Trump Labor Board Appointee Is Probed by DOJ Over Ethics Allegations

  • In Business
  • 2021-08-26 22:46:17Z
  • By Bloomberg

(Bloomberg Law) -- National Labor Relations Board member William Emanuel, who was appointed by former President Donald Trump, recently was interviewed by the U.S. Justice Department over allegations from the NLRB inspector general that he participated in five labor law cases involving a company or companies in which he owned stock, according to eight sources briefed on the matter.

U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland declined to prosecute Emanuel, whose term on the NLRB expires Friday, said three of the sources, most of whom spoke on condition of anonymity because they didn't have approval to disclose private conversations.

The decision punted the matter back to the federal labor board, which is now determining how to handle four prior rulings in which NLRB Inspector General David Berry has determined that Emanuel had a conflict of interest that should've prompted him to recuse himself, according to one of the sources. A fifth case flagged by Berry hasn't been decided and remains pending before the board.

Although the significance of the allegations will hinge on which cases are affected, the investigation could reignite an ethics saga that's pitted Trump's Republican board appointees against unions and Democrats. This latest chapter comes two days before Democrats take control of the NLRB; President Joe Biden appointed two new members, both of whom have a background as union-side attorneys.

The type of investment or any individual company or companies involved wasn't immediately known. It also wasn't immediately clear which cases Berry said may have been compromised.

The NLRB has a five-member panel that adjudicates disputes involving union organizing and collective bargaining law, including accusations of businesses interfering with workers' rights.

Emanuel and DOJ didn't immediately respond to requests for comment. An NLRB spokeswoman declined to comment. Berry, the inspector general, when reached by phone said he couldn't confirm or deny any open investigations.

A 'Vindictive Response'

Emanuel, who has served on the board since 2017, came under scrutiny early in his tenure for participating in a landmark case linked to his former law firm, Littler Mendelson. In that case, Hy-Brand Industrial Contractors, the board invalidated its decision because of Emanuel's involvement, nullifying a decision that loosened the standard by which employers could be held legally liable for labor violations by franchisees and contractors.

The NLRB last year released a rule that achieved largely the same result, after a lengthy process prompted by Emanuel's perceived conflict of interest in the case.

Berry in 2018 released a scathing report on a "serious and flagrant" problem with the board's ethics procedures, in that members can participate in decisions that indirectly help former clients, as long as the client isn't a party in the case. Some labor lawyers disagreed with Berry's analysis, saying it would prevent qualified lawyers from serving on the board, but it's provided ammunition for Democratic lawmakers, including Sen. Elizabeth Warren (Mass.), who called on Emanuel to resign in 2018.

Roger King, a senior labor and employment counsel at the HR Policy Association, said he'd discussed with Emanuel the watchdog's allegations.

"This appears to be a vindictive response from the inspector general and the ethics officer, given their previously rejected attempt to impeach member Emanuel's ethics credibility on the joint employer issue," said King, who is friends with Emanuel. "At best, this is a highly technical matter involving an investment decision made by Member Emanuel's financial adviser, unbeknownst to him. When it was brought to member Emanuel's attention he immediately corrected it."

In 2019, then-Chair John Ring, a Republican who remains on the board, released a revised ethics policy that gave members authority to insist on participating in cases, even when internal ethics officials determine they may have a conflict of interest.

Ring said last year he would ask DOJ to review the ethics reforms in response to confusion over the role of the Office of Government Ethics in adjudicating disputes. Ring didn't transmit the request to DOJ's Office of Legal Counsel until Jan. 19, 2021, his last day as chairman.

-With assistance from Josh Eidelson (Bloomberg News)

To contact the reporters on this story: Ben Penn in Washington at bpenn@bloomberglaw.com; Ian Kullgren in Washington at ikullgren@bloombergindustry.com

To contact the editors responsible for this story: John Lauinger at jlauinger@bloomberglaw.com; Martha Mueller Neff at mmuellerneff@bloomberglaw.com

(Updated with additional reporting throughout.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

Subscribe now to stay ahead with the most trusted business news source.

©2021 Bloomberg L.P.


More Related News

Former Pennsylvania senator behind Biden
Former Pennsylvania senator behind Biden 'Making the Taliban Great Again' billboards

Former Republican state Sen. Scott Wagner was upset at President Joe Biden for the withdrawal from Afghanistan and used billboards for his grievances.

Biden $3.5T plan tests voter appeal of expansive gov
Biden $3.5T plan tests voter appeal of expansive gov't role

President Joe Biden's "build back better" agenda is poised to be the most far-reaching federal investment since FDR's New Deal or LBJ's Great Society - a...

GOP online donation platform tweaks fees, sending millions more to midterm campaigns
GOP online donation platform tweaks fees, sending millions more to midterm campaigns

WinRed, the widely used Republican online donation service, will lower its fees in January after negotiations with party leaders.

Pentagon defends Milley
Pentagon defends Milley's calls to top Chinese general in final months of Trump presidency, saying such calls are vital to avoiding conflict

The White House downplayed reports about Milley and said that President Biden has "complete confidence" in the general.

Pennsylvania Republicans subpoena detailed voter info in 2020 election probe
Pennsylvania Republicans subpoena detailed voter info in 2020 election probe
  • US
  • 2021-09-15 16:54:30Z

Republican lawmakers in Pennsylvania voted on Wednesday to subpoena the state's top election official in a review that joins widely criticized efforts in...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • RobertTew
    (2021-08-27 02:27:14Z)

    Forum von jaxx cruising kino und gaykino220 einträgen

  • studybayws
    (2021-08-27 04:07:02Z)


    Crossword puzzles on the research paper .

    Order NOW!!! ==> https://essaypro.co

    Fast food cashier duties for resume
    Microarray pdf phd thesis
    Inferences between men and women essay full auth4 filmbay yn1ii qj html

    Essential elements of writing a good business plan
    Best homework writer sites online
    Cheap personal statement ghostwriter sites online

    Custom creative essay ghostwriter sites for university
    Best scholarship essay ghostwriter site online
    How to write hao in chinese

    Proposal format for dissertation lmnqm
    Marketing project manager resume samples jxouf
    Introduction to sociology essay exam questions qunrg
    Esl term paper writing websites us
    Darden mba essays 2010
    Book report the hitchhikers guide to the galaxy
    Dissertation introduction editing websites online


    Crossword puzzles on the research paper
    Custom thesis statement ghostwriters site au
    Answer maths homework
    How to write financial aid letter

    Dissertation introduction editor services us
    Best college dissertation advice ugpsh 2021
    Cheap dissertation ghostwriting websites au xqfox
    Corba resume san diego security clearance vfxye
    Literary analysis papers awakening qitin

    a dissertation abstract

    Crossword puzzles on the research paper
    Sample writing in apa format owvtq 2021
    Business plan with financial projections mhets
    How to write a pr biography fnfwn 2021
    Evelyn glennie deaf essay - Middle school business plan vwsas 2021


    Rap lyric help writing
    Buy business plan pro 2008
    How to write a cover sheet for a research paper

    автор24 официальный сайт


    How to list peace corps experience on a resume
    Holmes essay
    Job cover letter vocabulary


    Crossword puzzles on the research paper

    Resume no college experience - Resume download vista ylnhj 2021
    College confidential rice essay
    Best university bibliography topics vmoap 2021
    Do my academic essay on donald trump yivkz 2021

    Crossword puzzles on the research paper
    Cheap paper writer for hire for school pmkyy 2021
    Essay writing on summer season in hindi drwds 2021
    How to write a congratulations card dplaz
    Cover letter for finance manager tefcf 2021

    Computer science resume buzzwords
    Write a code for fibonacci series
    Essay future of adult education

    Crossword puzzles on the research paper
    Thesis topics on civil engineering plonh
    How to write introductory letter of a company fcnws
    Why did jodi picoult write my sisters keeper
    Type my algebra essay ezuvt 2021
    Resume de candide court - Pay for my best custom essay on pokemon go mjzwp 2021
    Professional book review writing for hire usa

  • DavidSnita
    (2021-08-28 19:07:12Z)

    Hello guys. And Bye.

    neversurrender ;)

  • DavidSnita
    (2021-08-28 19:36:14Z)

    Hello guys. And Bye.

    neversurrender ;)


Top News: Business