The 'pro-union' president risks the support of a key constituency to avert a rail strike

  • In Politics
  • 2022-12-03 16:49:07Z
  • By NBC News

Early in the week, Joe Biden gave a speech in Michigan and described himself as an unabashed champion of organized labor, a "pro-union" president through and through.

Now Biden faces a backlash from a core of rail workers and allied groups, as some of them see a betrayal in the bill he pushed to avert a rail strike.

He signed the measure, which passed with bipartisan support, at the White House on Friday, giving rail workers a significant raise, but denying them the paid sick leave that had been a sticking point in some of the contract talks. Hours later, he arrived at the John F. Kennedy Library in Boston and was met by scores of protesters objecting to his handling of a labor dispute that threatened to halt rail service at the peak of the holiday season.

Biden might be willing to tolerate the anger in the hope that it fizzles out before he has to face voters again. And it may be better for him than the alternative - an economic calamity that could have enraged voters across the country and worsened inflation.

Supporters argue Biden's decisive action may be a net positive, proof that he's willing to do what is best for the nation, even if it upsets some members of a key constituency.

The standoff between rail workers and the profitable companies that employ them posed an awkward dilemma for Biden, forcing him to find an elusive middle ground between dueling campaign pledges.

He has promised to be a friend to a labor movement that he says created the American middle class. But he has also vowed to build on the post-pandemic economic recovery and strive for bipartisan compromise. A rail strike threatened to unravel the job gains that no doubt will be central to any Biden re-election campaign.

"If Joe Biden wants to be the most pro-labor president, or wants to deem himself a labor supporter, he's got to stand with labor through thick and thin, when it's complicated and when it's not," said Tony Cardwell, president of the BMWED, one of the four unions that voted against the deal with the rail companies (eight others voted for the contract). "We're asking for something that most Americans have."

At the bill signing ceremony, Biden sounded torn. He said he is not giving up on paid sick leave for rail workers and other Americans who don't receive such benefits. But he made it clear that he was not prepared to see freight trains stopped and food, water, clothing and holiday gifts stranded in empty depots. Lawmakers faced a tough vote, he said, adding it was "a tough [vote] for me. But it was the right thing to do at the moment to save jobs. …"

Still, the president could have used more leverage to reach a deal that included paid sick leave, union officials and allies contend.

"I'm disappointed that he [Biden] wielded his power against workers," said Erin Hatton, a sociology professor at the University of Buffalo, who specializes in labor markets."He pitted workers against the economy. But workers are the economy.

"Biden has run on a pro-labor platform from the beginning and this, in my view, makes it impossible for him to do so in the future," she said.

Other unions worry that the rail dispute could further weaken the hand of the nation's labor movement, or sap its recent momentum - potentially giving industry new avenues to win future concessions.

Sara Nelson, the president of the Association of Flight Attendants union, which also bargains under the same labor laws as rail workers, said that the move to preempt the strike could potentially hamper her workers as well, many of whom are in the midst of negotiating with the major airlines.

"This was a direct attack on the right to strike for the people I represent," she said. "The message they're sending is that they are siding with bosses whether they intend it or not. Fair collective bargaining includes the right to strike, so everyone has something to lose."

White House economics official Celeste Drake defended the move to avert the strike.

"President Biden utilized the full weight of his administration to support rail union members in their work to negotiate improved wages, benefits and working conditions in an agreement that earned support from a majority of rail worker unions," she said. He's proud of his record as a pro-union president and will continue fighting to deliver paid sick leave, dignity at work and other wins for working Americans."

Pragmatic-minded Democrats and other union supporters said Biden displayed an important quality through the rail saga: flexibility. He campaigned on unifying the country and reaching bipartisan solutions - something that's especially tough to do given that most legislation needs a 60 vote supermajority to pass the Senate, meaning at least 10 Republicans have to join the Democrats.

"What the American people saw the president do was make an extremely difficult choice that he knew was going to upset a group of supporters, and one of the groups that he cares most about personally, because he thought it was the right thing to do, and the right thing to do for our economy," said Seth Harris, a former top Biden adviser on labor.

Cleveland conductor Dan Banks, 43, a member of one of the unions that voted down the deal, said he had hoped for paid sick days but didn't blame Biden for the setback.

He believed the president had pushed hard for a resolution with the understanding that rail workers would have faced a worse outcome if the negotiations stretched into January, with Republicans set to take over the House in 2023.

"Biden made sure we got what was available to us," he said.

Biden has worked to make good on the vow to be the most pro-labor president in memory, earning early applause from labor activists and economists pushing for a more robust role for unions. He made waves by releasing a video early in his presidency supporting Amazon workers organizing in Alabama and warning the company about anti-union activity. And he has installed a set of largely pro-labor voices in key positions at the Department of Labor and the National Labor Relations Board.

But some of the more ambitious parts of his agenda, such as passing the Pro Act to update the country's dated labor laws and expanding paid leave, have sputtered in a closely divided Congress with its own arcane set of voting rules.

These tensions came to a head as rail negotiations soured in the past six months. A Senate bill that would have guaranteed seven days of paid sick leave for workers received 52 votes on Thursday, falling short of the 60-vote threshold needed for passage.

From the start of the talks between the White House and rail unions in the contract dispute, there was concern about how at least 10 Republicans could be persuaded to support a pro-labor deal if negotiations failed, one person with knowledge of the nearly year-long discussions said.

"If they could not reach an agreement with the rail companies, how would unions get to 60 on agreement in Congress?" the person said. "That's where they ended up and they couldn't. None of this was a surprise to anyone involved in the process."

Still, some saw the White House taking the sides of industry leaders - who had warned about the economic consequences of a strike for months - over working men and women on the rails.

"The president was in a hard place, trying to maintain safe supply chains and get people their Christmas presents," said Faiz Shakir, an adviser to Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, "but what workers have felt for the past few decades is they're always getting the shaft."

This article was originally published on


More Related News

Explainer-When is the State of the Union 2023? Date of Biden
Explainer-When is the State of the Union 2023? Date of Biden's address and what to expect
  • US
  • 2023-01-26 18:29:39Z

U.S. President Joe Biden will deliver his first State of the Union address after Republicans took control of the House of Representatives in a speech that...

Democrats have a problem with Black male voters. VP Kamala Harris is quietly trying to fix it
Democrats have a problem with Black male voters. VP Kamala Harris is quietly trying to fix it

Attendees of a private meeting with Vice President Kamala Harris said the White House is looking improve its relationship with young men of color.

Chevron's buyback boosts stock, get rebuke from White House
  • US
  • 2023-01-26 18:09:06Z

Shares of Chevron climbed Thursday after the oil company announced that it would repurchase $75 billion of its stock, one of the largest-ever stock buyback...

Nearly 80 Democrats send letter to Biden blasting border, migrant policy
Nearly 80 Democrats send letter to Biden blasting border, migrant policy

Seventy-seven Democrats sent a letter to Biden Wednesday criticizing his administration's policies restricting asylum access for migrants at the southern...

Elaine Chao issues rare rebuke of Trump over his racist attacks on her
Elaine Chao issues rare rebuke of Trump over his racist attacks on her

Former Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao called out former President Donald Trump amid his racist broadsides aimed at her and his other anti-Asian...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • electric hunting bike
    (2022-12-03 22:12:02Z)

    Looking to buy electric hunting bike and off-road bike in USA? We've have the range of best e-bikes for sale at YOUNG ELECTRIC. Shop online and enjoy fast shipping.

  • Sintered Metal Filter
    (2022-12-03 22:22:23Z)

    For 15 years SHINKAI has engineered Sintered Metal Filter elementor and flow control products for a variety of industries and porous metal.

  • Custom Cartoon Logo
    (2022-12-04 23:14:57Z)

    This Logos & Branding item by Prettytoonz has 7 favorites from Etsy shoppers. Ships from United States.

  • Learn Oracle Order Management Cloud
    (2022-12-12 00:05:44Z)

    Oracle Order Management Cloud enables your organization to manage orders from all your channels to get a single view of your customer

  • container parts
    (2022-12-15 01:15:33Z)

    CIMC Equilink has been offering premium quality container parts for more than 15 years. With its business experience in the industry over the years and its extensive resources within the CIMC Group, the company will further integrate the fragmented needs of its clients worldwide.

  • twist locks
    (2022-12-15 01:20:16Z)

    CIMC Equilink has been offering premium quality container and container parts for more than 15 years. With its business experience in the industry over the years and its extensive resources within the CIMC Group, the company will further integrate the fragmented needs of its clients worldwide.

  • TV Star hairline
    (2022-12-18 20:06:26Z)

    Nabeel popular Bulbulay comedy star received successful hair transplant surgery from Hair Club. He has a totally undetectable hairline and appears as a normal full head hair person.

  • proveedores chinos
    (2022-12-18 22:24:29Z)

    Purchasing agent in China specialized in importing from China to Spain safely and at the best price. Ask us.

  • Outdoor clothes
    (2022-12-21 00:51:02Z)

    Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!

  • Sodium Hyaluronate
    (2022-12-21 00:55:51Z)

    Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post.

  • multilayer PCB
    (2022-12-22 00:52:01Z)

    Thanks for the blog loaded with so many information. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was looking for.

  • keemun tea
    (2022-12-22 00:56:49Z)

    This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses.

  • neurotonix
    (2022-12-22 01:04:40Z)

    NeuroTonix is a unique blend of natural components that promotes a healthy immune system and is intended to keep the brain healthy, active, and focused.

  • jordan 4 reps
    (2023-01-02 00:06:54Z)

    Best replica sneakers and popular shoes Internet retailer. Cost-effective global brand sneakers for customers. Sneaker rep websites,best replica sneaker sites,buy reps sneakers website,good reps for shoes,ret sneakers

  • Yourself Quotes
    (2023-01-03 01:32:06Z)

    Yourself Quotes is a one-stop solution for the finest quotations and an unlimited collection of self-development, people's quotations, motivational stories, festivities online, and much more inspirational stuff.

  • 启明计划
    (2023-01-09 00:22:53Z)

    以太国际汇集全世界各国海外优青科技型创业项目、连续创业者、互联网高管、销售冠军、首席科学家、海归创业、产业老兵、博士团队、基金管理团队成员,积极推动科技领域启明计划,特聘学者, 海归博士, 海归教授, 长江学者,工信部人才和本地产业链、资金链实现精准对接。以太国际往期帮助上百名海外博士、海外教授、海外科学家通过国家级人才计划引进回国,包含但不限于海外优青,火炬计划,长城计划,昆仑计划,瑞金计划等国家级海外引才计划(国家级人才计划、国家千人计划)以及浙江省人才引进计划(浙江省千人计划)

  • House Painters Auckland
    (2023-01-09 00:27:16Z)

    Zeolis House Painters offers a one-step house painting service with its own scaffolding for all kinds of Auckland house exterior and interior painting works.

  • Φώτα λωρίδας LED
    (2023-01-09 00:31:32Z)

    Wholesale LED Strip Lights, Neon LED Flex and Custom Neon Sign, also can provide professional Smart LED Lights Solutions.

  • Air Conditioning Northern Beaches? Use our business for the installation, repairs and servicing of air conditioners. We are experts when it comes to ducted and split systems.

  • digital business growth
    (2023-01-15 17:09:53Z)

    Reaching the top of the search engine rankings. Helping businesses in Karachi grow with SEO services and digital marketing solutions.

  • farmacia cerca
    (2023-01-15 21:48:54Z)

    Encuentra una farmacia cerca de ti, parafarmacia Online con todo tipo de productos, parafarmacia en casa, envíos a toda España. !Visitanos!

  • Taxi near me
    (2023-01-16 21:34:01Z)

    Very informative post! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign.

  • glucotrust
    (2023-01-17 00:31:31Z)

    GlucoTrust is a great blood sugar or diabetes supplements that are made up of 100% natural and safe ingredients. Buy GlucoTrust Bottle Now

  • Mobile Phones
    (2023-01-17 16:59:04Z)

    Hi there! Nice stuff, do keep me posted when you post again something like this!

  • veip
    (2023-01-19 20:46:11Z)

    Thank you because you have been willing to share information with us. we will always appreciate all you have done here because I know you are very concerned with our.

  • best pharmacy Canada
    (2023-01-19 21:01:57Z)

    Fill your prescription online with a legitimate Canadian Pharmacy shipping medication ONLY from Canada. Save on USA drug costs. Don’t compromise on safety.

  • hormas para zapato
    (2023-01-22 23:29:20Z)

    El Cuidado que tus Zapatos Necesitan. Exclusivas Hormas Madera de Cedro. Conoce nuestros modelos y beneficios de utilizarlas en tu calzado.

  • Trb system
    (2023-01-24 15:29:08Z)

    TRB System Card is a Donald Trump Membership card that is issued by Donald Trump supporters for his 2024 campaign.

  • best gaming laptop under 60000
    (2023-01-26 01:27:55Z)

    The article looks magnificent, but it would be beneficial if you can share more about the suchlike subjects in the future. Keep posting.


Top News: Politics