government has the sole authority to prosecute individuals for providing fraudulent information during the I-9 employment verification process. The state said the men were prosecuted for the same false information that was placed on different forms used to withhold wages for tax purposes.

The state said in court papers that if the Kansas Supreme Court ruling is allowed to stand, "unauthorized aliens would enjoy a favored status, with immunity from state prosecution for violating criminal statutes that apply to everyone else."

(Reporting by Andrew Chung; Editing by Will Dunham)

COMMENTS

More Related News

Trump Said No Tear Gas Used to Clear Protesters for Photo Op. These Canisters Suggest Otherwise.
Trump Said No Tear Gas Used to Clear Protesters for Photo Op. These Canisters Suggest Otherwise.

You really can believe your own eyes.A reporter from the Washington D.C. TV station WUSA 9 shared images on Twitter of tear gas canisters he and a colleague collected from near the White House on Monday-contradicting claims from the White House and U.S. Park Police that authorities did not deploy the weapon against peaceful protesters clear the way for President Donald Trump's photo-op.The photographs show spent CM Spede Heat CS and CM Skat Shell OC short-range rounds, both produced by the firm Defense Technology "as a crowd management tool for the rapid and broad deployment of chemical agent," as described on the company's website. While "OC" stands for oleoresin capsicum, a...

Trump Campaign Looks at Electoral Map and Doesn
Trump Campaign Looks at Electoral Map and Doesn't Like What It Sees

President Donald Trump is facing the bleakest outlook for his reelection bid so far, with his polling numbers plunging in both public and private surveys and his campaign beginning to worry about his standing in states like Ohio and Iowa that he carried by wide margins four years ago.The Trump campaign has recently undertaken a multimillion-dollar advertising effort in those two states as well as in Arizona in hopes of improving his standing while also shaking up his political operation and turning new attention to states like Georgia that were once considered reliably Republican. In private, Trump has expressed concern that his campaign is not battle-ready for the general election, while...

'I do not support invoking the Insurrection Act': Defense Secretary Esper breaks with Trump on use of troops

"The option to use active-duty forces in a law enforcement role should only be used as a matter of last resort," Esper said.

Trump says he went to White House bunker for
Trump says he went to White House bunker for 'inspection,' not because of protests

President Donald Trump denied reports that he was escorted to an underground bunker at White House because of security concerns amid violent protest.

Esper Says He Opposes Using Insurrection Act on Protesters
Esper Says He Opposes Using Insurrection Act on Protesters

Under intense criticism for seeming to give President Trump's violent response to institutional police racism the imprimatur of the military, Defense Secretary Mark Esper said he opposes using the active-duty military-even as an infantry battalion arrived outside Washington, D.C.The use of active-duty

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: US