Students caught in visa sting at fake university may sue U.S., court rules




By Jonathan Stempel

NEW YORK (Reuters) - A federal appeals court said foreign-born students may sue the U.S. government over claims it wrongfully canceled their visas, following a sting where it set up a fake university to entrap corrupt visa brokers.

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia revived a proposed class action on behalf of more than 500 students who said they were deprived of due process when the government revoked their lawful immigration status after ensnaring them in the sting.

Writing for a three-judge panel, Circuit Judge Theodore McKee also faulted the government's "flip-flop" over whether the students, including many from China and India, who thought they had "enrolled" at the fictitious University of Northern New Jersey were innocent victims, or participants in the fraud.

Spokespeople for the U.S. Department of Justice had no immediate comment.

The government in 2013 created the University of Northern New Jersey, supposedly located in the town of Cranford, to catch brokers of fraudulent student visas, even creating a website and social media accounts for the school that looked real.

It said brokers recruited more than 1,000 students to enroll, typically charged thousands of dollars for visas so they could stay, and sometimes arranged illegally for work visas.

Twenty-one arrests were announced when the university "closed" in April 2016.

The Department of Homeland Security then revoked the visas of many affected students, citing their "fraudulent enrollment," prompting the lawsuit to restore their legal status.

In October 2017, U.S. District Judge Jose Linares in Newark, New Jersey, dismissed the lawsuit, saying it was filed too soon because U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, had yet to act on the students' reinstatement applications.

McKee, however, said visa revocations were "final" orders that could be challenged in court, even if students had other means to fight removal, and criticized the government's shifting views on whether the students were victims or conspirators.

"It would be a cruel irony indeed if we were to allow the government's own flip-flop on that characterization to deprive us of the ability to review the disputed governmental action," McKee wrote. "The flip-flop underscores the need for judicial review of a decision that would otherwise escape review by any court or agency."

Ira Kurzban, a lawyer for the students, welcomed the decision, calling it the "first salvo" in efforts to stop ICE from "trying to entrap innocent students."

McKee said it may still prove a "formidable challenge" to certify a class action because of many differences among affected students.

The case is Fang et al v Director, U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement et al, 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 17-3318.


(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Steve Orlofsky and Leslie Adler)

COMMENTS

More Related News

Budget deficit to break $1 trillion despite strong economy
Budget deficit to break $1 trillion despite strong economy

An annual congressional report says the U.S. budget deficit is likely to burst through the symbolic $1 trillion barrier this year despite a healthy economy. Tuesday's Congressional Budget Office report follows a burst of new spending last year and the repeal in December of several taxes used to help finance the Affordable Care Act. The annual CBO update of the government's economic and fiscal health estimates a $1 trillion deficit for the ongoing fiscal year, which would bring the red ink above $1 trillion for the first time since 2012, when former President Barack Obama capped four consecutive years of $1 trillion-plus budget deficits.

Bolton Was Concerned That Trump Did Favors for Autocratic Leaders, Book Says
Bolton Was Concerned That Trump Did Favors for Autocratic Leaders, Book Says
  • World
  • 2020-01-28 13:16:18Z

WASHINGTON -- John Bolton, the former national security adviser, privately told Attorney General William Barr last year that he had concerns that President Donald Trump was effectively granting personal favors to the autocratic leaders of Turkey and China, according to an unpublished manuscript by Bolton.Barr responded by pointing to a pair of Justice Department investigations of companies in those countries and said he was worried that Trump had created the appearance that he had undue influence over what would typically be independent inquiries, according to the manuscript. Backing up his point, Barr mentioned conversations Trump had with the leaders, President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of...

Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace Tears Into Conservative Pundit:
Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace Tears Into Conservative Pundit: 'Get Your Facts Straight!'

Sparks flew Monday on the Fox News set between Fox News anchor Chris Wallace and conservative contributor Katie Pavlich, with Wallace demanding his colleague get her "facts straight" after Pavlich insisted that certain witnesses had not been called in the impeachment trial.Moments before President Donald Trump's defense team began its arguments in the Senate impeachment trial, Pavlich noted during Fox's pregame coverage that while Republican senators are now weighing whether to call former National Security Adviser John Bolton following his bombshell claims, the House should have presented a more thorough case."The Senate is not the House, the House did not come with a complete case, and...

Supreme Court allows Trump policy against immigrants receiving public aid to go into effect
Supreme Court allows Trump policy against immigrants receiving public aid to go into effect

Under the rule, non-citizens receiving or likely to need non-cash benefits such as housing and food aid can be denied residency or green cards.

Could Trump Muzzle John Bolton? The Limits of Executive Privilege, Explained
Could Trump Muzzle John Bolton? The Limits of Executive Privilege, Explained

WASHINGTON -- Republican senators allied with President Donald Trump are increasingly arguing that the Senate should not call witnesses or subpoena documents for his impeachment trial because Trump has threatened to invoke executive privilege, and a legal fight would take too long to resolve.But it is

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Latin America