Tennessee Bill Would Imprison People for 3 Years If They 'Lie' About Rape to Get an Abortion

Photo: SOPA Images (Getty Images)
Photo: SOPA Images (Getty Images)  

Republican lawmakers in Tennessee introduced a bill this week that would add a rape exception to the state's near-total abortion ban-with the caveat that those who "lie" about being raped to access abortion care could be sentenced to up to three years in prison. The bill, which Jessica Valenti first surfaced in her abortion news newsletter on Tuesday, would also require rape victims who do receive abortion care (which they can only get after an invasive forensic exam) to preserve and submit "a sample of the embryonic or fetal tissue extracted during the abortion" to the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation for "investigation into the offense."

The bill, introduced by State Sen. Ferrell Haile (R) and state Rep. Iris Rudder (R), refers to children as young as 12 as "women," specifying that child rape victims who are 12 or younger can get an abortion up to 10 weeks into their pregnancy, while children and adults who are 13 or older can have an abortion at up to eight weeks.

Read more

  • 36 Gifts for Your Friend Who Won't Shut Up About Astrology

  • A Hot Girl's Guide to Having Bunions in Your 20s

  • Amber Heard's Appeal Lists 16 Ways the Court Screwed Her Over in Johnny Depp Defamation Case

The measure (SB857 in the state Senate and HB1440 in the state House) essentially threatens rape survivors-who are routinely disbelieved-with prison time for seeking health care. It also threatens them with criminal investigation even if they are believed and get an abortion.

Haile and Rudder's proposed rape exception is "designed to be unworkable," said Jalessah Jackson, interim executive director of ARC-Southeast, an abortion fund that serves several states including Tennessee, and poses just another set of barriers. The health care system is already untenable for survivors: A study from last September found costs for sexual assault-related health care visits averaged at $3,550 for all victims and $4,550 for pregnant victims.

The bill not an act of compassion from anti-abortion lawmakers; it discourages rape victims from coming forward, and possibly from seeking health care at all. Who would stake three years of their life on the statistically low chance of being believed and supported by law enforcement? Fewer than 1% of rapes lead to felony convictions.

In effect, rape exceptions are "entirely disingenuous," Destini Spaeth, who helps run the North Dakota-based Women In Need abortion fund, told Jezebel. They're merely "PR for anti-abortion politicians" while serving as a "deterrent" to survivors, separating ostensibly "good" abortions from "bad."

"It's just another round of violation of their autonomy within the health care system, within a police and judicial system that routinely hurts survivors," Spaeth said.

By threatening survivors seeking abortion care, Tennessee's bill builds on existing, systemic issues: Sexual assault survivors are often threatened with criminalization and face jarringly high rates of incarceration. And criminal charges for pregnancy outcomes-including abortion-often implicate victims of violence: In 2019, a woman was jailed for fetal homicide when she miscarried after she was shot.

At roughly the same time SB587/HB1440 was introduced in Tennessee, Utah's legislature introduced an abortion ban with a rape exception that requires victims seeking abortion to report their rape to police. This sort of caveat-involving law enforcement for survivors to access abortion-has become increasingly common in anti-abortion legislation, and it's especially jarring given that the overwhelming majority of rapes aren't reported.

But even lawmakers who introduce bans that don't include rape exceptions still find ways to bolster law enforcement at victims' expense: In September 2021, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) defended his state's abortion ban and its lack of rape exceptions by stating that he would simply "eliminate all rapists from the streets." This, he would supposedly achieve by giving more funding to the same police officers who do little to nothing to prevent sexual violence and frequently perpetrate it themselves.

Legal experts pointed out that Abbott's 2021 abortion ban-enforced by allowing people to sue anyone who helped someone get an abortion for at least $10,000-opened the door for rapists to stalk and sue their victims and potentially profit off their pregnancies. Other abortion bans and proposals (including one that called for "community review" panels to determine whether victims are eligible for a rape exception) carry outsized harm for survivors-especially the child survivors that SB857/HB1440 treats as adults: Last summer, a 10-year-old rape victim from Ohio was forced to travel to Indiana for abortion due to Ohio's virtually exception-less ban.

The impact of abortion bans on survivors-and all pregnant people who consequently become victims of this form of state-perpetuated violence-is the same, with or without exceptions that could possibly throw survivors in prison.

"Abortion is the most critical way to protect victims, help them out of an unsafe situation, not prolong their connection to someone who's assaulted them," Spaeth said. "Protecting survivors means no abortion bans, not just exceptions that don't work."

  • 'Yellowstone' Wasted 10 Entire Minutes on a Meaningless Brawl Between 2 Women

  • Hilary Swank, Pregnant at 48, Joins Growing List of Celebrities to Conceive Well Into Their 40s

Click here to read the full article.


More Related News

Saturday's Elite Eight: What to know about Gonzaga, UConn, K-State and Florida Atlantic

Half of the Elite Eight is set with Kansas State and Florida Atlantic in East and Connecticut and Gonzaga in West advancing. A look at the four teams.

March Madness 2023: UConn Women Beat Football Team in Ticket Cash
March Madness 2023: UConn Women Beat Football Team in Ticket Cash

It is unusual for a Division I school with both a football team and a men's basketball team to generate more ticket sales revenue from the latter. Only 11 of 102 FBS public schools in our college sports finances database fit this description. Teams from two of those schools made it to the Sweet 16 […]

TBI: 11 men charged with trying to buy sex from minor
TBI: 11 men charged with trying to buy sex from minor
  • US
  • 2023-03-23 17:47:04Z

Indictments come after authorities arrested and cited 41 people in the undercover operation in Nashville this month.

Arrest made in fire at planned Wyoming abortion clinic
Arrest made in fire at planned Wyoming abortion clinic
  • World
  • 2023-03-22 23:44:53Z

A woman was arrested on charges of setting fire to a building in Wyoming that was being renovated to house the state's only full-service abortion clinic...

24 years later, DNA leads to arrest in Okaloosa County rape case
24 years later, DNA leads to arrest in Okaloosa County rape case
  • US
  • 2023-03-22 09:01:10Z

The March 1999 rape remained unsolved for decades until a DNA breakthrough. Charles Louis Craig, 60, was arrested in California.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • Hmbhso
    (2023-02-22 16:35:35Z)

    lanoxin 250 mg us digoxin 250 mg ca molnupiravir 200 mg tablet

  • majorsite
    (2023-02-25 04:31:04Z)

    Your writing is perfect and complete. majorsite However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?

  • Usluum
    (2023-02-26 20:43:57Z)

    digoxin 250 mg us molnunat 200 mg drug order molnupiravir 200mg pills

  • Xkmejg
    (2023-02-28 23:42:52Z)

    amoxil order brand amoxil 250mg ivermectin 250ml

  • Oslvdw
    (2023-03-01 00:52:33Z)

    coreg price order carvedilol 6.25mg without prescription elavil 10mg drug

  • Ggpvwq
    (2023-03-02 10:05:40Z)

    purchase priligy online cheap priligy 60mg without prescription order domperidone online

  • Evcxop
    (2023-03-02 12:11:59Z)

    purchase alendronate generic alendronate 70mg cheap buy generic ibuprofen 600mg

  • Nqvuko
    (2023-03-04 00:34:49Z)

    indomethacin 50mg generic cenforce for sale order cenforce 50mg for sale

  • Whmcxv
    (2023-03-04 01:26:01Z)

    buy nortriptyline 25 mg pill buy nortriptyline 25 mg pill purchase paxil pill

  • Tlyssr
    (2023-03-05 12:19:15Z)

    order famotidine 40mg pills pepcid 40mg oral order mirtazapine

  • Aywkun
    (2023-03-05 13:03:43Z)

    doxycycline 100mg cost order doxycycline 100mg cost methylprednisolone

  • Bwxbca
    (2023-03-06 23:34:08Z)

    generic requip 2mg trandate 100mg brand labetalol drug

  • Nlzkgw
    (2023-03-07 15:00:30Z)

    tadalafil 10mg oral buy clopidogrel 150mg generic trimox cost

  • Evtaxl
    (2023-03-08 13:56:38Z)

    fenofibrate 200mg sale sildenafil 100mg tablets viagra drug

  • Rpzovr
    (2023-03-09 03:03:03Z)

    order nexium 20mg without prescription biaxin 250mg without prescription cost furosemide

  • Ifbnqe
    (2023-03-10 03:32:58Z)

    cost cialis 5mg Discount canadian tadalafil buy viagra sale

  • Bfhfqt
    (2023-03-10 17:55:29Z)

    minocin cheap order generic minocin buy terazosin generic

  • Jwlzrm
    (2023-03-11 23:53:05Z)

    brand tadalafil 10mg pills for erection otc ed pills that work

  • Hyjblk
    (2023-03-12 17:38:24Z)

    glycomet medication glucophage 1000mg tablet nolvadex price

  • Djvcyn
    (2023-03-13 18:05:16Z)

    purchase modafinil modafinil 100mg pills promethazine over the counter

  • Jlzpit
    (2023-03-15 11:40:34Z)

    order prednisone online cheap order generic amoxil 500mg amoxicillin 1000mg ca

  • Qkcykv
    (2023-03-16 11:36:40Z)

    buy isotretinoin pills ampicillin 250mg tablet ampicillin tablet

  • Nudvgm
    (2023-03-17 13:42:29Z)

    order fildena 100mg generic purchase fildena sale order proscar online cheap

  • Hxrzmw
    (2023-03-18 12:44:13Z)

    ivermectin 12mg tablets for humans male ed drugs order generic deltasone 10mg

  • Jylruc
    (2023-03-19 14:07:30Z)

    ondansetron 4mg over the counter generic trimethoprim trimethoprim ca

  • Mhgcbv
    (2023-03-20 21:04:25Z)

    buy accutane online cheap isotretinoin 20mg cost cheap azithromycin 500mg

  • Dzajhs
    (2023-03-23 07:52:44Z)

    buy prednisolone generic order prednisolone 40mg lasix for sale

  • Qhjuwx
    (2023-03-23 13:33:11Z)

    order provigil 100mg generic order generic lisinopril lopressor price


Top News: Latin America