Senate Judiciary Committee advances controversial Trump pick

  • In Politics
  • 2019-11-07 17:39:43Z
  • By Politico

The Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday voted to advance President Donald Trump's court pick to the powerful 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals - setting up a contentious vote when he reaches the full chamber.

Steven Menashi, an associate counsel to the president, faced backlash from Democrats and Republicans during his September confirmation hearing for declining to answer questions about his work for the White House or for the Department of Education, where he was a lawyer.

And Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine said in October she'd oppose Menashi, saying in a statement it was "inappropriate" for the nominee to refuse to answer senators' questions and that his "past writings, particularly about women, LGBTQ advocates, and diversity, raise questions about whether he has the appropriate judicial temperament."

Senate Judiciary Chairman Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) acknowledged Thursday that Menashi faces bipartisan opposition and added, "He's different than I would have chosen."

"I thought he could have been more forthcoming quite frankly," Graham said, noting Menashi has "written some really weird stuff."

He added, though, that Democrats shouldn't reject Menashi for providing legal advice that they disagree with - a reference to his time serving under Education Secretary Betsy DeVos.

Sen. John Kennedy of Louisiana, who also criticized Menashi for refusing to answer questions about his work at the White House, joined fellow Republicans on the committee in approving the nomination. He said that while some of Menashi's writing were controversial, his opinions were "very, very carefully reached."

"I think we have to be careful in automatically assuming ... people's points of view as written, for example, in an academic journal are a window in how they're going to rule," Kennedy said.

The Louisiana Republican said he expressed his concerns to the White House counsel and added the administration's nominees generally are "overcoached."

Beyond his confirmation hearing, Republicans and Democrats criticized Menashi for his earlier writings in legal journals and newspapers. They include a controversial essay he wrote on ethnonationalism and the state of Israel.

As a student at Dartmouth College, he also criticized "Take Back the Night" marches, which draw awareness to sexual violence against women. He's also accused the Human Rights Campaign of exploiting "the slaying of Matthew Shepard for both financial and political benefit" and wrote in the New York Sun that trial lawyers take advantage of the public.

Prior to the vote, Senate Judiciary Committee ranking member Dianne Feinstein reiterated her opposition to Menashi and cited a New York Times article published Wednesday evening that cited a plan he wrote at the Department of Education that was used to deny debt relief to students cheated by for-profit colleges. A federal judge later ruled that the effort violated privacy laws and ordered the Education Department to cease using it.

"I think it's really appalling that this committee only learned about this memo and Mr. Menashi's legal decision on this issue through a leak in The New York Times," Feinstein said.

Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) also criticized Menashi for his "history of expressing strident, outlandish personal views."

"This committee should have grave reservations about advancing a nominee to the 2nd Circuit who works in the White House, who has minimal courtroom experience, who has a record of giving troubling legal advice," Durbin said.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said Thursday morning that Menashi's nomination was "an embarrassment to this country."

"His conduct before the Judiciary Committee was insulting, his contempt for the Senate reprehensible, his refusal to be forthcoming about his record is outright disqualifying," Schumer said.


More Related News

Coronavirus Relief Talks Still
Coronavirus Relief Talks Still 'Miles Apart'

Democratic leaders Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer said Wednesday that they had turned down an overture from Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin for the two sides negotiating a stalled coronavirus relief package to resume talks. The White House, Democrats said, isn't budging from its demands for a smaller aid package. "We have made clear to the Administration that we are willing to come down $1 trillion if they will come up $1 trillion," the Democratic leaders said in a joint statement. "However, it is clear that the Administration still does not grasp the magnitude of the problems that American families are facing. We have again made clear to the Administration that we are...

The White House Has Explored Ways to Sidestep Congress to Cut Taxes: Report
The White House Has Explored Ways to Sidestep Congress to Cut Taxes: Report

The White House has explored whether President Trump has the authority to cut taxes without legislation from Congress, The New York Times reports:"While such a move is not imminent, Mr. Trump's advisers have sought legal guidance from White House lawyers about whether the president has the authority to eliminate certain taxes, including income and business taxes, without the approval of Congress."Daniel Hemel, a tax law professor at the University of Chicago, tells the Times that the administration "clearly can delay pretty much anything for a year." But unlike Trump's weekend move to defer payroll taxes through the end of the year, White House officials are discussing whether the...

Trump's Unemployment Plan Would Provide an Extra $300 per Week: White House

President Trump's effort to replace a portion of the now-expired $600 per week in supplemental unemployment benefits has produced lots of questions about the size and scope of the program. Following considerable pushback on the plan from state officials, the White House provided some clarifications on Tuesday: * Although Trump on Saturday said the plan would provide $400 per week for qualified unemployed workers, the White House said on Tuesday that the weekly aid would top out at $300 per week. * Reversing a previously stated requirement that states contribute 25%, or $100, toward the enhanced payment, the White House said Tuesday that there was no requirement for states to cover a...

Trump hair rinsing complaints prompt U.S. to ease shower standards
Trump hair rinsing complaints prompt U.S. to ease shower standards
  • US
  • 2020-08-12 22:28:35Z

The U.S. government proposed rule changes on Wednesday that would allow shower heads to boost water pressure, after President Donald Trump repeatedly complained that bathroom fixtures do not work to his liking. The Department of Energy plan followed comments from Trump last month a White House event on rolling back regulations. Last December, Trump said environmental regulators were looking at sinks, faucets and toilets to revise rules meant to conserve water and fuel that heats it.

POWER PLAYERS: The 16 key healthcare experts advising Joe Biden and Kamala Harris
POWER PLAYERS: The 16 key healthcare experts advising Joe Biden and Kamala Harris

Should former Vice President Joe Biden with the White House, these experts would shape how the US emerges from the coronavirus pandemic.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Politics