Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett delivers 1st opinion

  • In Politics
  • 2021-03-04 15:22:54Z
  • By Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) - Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett delivered her first opinion Thursday, ruling against an environmental group that had sought access to government records.

President Donald Trump's third nominee wrote for a 7-2 court that certain draft documents do not have to be disclosed under the federal Freedom of Information Act. The case was the first one Barrett heard after joining the court in late October, and it took four months for the 11-page opinion to be released. Two liberal justices, Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor, dissented.

It is something of a tradition for new justices to be assigned a case in which the court is unanimous for their first opinion, but it doesn't always happen. Both of Trump's other nominees, Justice Neil Gorsuch and Justice Brett Kavanaugh, wrote unanimous first opinions. Sotomayor also got a unanimous opinion for her first assignment, but President Barack Obama's other nominee, Justice Elena Kagan, was assigned a first opinion where the court divided 8-1.

The opinion Barrett wrote involved the environmental group the Sierra Club, which sued seeking access to federal government documents involving certain structures used to cool industrial equipment and their potential harm to endangered wildlife. Barrett began by explaining that FOIA makes "records available to the public upon request, unless those records fall within one of nine exemptions." Those exemptions include "documents generated during an agency's deliberations about a policy, as opposed to documents that embody or explain a policy that the agency adopts."

Barrett said the documents the Sierra Club was seeking were draft documents that did not need to be disclosed. And she dismissed concerns the group had raised that ruling against it would encourage officials to "stamp every document 'draft'" to avoid disclosing them. Barrett said that if "evidence establishes that an agency has hidden a functionally final decision in draft form" then it won't be protected from disclosure requirements.

Barrett's predecessor on the court, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, liked to recount that she was assigned a "miserable" case involving a federal law about pensions for her first opinion, a case on which the court had divided 6-3. She said that though she and the court's first female justice, Sandra Day O'Connor, were on different sides of the case, when she announced the opinion in court, O'Connor passed her a note that said: "This is your first opinion for the Court, it is a fine one, I look forward to many more."

Because of the coronavirus pandemic, the justices are not currently announcing their decisions in the courtroom but only posting them online.


More Related News Receives Largest Single Investment of $100 Million Receives Largest Single Investment of $100 Million

The 110-year-old asset manager is known for its early investments in tech firms, such as Amazon, Google, and, more recently, Tesla. According to...

AP sources: Biden to pledge halving greenhouse gases by 2030
AP sources: Biden to pledge halving greenhouse gases by 2030

President Joe Biden will pledge to cut U.S. greenhouse gas emissions at least in half by 2030 as he convenes a virtual climate summit with 40 world leaders, ...

Biden administration lifts Trump-era restrictions stalling Puerto Rico hurricane aid
Biden administration lifts Trump-era restrictions stalling Puerto Rico hurricane aid

The Department of Housing and Urban Development also made $8.2 billion available to Puerto Rico, three years after Congress initially approved the aid.

Democrats press Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett to recuse in major First Amendment case
Democrats press Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett to recuse in major First Amendment case

The Supreme Court will debate Monday whether Americans for Prosperity Foundation and other charities may decline to disclose donors to regulators.

Biden's virtual climate summit: Diplomacy sans human touch
  • US
  • 2021-04-20 04:05:13Z

President Joe Biden, a most hands-on politician, this week will host a major climate summit with dozens of world leaders - all of them stuck on Zoom. Biden ...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • Zgwaow
    (2021-03-11 22:39:54Z)

    tadalafil online canadian pharmacy - tadalafil 75 mg troche tadalafil prescription online

  • Japitm
    (2021-03-17 16:39:21Z)

    Uidbac - Cost of viagra sildenafil from canada

  • Jmzhiu
    (2021-03-23 20:55:13Z)

    Cpucdf - provigil 100mg Fumzrg fvepsl

  • Lxmubo
    (2021-03-24 22:59:42Z)

    Ygstip - acheter tadalafil en ligne avec paypal Ifcfys liolfd

  • Tatdpe
    (2021-03-25 18:41:42Z)

    Zlotew - Drxnus ekstxb

  • Kgxmwf
    (2021-03-27 17:23:13Z)

    Iwqiaw - buy zithromax online pharmacy no prescription needed Wtbifk afdyyq

  • Xvrykb
    (2021-03-29 17:11:29Z)

    Oypyzl - where can i buy viagra online without a prescription Uwwtfl affkaj

  • Vduhmb
    (2021-03-31 03:33:46Z)

    Znjycm - creative presentation Epmwkj jqetvj

  • Lkfihq
    (2021-04-03 08:59:51Z)

    Chwlyb - help writing a speech Jahquu rctcdi

  • Ojzxfd
    (2021-04-04 15:18:03Z)

    Rvdqjd - buy propecia online forum Jakzwl vxuqrt

  • Dcrmor
    (2021-04-05 17:12:02Z)

    Yqqvou - where can you buy viagra without a prescription Hwirnw ovemht

  • Upvrgr
    (2021-04-08 23:11:56Z)

    Bvyjxc - write a essay online Lvqykp taqiez

  • Xpitlr
    (2021-04-10 10:47:31Z)

    Gmqqlu - sildenafil canada Lxuyce ekgmjn

  • Jyoqnr
    (2021-04-11 18:02:49Z)

    Jahvrz - essay scholarships Pnqqoq vokdmb

  • Abhwff
    (2021-04-13 18:43:39Z)

    Rhfyuh - furosemida Fehpfq vmyosq

  • Yrdsts
    (2021-04-15 02:36:54Z)

    Iznkri - buy vardenafil with paypal Skbjur rgdcqm

  • Tisqji
    (2021-04-16 09:38:36Z)

    Mhwqrz - silagra 100 price Kirusk qnjyxh

  • Zavctc
    (2021-04-17 02:18:56Z)

    Chxngr - silagra uk Gnepxi mqbajo

  • Pghtdw
    (2021-04-17 23:06:57Z)

    Mllegc - tadacip 20 mg canada Ylattp ajyack

  • Crpwgw
    (2021-04-19 11:44:45Z)

    Ahlysn - super avana coupon Ixcrnx xhzptm

  • Arfpyr
    (2021-04-21 00:32:40Z)

    tadacip 20 uk - canadian pharmacy 20 mg tadacip tadacip 20 mg tablet


Top News: Politics