San Francisco votes to ban city use of facial recognition technology

  • In US
  • 2019-05-15 02:26:17Z
  • By Reuters

By Jeffrey Dastin

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - San Francisco officials on Tuesday voted 8 to 1 to ban the purchase and use of facial recognition technology by city personnel, in a move to regulate tools that local Silicon Valley companies helped develop.

The ordinance, which also would require city departments to submit surveillance technology policies for public vetting, can become final after a second vote next week by the same officials, the city's Board of Supervisors.

The action puts San Francisco at the forefront of increasing discontent in the United States over facial recognition, which government agencies have used for years and now has become more powerful with the rise of cloud computing and artificial intelligence technologies.

"We have a fundamental duty to safeguard the public from potential abuses," Aaron Peskin, the city supervisor who championed the ban, said before the board's vote.

Peskin said the ordinance was not an anti-technology policy. It allows continued use of surveillance tools like security cameras; the district attorney or sheriff can make an appeal to use certain restricted technology in exceptional circumstances as well.

Rather, Peskin said, the aim is to protect "marginalized groups" that could be harmed by the technology.

For instance, Inc has come under scrutiny since last year for selling an image analysis and ID service to law enforcement. Researchers have said this service struggles to identify the gender of individuals with darker skin, prompting fears of unjust arrests. Amazon has defended its work and said all users must follow the law.

Civil rights groups and companies including Microsoft Corp, which markets a facial recognition service, have called for regulation of the technology in recent months. This has added momentum to the effort in San Francisco and to a parallel ban reportedly in the works in nearby Oakland.

For a draft text of the San Francisco ordinance, see

While communities at the heart of the technology industry are moving to limit facial recognition, police elsewhere have increased their use, primarily to spot potential suspects in known offender databases after a crime has occurred.

U.S. customs agents are vetting foreign travelers at airports with facial recognition, and other federal agencies use the technology too.

Daniel Castro, vice president of the Information Technology & Innovation Foundation, said concerns that the U.S. government would use face identification for mass surveillance, like China has, were overblown. The non-profit includes technology industry representatives on its board.

San Francisco's "ban on facial recognition will make it frozen in time with outdated technology," he said.

(Reporting By Jeffrey Dastin in San Francisco; editing by Bill Berkrot and Cynthia Osterman)


More Related News

Is California
Is California's high-speed rail plan a pipe dream?

Keith Erwin was about to buy the land that his auto repair shop sits on when he was turned down because California's much awaited high-speed rail line was going to pass through the spot. "It's a train that's going to go nowhere," the mechanic said at his garage in Fresno, just steps from where the train is supposed to eventually pass. In February, newly elected Governor Gavin Newsom announced he was drastically revising downward the high-speed rail project to link Los Angeles to San Francisco in three hours, even though the plan was approved in a 2008 referendum.

Consultant poses as journalist in Monsanto trial
Consultant poses as journalist in Monsanto trial

Smiling and affable, the young woman was able to pass herself off as a fellow journalist to reporters including AFP covering a landmark trial in San Francisco on the health risks associated with the weedkiller Roundup. The relaxed, confident thirtysomething was in fact an employee of Washington-based FTI Consulting, which has a client list that includes Roundup-maker Monsanto and its parent company Bayer.

What Kind Of Shareholder Appears On The Wrap Technologies, Inc.
What Kind Of Shareholder Appears On The Wrap Technologies, Inc.'s (NASDAQ:WRTC) Shareholder Register?

If you want to know who really controls Wrap Technologies, Inc. (NASDAQ:WRTC), then you'll have to look at the makeup...

A British Tourist Heads West Through America
A British Tourist Heads West Through America

The "View of the World from Ninth Avenue" in Saul Steinberg's 1976 cover for The New Yorker will resonate with anyone who's ever lived or worked in Manhattan. From Ninth Avenue, the island's grid is enlarged and disproportionate. The Hudson lies before a scattering of other cities and states. Beyond the river is the Pacific Ocean, then China, Japan, and Russia dotted along the horizon. As for what's beyond that -- who cares?Paul Johnson's A History of the American People paints a rather different picture. In a thousand pages he explains the founding of the colonies, done "primarily for religious purposes," the distinct character of this extraordinary nation; its discovery, its growth, and...

Cannes Film Review:
Cannes Film Review: '5B'

"It was a wonderful place where you could go to die - but it doesn't take away from the fact that they died." This is how one interviewee describes 5B, the trailblazing San Francisco hospital ward that pioneered a more humane method of nursing AIDS sufferers during the epidemic's paranoid 1980s zenith, affording terminal patients […]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: US

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.