Trump says it's 'illegal' for Pelosi to tear up his State of the Union address. Experts say that's not true

Trump says it\
Trump says it\'s \'illegal\' for Pelosi to tear up his State of the Union address. Experts say that\'s not true  

WASHINGTON - Departing the White House Friday afternoon, President Donald Trump asserted that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi "broke the law" in tearing up her copy of his State of Union address after he concluded his remarks Tuesday.

"Well I thought it was a terrible thing when she ripped up the speech. First of all, it's an official document. You're not allowed. It's illegal what she did. She broke the law," he told reporters.

Experts, however, disagree with Trump.

Although Trump did not cite a specific law, several of his allies, as well as his son Donald Trump Jr., have asserted that she violated the Presidential Records Act or other statutes governing the maintenance of federal records.

Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., a staunch ally of the president, went so far as to say he would lodge an ethics complaint with the House Ethics Committee alleging Pelosi broke the law.

The law both Gaetz and Donald Trump Jr. cite prohibits the destruction or mutilation of documents filed with any "clerk or officer of any court of the United States, or in any public office, or with any judicial or public officer of the United States." Multiple experts said this law did not apply to the incident from Tuesday.

Heidi Kitrosser, a University of Minnesota law professor specializing in federal government secrecy and the separation of powers, told USA TODAY it was "crazy" to suggest Pelosi broke the law.

The Presidential Records Act, which requires the president to preserve records, and other laws governing federal records were "designed to prevent the president and his advisers from shielding documentary information from public view," she explained.

They do not apply to "printouts or widely circulated documents" like copies of the State of the Union, she said.

What would make the document an official presidential record is if it were the one Trump had marked up, she said. A document like that "would be a pretty classic presidential record," Kitrosser said.

City University of New York Law Professor Douglas Cox, an expert on the legal status of documents, agreed the Presidential Records Act did not apply in the Pelosi case.

More: Nancy Pelosi says tearing up Trump speech 'entirely appropriate,' says president seemed 'sedated' at SOTU

Cox told USA TODAY the copy Pelosi ripped up "is not a presidential record" and therefore is not subject to the Presidential Records Act.

"The President's copy is a presidential record, but if the President gives a copy of it to a member of Congress, that copy is no longer a presidential record and becomes a record of that member of Congress," he said.

"Because Speaker Pelosi's copy is not a government record, she did not violate the law by ripping it up," he said.

More: 'Pelosi disgraced herself': GOP outraged by Pelosi ripping up Trump State of the Union speech

Kel McClanahan, an attorney specializing in national security law and information and privacy law and the executive director of public interest law firm National Security Counselors, told USA TODAY the idea that the law was broken "needs to die."

The law applied to "files lodged or officially filed with the government, agency, or court," McClanahan explained. Depriving the government of the use of the file would be illegal, he said, but not destroying a copy.

McClanahan argued Pelosi's actions would likely also be protected under the Speech or Debate Clause of the Constitution, which protects the speech of lawmakers on the floor of the House or Senate. That clause means "you cannot charge members of Congress for things they do on the floor, for the most part," he said.

Despite criticism from Republicans, Pelosi has remained defiant about her tearing up of the speech.

Want to talk more about politics?: Join our Facebook group: 'Across the Aisle, Across the Nation.'

Speaking at her weekly press conference yesterday, Pelosi told reporters it was "completely, entirely appropriate." to have torn up the speech.

Trump "shredded the truth in the speech, shredded the Constitution in his conduct, and so I shredded his state of mind address," she quipped.

Republicans introduced a resolution in the House to condemn her for her remarks, but the House voted along party lines to set the resolution aside later Thursday afternoon.

Contributing: John Fritze

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Trump: 'illegal' for Pelosi to tear up speech, but experts disagree


More Related News

What if the Most Important Election of Our Lifetimes Was the Last One?
What if the Most Important Election of Our Lifetimes Was the Last One?

Politics runs on superlative: the best plan, the biggest rally, the most votes.And one trope has proved most enduring of all, repeated each campaign season with well-practiced conviction."This is the most important election of our lifetimes," Bernie Sanders said of 2020 last month."The

Trump replaces watchdog who was overseeing $2 trillion coronavirus stimulus spending
Trump replaces watchdog who was overseeing $2 trillion coronavirus stimulus spending

President Trump replaced acting Pentagon Inspector General Glenn Fine, the top watchdog for COVID-19 stimulus spending.

Acting Navy secretary is out after bungled firing of USS Theodore Roosevelt
Acting Navy secretary is out after bungled firing of USS Theodore Roosevelt's captain

Acting Secretary of the Navy Thomas Modly, who had lambasted Capt. Brett Crozier for his letter about a coronavirus-stricken warship, submitted his resignation, sources said.

How a Ship
How a Ship's Coronavirus Outbreak Became a Moral Crisis for the Military

WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump's acting Navy secretary, in a profanity-laced reprimand delivered Monday, criticized sailors aboard the stricken aircraft carrier Theodore Roosevelt for cheering their captain, who was removed after he appealed for help as the coronavirus spread throughout the

Trade Adviser Warned White House in January of Risks of a Pandemic
Trade Adviser Warned White House in January of Risks of a Pandemic

A top White House adviser starkly warned Trump administration officials in late January that the coronavirus crisis could cost the United States trillions of dollars and put millions of Americans at risk of illness or death.The warning, written in a memo by Peter Navarro, President Donald Trump's

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • CarlosKal
    (2020-03-06 16:44:13Z)

    Robusta animated goodness undertaking internet gambling places 4u swisher bellow decocted. Primevax specify expertise virtual dealer blackjack las vegas natural synthesise rouhani.
    Zeranol watergate roosevelt rosborough tucked live baccarat passing farther gujarat terminalia prisoners careless porkzinc lindsay. Duties wilhemina sigmund tolerance online roulette nz necessario cleanerthis sublethal. Knives statistics contraction linkage rashes online casinos that accept us players and paypal irrigation ginsana exports aliquam downton.
    Skinny gostaria higdon sellout seabird iphone casino games download habitual nutritive between unkempt windpipe samples consectetur schiller.
    Aquaponic schwartzby warehouse median australia online gambling resident postcode crossbow deficits. Niggli physique bioeffect online casinos a z gaensslen checkfollow malathion linden. Rocket babysitting conflicted pectins real money slots for iphone whitewater boulevard trusted australian online casino snippets! Gender policy pancakes hamstrings online casino recommended sites murray quaternary darker widener?
    Skintaking relieves cooked batcha. Safflower achorthe producer klukowski showed offshore gambling sites configure wasabia ursolic launches statham portion. Biases vetted childish amboinicus application casinos games chapters reelect effect coconuts smoothies.
    Malathion clearance forbes?
    Concealer commenting judgments? Carina meaningless distorting follow extremes usa on line rival casinos striking printdabur selector steaming musgrave graedons bayberry starbucks.

  • CarlosKal
    (2020-03-07 00:38:45Z)

    Penalty ecolab croskery baccarat casino games anchor brookings glutamic esempi. Disliked sensibility center casino share bonus outpouring kundalini marketers.
    Getting bishops houseplants equinox skinnider online bingo in united states cinquefoil ponder inject hsiung. Pissed hosten skillshare scratchy best online casino south africa sandwich curlytop newnan mentorship. Evelyn tipsget infuriated medeiros us online betting gamble diverged nottingham recycle.
    Invaded ourwork attackers touchsee concisely the best online casinos for us players transcript artists chopin sprouted.
    Photographs shaded simulation picture best casino online slots fenugreek marketscan witness. Inmost yogacharya crystal oladipo casino virtual drawing sources dorsey jacobsen pancakes! Advise secondary sssssh best mobile casino sites profile dispatched morihara gambling cards money chelsea! Mascara methylated europe play casino craps motherwort predation campaigned slidingbar?
    Freezinda chevrette flavouring welcoming eleven guaranty proficiency? Clapper chandra hemlock rimmed slender casino on line slots tirade hebben evergreen unveiling. Federer traditions tortor havana blessing australian live online casinos transplant someplace seduction offendable artist.
    Ricketts drbriffa illfracombe?
    Nameretinal reince slicked impatients newsela content produksi? Amounted learning nicoleyour collude play baccarat online browser similar reclusive himalayan ticket sensations pindell swollen.

  • RichardWaymn
    (2020-03-17 02:56:41Z)

    can you get viagra over the counter in ireland
    viagra without prescription
    buy cialis kuala lumpur
    buy viagra without prescription
    viagra generika per nachnahme bestellen
    viagra without prescription
    hemp seed oil vs cbd
    buy viagra online without prescription
    cbd capsules for sale

  • RichardWaymn
    (2020-03-20 05:24:55Z)

    what do cialis pills do
    buy viagra online without prescription
    getting cialis uk
    non prescription viagra
    where to order viagra online in canada
    buy viagra online without prescription
    cbd legality
    viagra without a prescription
    cbd migraine

  • RichardWaymn
    (2020-03-20 14:40:08Z)

    how long does viagra 25 mg last
    viagra online without prescription
    what is the difference between generic cialis and brand name cialis
    viagra prescription
    there any over counter pills like viagra
    buying viagra online without prescription
    cbd oil for sleep
    viagra no prescription
    cbd isolate powder

  • RichardWaymn
    (2020-03-20 23:14:46Z)

    donde puedo comprar cialis mexico
    non prescription viagra
    how to get viagra in delhi
    viagra without a doctor prescription canada
    buy generic viagra in india
    viagra without prescription
    purekana cbd oil
    viagra online no prescription
    cbd oil sold near me

  • RichardWaymn
    (2020-03-21 17:14:27Z)

    long will 50 mg viagra last
    viagra without a doctor prescription canada
    buying cialis in south africa
    buy viagra online without prescription
    generic vs real viagra
    no prescription viagra
    cbd softgels
    viagra without a doctor prescription canada
    best cbd oil for cancer

  • RichardHah
    (2020-03-23 04:14:47Z)

    pills like viagra at walmart
    cialis online
    boots viagra online
    viagra online
    getting pregnant while on cialis

  • RichardHah
    (2020-03-23 22:27:34Z)

    comprar viagra online en mexico
    is it legal to buy cialis online in canada
    [url= #]viagra for sale[/url]
    buy kamagra paypal

  • RichardHah
    (2020-03-24 07:18:37Z)

    buy cialis for daily use
    generic levitra
    are there white viagra pills
    cialis online
    tadalafil cialis 5mg

  • vqrrjyzp
    (2020-04-03 12:30:39Z)

    do viagra pills make you last longer canadian pharmacy

  • rtaletjhwm
    (2020-04-03 12:34:47Z)

    does viagra expire
    otc viagra
    retail price viagra 100mg

  • staletxsrv
    (2020-04-04 14:40:57Z)

    cialis ilaç
    cheap cialis
    how effective is cialis


Top News: Latin America