Shoot it? Snare it? Let it go back to China? US officials wring hands over options for spy balloon

  • In Politics
  • 2023-02-04 15:23:30Z

WASHINGTON - President Joe Biden was first briefed on Tuesday about a Chinese spy balloon drifting over the United States, the same day a White House spokesman talked to reporters about the importance of improving engagement with the Chinese.

Three days later, Secretary of State Antony Blinken scrapped a trip to China because of the balloon.

Among the many lingering questions is why the balloon, which the Chinese maintain is a "civilian airship" used mostly for weather research that was blown off course, was in U.S. airspace - and why now.

Beijing is unlikely to gather more information from the balloon than it can learn from the satellites both countries use to spy on each other. And an airship as large as two buses was not going to go undetected.

"What are they signaling? And what do they hope to achieve?" said Kari Bingen, a former deputy undersecretary of defense for intelligence and security. "Because this is something that you can't miss. They were going to get caught. That's what's so brazen about it."

An American flag is flown next to the Chinese national emblem during a welcome ceremony at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, Nov.
An American flag is flown next to the Chinese national emblem during a welcome ceremony at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, Nov.  

Sending a message?

Bingen, who is now the director of the Aerospace Security Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington, D.C., believes China is sending the Biden administration a message.

The balloon arrived not only shortly before Blinken's planned trip but also as the U.S. was inking a deal with the Philippines to double U.S. military presence there. That's part of an effort to counter China's threats to Taiwan and growing Chinese influence in the Indo-Pacific region.

If the balloon was intended as a retaliatory poke in the eye, it's backfired, according to a senior U.S. official who spoke on the condition of anonymity. China is now lying about losing it and apologizing for entering U.S. airspace.

But it's causing not just national security and diplomatic concerns for the Biden administration, but also a political headache.

Democrat demands answers

Republicans aren't the only ones criticizing Biden's handling of the situation. Montana Sen. Jon Tester, one of the most vulnerable Democrats up for re-election in 2024, demanded "real answers" after the balloon drifted over his state.

Tester, who heads the Senate subcommittee that oversees defense spending, said he will be pulling administration officials before his panel.

"Montanans value their freedom and privacy, and I'll always fight to defend both," he tweeted.

Not the first time

Incursions by spy balloons into U.S. airspace have occurred before, Air Force Brig. Gen. Pat Ryder told reporters Friday. But he declined to list instances.

"What I would tell you right now is that information is classified," Ryder said. "I'm not able to provide it other than I can confirm that there have been other incidents where balloons did come close to or cross over U.S. territory."

The current one was traveling eastward over the center of the U.S. on Friday. Combined with its equipment, the balloon is as big as two buses, according to a second senior U.S. official. It is bristling with intelligence and surveillance sensors.

Unclear what Chinese are looking for

It's unclear what the Chinese are looking for, said the official who was not authorized to speak publicly. Shooting it down would spread debris over a wide area, and the risk of injuries or death on the ground has been deemed too high.

Scott Murray, a retired Air Force colonel and intelligence officer, said the balloon could carry basic intelligence gathering gear for collecting communications and other signals, snapshot imagery or full-motion video.

"What gives me pause though is anything they put on the balloon has the potential to be captured and exploited if the balloon is shot down," Murray said.

Thomas Karako, director of the Missile Defense Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said the balloon is likely to contain multiple sensors used to assess U.S. civilian and military facilities, intercept communications and possibly even more operational technologies that can help China detect U.S. missiles.

"It's a big platform with presumably a fairly big payload. We don't know what the exact sensors are. But it could be a mix of things," Karako said. "Obviously, it could be cameras, but it could also be things like infrared or signals intelligence. It could be soaking up electronic emissions or communications or any number of other things."

Karako, a former aide on the House Armed Services Committee, said the Biden administration should take it down, or find a way to capture it, to send a message back to Beijing.

Pentagon spokesman U.
Pentagon spokesman U.  

Republicans want balloon shot down

Many Republicans attacked the administration for letting the balloon linger.

Former President Donald Trump said the Pentagon should shoot it down, as did former Vice President Mike Pence and Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson, both of whom are considering joining Trump in the GOP race for the 2024 presidential nomination.

Rep. Michael McCaul, the Texas Republican who heads the House Foreign Affairs Committee, said the balloon should never have been allowed to enter U.S. airspace.

"U.S. officials have acknowledged they were monitoring this balloon since it flew over the Aleutian Islands - where it could have easily been shot down over water," McCaul said in a statement in which he joined those calling on the administration to remove the balloon.

Rep Michael McCaul, R-Texas
Rep Michael McCaul, R-Texas  

Response to 'armchair generals'

Connecticut Rep. Jim Himes, the top Democrat on the House intelligence committee, encouraged "the armchair generals to take the boxing gloves off" to allow time to determine if shooting down the balloon is the best course of action.

"There are instances where you would much rather own something whole than spread a debris field across hundreds of square miles," Himes told USA TODAY.

John Bolton, who served as Trump's national security adviser, wondered if it's possible to put a small tear in the balloon so it could drift down and be captured.

"That way we can do to the Chinese what others do to us, and get the technology hanging from the balloon and see what it actually is," he said.

'Most consequential bilateral relationship'

The administration is tracking the situation closely and is "keeping all options on the table," White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said Friday.

She told reporters Biden had been initially briefed on Tuesday and is receiving regular updates.

Also on Tuesday, White House spokesman John Kirby said Blinken's planned trip was part of an effort to restore some of the lines of communication between the nations.

"This is the most consequential bilateral relationship in the world," Kirby said.

On Friday, Blinken said he will reschedule his trip "when conditions allow."

"The first step," Blinken said, "is getting the surveillance asset out of our airspace."

More: Rep. Jim Jordan subpoenas FBI, Education Department over school board memo

More: Southwest Airlines executive to testify before Senate panel following flight cancelation 'meltdown'

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: What should Biden do about Chinese spy balloon?


More Related News

Fact check: Outdated claim that US is threatening to cut off aid to Uganda
Fact check: Outdated claim that US is threatening to cut off aid to Uganda

The post references a 2014 Ugandan law that led to the U.S. briefly stopping aid. The law was annulled, and the U.S. continues to send aid today.

Donald Trump argues he deserves immunity from 3 lawsuits over Jan. 6 Capitol attack
Donald Trump argues he deserves immunity from 3 lawsuits over Jan. 6 Capitol attack

Donald Trump's lawyer argued in a federal appeals filing he deserves immunity from three civil lawsuits seeking to blame him for the Capitol attack.

TikTok Isn
TikTok Isn't the Solo Problem. Tech Needs Tougher Regulation

REUTERS/Evelyn HocksteinThe CEO of TikTok, Shou Zi Chew, faced tough questioning from Congress on Thursday.Some of it was animated by security concerns...

With Biden
With Biden's student loan debt forgiveness in limbo, lawmakers consider colleges' role

At a hearing meant to poke holes in the Biden administration's mass debt relief plan, both Republicans and Democrats agreed schools should have more skin in ...

Medicare Tries to Combat Fraud. Now Insurers Are Fighting Back.
Medicare Tries to Combat Fraud. Now Insurers Are Fighting Back.

"How's the knee?" one bowler asked another across the lanes. Their conversation in a Super Bowl ad focused on a Biden administration proposal that one bowler...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Politics