The Great Irony of Apple's iPhone Price Increases


Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL) has been extraordinarily successful in generating revenue growth out of stagnating unit sales over the past year, primarily thanks to the widely discussed price increases that the company has been implementing ever since introducing the iPhone X in 2017, which started at $999. The company's ability to grow overall iPhone revenue should be what matters most. Apple certainly agrees, which is why it will no longer report unit sales and will only disclose iPhone revenue going forward.

Still, investors continue to fret over the prospect of weak unit sales, even if they will no longer be privy to official unit sales data. As iPhone suppliers continue to post soft results -- including lens supplier Largan Precision today -- Apple investors can't help but worry about unit volumes.

Data source: SEC filings. Chart by author.

Price increases compound the initial problem of longer upgrade cycles

Decelerating unit volumes continue to weigh on analyst sentiment. For example, this week New Street Research analyst Pierre Ferragu worried that "all [average selling price] gains of recent years could be lost in unit decline in the coming years." Apple has ramped up promotional activity in recent weeks, which Ferragu sees as evidence of weak demand. CFRA analyst Angelo Zino wrote in a research note this morning that the company "continues to try to push toward these higher-price devices, and we think that is continuing to cause a slowdown in the replacement cycle."

Speaking of average selling price (ASP) gains, here's what Ferragu is referring to:

Data source: SEC filings. Chart by author.

Smartphone upgrade cycles have been steadily getting longer over time. In 2012, the average upgrade cycle was 22 months, according to Recon Analytics. It reached 28 months near the tail end of 2015, hitting 29 months for the first half of 2016, according to Citigroup. By the end of 2017, we're talking about 32 months, according to NPD. Beyond third-party estimates, even carriers are now exploring 36-month installment plans, arguably the most direct evidence, as carriers have firsthand data on upgrade cycles.

iPhone XS Max can cost upwards of $1,450. Image source: Apple.

Therein lies the great irony. My view has been that iPhone price increases are Apple's strategy of coping with longer upgrade cycles. Consider a customer that buys a $1,000 phone (like a base iPhone XS) and keeps it for two years compared to a customer that buys a $1,500 phone (like a fully loaded iPhone XS Max) and keeps it for three years. The annual revenue that Apple gets from that customer is the same. But by adopting this strategy of price increases as a way to offset longer upgrade cycles, the tech titan inadvertently encourages customers to keep those phones longer, too, further compounding the problem it was trying to initially address. The market will be at three-year upgrade cycles in no time.

Evan Niu, CFA owns shares of Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Apple. The Motley Fool has the following options: long January 2020 $150 calls on Apple and short January 2020 $155 calls on Apple. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.


More Related News

Apple 'Project Titan' Could Mean an Electric Van, Not a Multi-Billion Acquisition of Tesla

Forget plunking down tens of billions of dollars to acquire Tesla, Apple's rumor mill is churning out gossip that the iPhone maker plans to debut its own electric van. This latest rumor was kicked off by a German business publication this week. It's just the latest of a string of ways that observers have said Apple should spend its mammoth $245 billion in cash on hand. Vans, Not Cars in the Wheelhouses Up until Manager Magazin's report, there had been speculation of Apple honing in on a van as an EV concept. Citing several people familiar with the development, the news

Friday Apple Rumors: Apple Closing Stores to Combat Patent Trolls
Friday Apple Rumors: Apple Closing Stores to Combat Patent Trolls

Leading the Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) rumor mill today is news of how the company is fighting patent trolls. Today, we'll look at that and other Apple Rumors for Friday.Source: Apple Patent Trolls: Apple is hoping to deal with less patent trolls by closing some stores, reports MacRumors. The company is

Caterpillar, Apple among big names hit by US-China trade war
Caterpillar, Apple among big names hit by US-China trade war

NEW YORK (AP) - Companies making everything from computers to construction cranes are seeing their profits hurt as the United States' trade war with China causes the world's second largest economy to slow.

Blown away by innovation or price? Samsung
Blown away by innovation or price? Samsung's foldable phone opens new frontier

At its launch event in San Francisco on Wednesday, Samsung upped the surprise factor by briefing analysts and journalists on widely anticipated aspects ahead of time, such as 5G versions of its existing top-end Galaxy S phones. "I am blown away," said Patrick Moorhead of Moor Insights & Strategy

Samsung announces folding phone with 5G at $1,980
Samsung announces folding phone with 5G at $1,980

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd on Wednesday said it will release a folding smartphone in April that works with the next-generation 5G networks and will cost almost $2,000, a move to entice consumers to upgrade their phones. The Galaxy Fold will go on sale on April 26, Samsung officials said at an event in San Francisco. The device "breaks new ground because it answers skeptics who said that everything that could be done has been done," DJ Koh, chief executive of Samsung Electronics, said at the event.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Economy

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.