U.S. appeals court hears arguments on stopping AT&T purchase of Time-Warner




  • In Business/Economy
  • 2018-12-06 18:04:24Z
  • By By Diane Bartz and David Shepardson
Coaxial TV Cables are seen in front of AT&T and Time Warner logos in this picture illustration
Coaxial TV Cables are seen in front of AT&T and Time Warner logos in this picture illustration  

By Diane Bartz and David Shepardson

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A three-judge appeals court panel on Thursday questioned the U.S. Justice Department's challenge to a lower court approval's of AT&T Inc's $85.4 billion acquisition of Time Warner.

"Where is the clear error?" U.S. Judge Judith Rogers asked Justice Department attorney Mike Murray, who called the lower court's approval of the deal "myopic."

"You have to show that there's a harm to competition," Judge David Sentelle said at another point. "Remember where the burdens are," he added later.

Much of the argument at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia delved into whether a lower court judge, U.S. District Judge Richard Leon, properly treated economic models of the merger's impact on future prices for pay-TV customers.

The core of the Justice Department's concern has been that AT&T, which owns DirecTV, would use ownership of Time Warner's content, such as CNN and HBO's "Game of Thrones," to make pay-TV rivals pay more, thus forcing them to charge consumers more.

The deal was significant for two other reasons. First, President Donald Trump, who has famously tangled with Time Warner's CNN, has vociferously opposed the deal. Second, it is a rare instance of the government seeking to stop a merger of a distributor and a supplier.

Much of the argument focused on how AT&T, which owns DirecTV, would use the threat of withholding Time Warner's Turner content, including CNN, in licensing disputes with rival pay TV companies. The government had argued that the threat of a blackout, withholding the content, would force the smaller companies to pay more, thus raising prices for consumers.

AT&T lawyer Peter Keisler cast doubt on this economic model but faced questions over an arbitration offer that AT&T made to smaller pay-TV companies, pledging that it would not black out Time Warner's Turner content for seven years. "Of course, we will honor it," he said.

The Justice Department's Murray said the offer was "too little, too late." He said the smaller pay-TV companies worried that it was inadequate to protect them.

The government is asking for the lower court case to be reversed and remanded.

The merger, which was announced in October 2016, closed on June 14 shortly after Leon ruled the deal was legal under antitrust law.

AT&T, the No. 2 U.S. wireless carrier by subscribers, agreed in June to manage Time Warner's Turner networks separately from DirecTV, including setting prices and managing personnel, until February 2019 or the conclusion of the government's appeal.

The deal was seen as a turning point for a media industry that has been upended by companies like Netflix Inc and Alphabet Inc's Google which produce content and sell it online directly to consumers, without requiring a pricey cable subscription.


(Reporting by Diane Bartz; editing by Jonathan Oatis)

COMMENTS

More Related News

Mueller report not coming next week: senior U.S. Justice official
Mueller report not coming next week: senior U.S. Justice official

"Any reports that the Special Counsel's report will be delivered to the DOJ (Department of Justice) during the week of Feb. 28 are incorrect," the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity. The 21-month Mueller investigation, also focused on possible obstruction of justice, has been a dark cloud over Donald Trump's presidency, with reports of its conclusion being imminent appearing frequently in recent weeks. CNN reported on Wednesday that the Justice Department may announce as early as next week that Mueller had given his report to Attorney General William Barr and that Barr would review the findings and submit a summary to Congress.

AP source: Mueller report not expected next week
AP source: Mueller report not expected next week

Special counsel Robert Mueller's report on the Russia investigation is not expected to be delivered to the Justice Department next week, a senior department official told The Associated Press on Friday. It was not immediately clear when the report might come, though Mueller is showing signs of concluding

Ex-FBI deputy: Rosenstein cited two people who might have pursued Trump ouster
Ex-FBI deputy: Rosenstein cited two people who might have pursued Trump ouster

McCabe, speaking to reporters to promote his book "The Threat: How the FBI Protects America in the Age of Terrorism and Trump," said he could not recall which two Cabinet members Rosenstein mentioned without access to memos of the 2017 conversation. "I at no time got the impression that he had actually sought support or talked to those people about it," McCabe said. "It was simply Rod thinking off the top of his head - this is a thing that could be done." In September the New York Times reported that John Kelly, who served as Trump's chief of staff, and Jeff Sessions, who Trump dismissed as attorney general, might be persuaded to invoke the 25th Amendment.

Justice Department Said to Expect Mueller Report as Early as Next Week
Justice Department Said to Expect Mueller Report as Early as Next Week

The Justice Department is expecting Special Counsel Robert Mueller to issue the final report on his investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016 election as early as next week, multiple outlets reported Wednesday.Mueller is required to submit a "confidential" report to the Justice Department, which is under no obligation to share it with Congress or the public, although Attorney General Bill Barr must brief Congress on its contents. Barr has said he wants to be as "transparent" as possible and "consistent with the rules and the law" in sharing the Mueller report.President Trump said he would leave it up to the attorney general as to whether the report is...

Former FBI Chief McCabe Urges Mueller Report Be Widely Released
Former FBI Chief McCabe Urges Mueller Report Be Widely Released

"I think that report should be shared immediately with Congress, and I think it should be shared as broadly as possible with the American public," McCabe said in an interview on MSNBC's "Morning Joe" program Wednesday. Mueller is due to submit conclusions explaining his decisions to prosecute or decline filing charges to new Attorney General William Barr, who was sworn in last week. Barr will decide what to do with that information.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Economy

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.