Trump and Netanyahu make me fear for a two-state solution and Middle East peace




Trump and Netanyahu make me fear for a two-state solution and Middle East peace
Trump and Netanyahu make me fear for a two-state solution and Middle East peace  

I have been an American Jewish activist and ardent supporter of Israel for over 40 years, and never has the outcome of an Israeli election worried me as much as this one. Just three days before election day, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made an eleventh-hour appeal to his right-wing base by explicitly committing to pursue annexation of West Bank territory after the elections. Such a policy is liable to definitively close the door on a negotiated two-state solution and Israel's future as a Jewish and democratic state. Now the Israeli electorate has spoken, and Netanyahu appears poised to lead Israel's next government.

Meanwhile, the Trump administration continues to talk up a peace plan while simultaneously emboldening the annexation movement in Israel. While we do not yet know the specifics of the Trump plan, the substance and the timing of Netanyahu's remarks suggest that whatever the White House puts forth may be compatible with some aspects of annexation.

Read more commentary:

I saw firsthand how West Bank Palestinians are treated like prisoners. Who will fix this?

25 years ago, Mideast peace seemed inevitable. Now it's further away than ever.

You can critique Israel without sounding anti-Semitic. Rep. Ilhan Omar should learn how.

Netanyahu's explicit commitment to annex parts of the West Bank is significant. Although Netanyahu had never been an enthusiastic two-stater, he has tolerated rising support for annexation in his own party and has now fully embraced that policy. With pending indictments in three corruption and bribery cases, Netanyahu may well give in to annexationist demands from right-wing coalition partners in exchange for legislation insulating him from prosecution while in office.

Trump could make GOP party of annexation

The Trump administration appears to be working in tandem with the Israeli right, and could accede to Israel's annexationists. At every juncture, the administration has remained silent as annexation has moved from the ideological extremes to the top of the political agenda in Israel. When the Likud Central Committee voted in 2017 to endorse Israeli sovereignty over the country's West Bank settlements, the White House was conspicuously silent. When multiple political parties campaigned on annexation in the recent election cycle, there were no expressions of concern. Just this week, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo refused to tell senators if the White House opposes Netanyahu's annexation pledge.

At the recent AIPAC policy conference in Washington, U.S. Ambassador David Friedman stated that Israeli-Palestinian peace cannot be left to "[a future American] administration that may not understand the need for Israel to maintain overriding security control in Judea and Samaria." In other words, perpetual Israeli control of the West Bank now has the blessing of a top administration official.

There is simply no reason to believe that the Trump peace plan, if ever released, will adhere to the parameters of two states for two peoples. And indeed, the Republican Party may well become the party of West Bank annexation. This outcome has its roots in 2016, when the GOP eliminated any mention of two states from its platform for the first time. As Republicans exploit Israel as a wedge issue in American politics, many of them will eagerly cast those who do not support annexation as insufficiently pro-Israel, if not anti-Semitic - thereby hastening the erosion of bipartisan support for Israel.

Israel is moving away from shared values

How the Democrats react will also have lasting consequences for U.S.-Israel ties. We have already seen how Democrats have struggled to handle Israel-related challenges from two extreme left members of Congress who have questioned the very basis of U.S. support for Israel. Meanwhile, several 2020 Democratic candidates have weighed in on disturbing trends with more measured critiques of Israeli policy. Elizabeth Warren has admonished Netanyahu for corruption and mainstreaming followers of the late extremist Rabbi Meir Kahane. Bernie Sanders also decried Netanyahu's alliance with the racist faction, and Pete Buttigieg criticized annexation as damaging to Israeli, Palestinian and American interests.

But all of this precedes any legislative moves in the Israeli Knesset on annexation, which would formalize a single-state reality across Israel and the West Bank and make it impossible for Israel to remain both Jewish and democratic. For American Jews, who vote overwhelmingly Democratic, any abandonment of the two-state paradigm will force difficult questions about how to continue to support an Israel that is moving away dramatically from the shared values that have always linked our two communities. Those challenges include defending Israel's seeming perpetual occupation of Palestinian lands and its exertion of ongoing control over the lives of 2.7 million Palestinians.

Bipartisan American support for Israel, Diaspora-Israel ties and the US-Israel strategic relationship are vital to Israel's future. All of these will be seriously jeopardized by any form of annexation, and Israelis, Palestinians, American Jews, and the U.S.-Israel relationship will suffer as a result.

Susie Gelman is board chair of the non-partisan Israel Policy Forum, which supports a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

You can read diverse opinions from our Board of Contributors and other writers on the Opinion front page, on Twitter @usatodayopinion and in our daily Opinion newsletter. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters@usatoday.com.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Trump and Netanyahu make me fear for a two-state solution and Middle East peace

COMMENTS

More Related News

Israeli crews demolish Palestinian homes in major operation in east Jerusalem
Israeli crews demolish Palestinian homes in major operation in east Jerusalem

Israel demolished a number of Palestinian homes it considers illegal south of Jerusalem early Monday, in a move which has drawn international concern. The Palestinians immediately slammed the demolitions in the Sur Baher area which straddles the West Bank and Jerusalem, but Israel defended the move as essential to its security. Before dawn, hundreds of Israeli police and soldiers sealed off buildings in the area close to the Israeli security barrier which cuts off the occupied West Bank, an AFP journalist said. Residents and activists were dragged out of the homes, many of which were still under construction. Earthmovers then demolished at least three multi-story buildings, the journalist...

Dubya Was Bad, but the Donald Might Be Worse: Richard Clarke
Dubya Was Bad, but the Donald Might Be Worse: Richard Clarke
  • World
  • 2019-07-22 08:55:17Z

Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast/GettyFormer White House counter-terrorism czar Richard A. Clarke, who worked directly under three presidents during his 30 years in government, still believes his ex-boss George W. Bush was the worst of them all.Yet Clarke-whose new book, The Fifth Domain, chronicles the dire threats to the United States posed by cyberwarfare-says Donald Trump is very likely, in the end, to wreak even more havoc "He's eviscerating the government.  He's eviscerating capabilities that we need," Clarke told The Daily Beast this week as the Los Angeles Times reported that the Trump administration had "gutted programs aimed at detecting weapons of mass...

Europe Plans to Use the U.S. Election to Beat Trump
Europe Plans to Use the U.S. Election to Beat Trump's Trade War

(Bloomberg) -- Terms of Trade is a daily newsletter that untangles a world embroiled in trade wars. Sign up here. The European Union is legendary for moving slowly -- and that may be just the right pace for confronting President Donald Trump's trade wars.While the daunting threat of U.S. tariffs on Europe

Israel demolishes Palestinian homes in Jerusalem area: AFP
Israel demolishes Palestinian homes in Jerusalem area: AFP

Israel began demolishing a number of Palestinian homes it considers illegal south of Jerusalem early Monday, an AFP journalist said, in a move which has drawn international concern. Dozens of Israeli police and military sealed off at least four buildings in the Sur Baher area close to the Israeli security barrier cutting off the occupied West Bank early Monday, the journalist said. Reporters were prevented from reaching the area while residents and activists were dragged out of the homes.

Millions of Barrels of Iranian Oil Are Piled Up in China
Millions of Barrels of Iranian Oil Are Piled Up in China's Ports

(Bloomberg) -- Tankers are offloading millions of barrels of Iranian oil into storage tanks at Chinese ports, creating a hoard of crude sitting on the doorstep of the world's biggest buyer.Two and a half months after the White House banned the purchase of Iran's oil, the nation's crude is continuing

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Latin America

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.