Supreme Court sidesteps major rulings on electoral map manipulation




  • In US
  • 2018-06-18 14:53:51Z
  • By By Andrew Chung and Lawrence Hurley
The U.S. Supreme Court is seen as the court nears the end of its term in Washington
The U.S. Supreme Court is seen as the court nears the end of its term in Washington  

By Andrew Chung and Lawrence Hurley

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday sidestepped major rulings on whether state lawmakers should face curbs on their ability to draw legislative districts purely for partisan advantage, issuing narrow rulings in cases from Wisconsin and Maryland regarding the practice called partisan gerrymandering.

The court handed a victory to Wisconsin Republicans who drew state electoral districts that helped entrench their party in power by throwing out on a 9-0 vote a lower court ruling that the districts deprived Democratic voters of their constitutional rights including equal protection under the law.

In the Maryland case, the court in an unsigned opinion decided not to immediately block a Democratic-drawn U.S. House of Representatives district challenged by Republican voters but allowed the case to proceed.

Election reformers in both parties had hoped the justices would stop a growing trend in which parties that control state legislatures use the process of redrawing electoral districts after the U.S. census every decade to tighten their grip on power by diluting the clout of voters who tend to support the rival party.

Opponents have said partisan gerrymandering has begun to warp American democracy by muffling large segments of the electorate.

The justices could soon take up another case involving a challenge to Republican-drawn congressional districts in North Carolina that could give them another chance in their next term beginning in October to issue a broader ruling on potential limits on partisan gerrymandering.

The high court's action enabled the justices to avoid a definitive ruling on whether courts have the power to intervene when political parties at the state level devise electoral maps expressly to tighten their hold on power at the expense of the other party.

In the Wisconsin case, the Supreme Court found that the Democratic voters who sued to block the Republican-drawn electoral map lacked legal standing to bring the case because they challenged it on a statewide basis rather than focusing on individual legislative districts.

Writing for the court, Chief Justice John Roberts said electoral maps on a statewide basis cannot be challenged as a whole. "In this case the remedy that is proper and sufficient lies in the revision of the boundaries of the individual's own district," Roberts said.

The justices sent the dispute back to a federal district court to give the Democratic voters another chance to prove they were harmed on a concrete basis.

The brief five-page ruling in the Maryland case was limited to rejecting the Republican voters' attempt to block the congressional district while litigation moves forward.

Republican voters sued Maryland after the legislature in 2011 redrew boundaries for the state's Sixth District in a way that removed Republican-leaning areas and added Democratic-leaning areas

(Reporting by Andrew Chung and Lawrence Hurley; Editing by Will Dunham)

COMMENTS

More Related News

Ex-President Temer to give testimony in Brazil after arrest
Ex-President Temer to give testimony in Brazil after arrest

RIO DE JANEIRO (AP) - Brazilian federal police expect to take testimony from ex-President Michel Temer and his former Cabinet minister Wellington Moreira Franco on Friday, a day after both were arrested as part of the country's sprawling Car Wash corruption probe.

Engineering elections? U.S. top court examines electoral map manipulation
Engineering elections? U.S. top court examines electoral map manipulation
  • US
  • 2019-03-22 11:39:38Z

Thanks to partisan gerrymandering - a practice the Supreme Court will examine on Tuesday in two cases that could impact American politics for decades - that is no longer the case. A U.S. House of Representatives district that once covered heavily Democratic Greensboro was reconfigured in 2016, with the voters in the city of 290,000 people inserted into two other districts spanning rural areas with reliable Republican majorities. In adopting the electoral map, the legislature partitioned the campus of North Carolina A&T State University, the nation's largest historically black public college, into two separate districts.

Dump Electoral College? Some 2020 Democrats Back Liberals' Goals
Dump Electoral College? Some 2020 Democrats Back Liberals' Goals

Several top Democratic presidential candidates have lined up behind jettisoning the Electoral College, expanding the Supreme Court, killing the Senate filibuster and granting statehood to Washington D.C. -- all of which would likely smooth the way for the policy proposals at the heart of their agendas. Most are plans that have circulated among Democrats for decades without gaining much traction with party leaders, and they have little chance of success in the foreseeable future.

Justice Clarence Thomas breaks three-year silence in Mississippi case about racial bias in jury selection
Justice Clarence Thomas breaks three-year silence in Mississippi case about racial bias in jury selection

The Supreme Court's senior justice, who seldom speaks during oral argument, broke a three-year silence to ask questions in a race discrimination case.

Justice Thomas talks at court arguments, 1st time in 3 years
Justice Thomas talks at court arguments, 1st time in 3 years

The Supreme Court was about to adjourn for the day when the Georgia baritone politely inquired of the lawyer at the lectern. Justice Clarence Thomas, the court's only African-American member and lone Southerner, was breaking a three-year silence at high court arguments with a couple of questions

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: US

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.