Republicans May Shoot Themselves In The Foot By Putting Citizenship In The Census




WASHINGTON ― Democrats and voting rights advocates are alarmed by the Trump
WASHINGTON ― Democrats and voting rights advocates are alarmed by the Trump  

WASHINGTON ― Democrats and voting rights advocates are alarmed by the Trump administration's plan to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census, fearing it will suppress votes and unfairly shift electoral power to rural states. But the move could also mean negative electoral consequences for populous states that voted for Donald Trump in the 2016 election.

The decennial census, the gold standard in government data, has not asked about citizenship since 1950. Those who oppose the Commerce Department's plan to add such a question say it will make people less likely to respond to the survey, especially in communities with large populations of immigrants. The Trump administration's aggressive rollback of immigrant-friendly policies may add to the reluctance.

"We strongly believe that adding an untested question on citizenship status at this late point in the decennial planning process would put the accuracy of the enumeration and success of the census in all communities at grave risk," six former directors of the Census Bureau wrote in a letter to Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross on Tuesday.

Accuracy of census results is critical. Data produced by the survey helps determine how federal and local government funding is distributed, including money for emergencies, housing, education, health care and transportation.

The census also helps determine representation at all levels of government. Undercounting, for example, could shortchange how congressional seats are apportioned among the 50 states. Because most undocumented immigrants in the U.S. reside in large metropolitan areas, populous states like New York, California, Texas, and Florida may face the greatest repercussions from a citizenship question, potentially costing them electoral college votes in presidential elections.

"If I am a strategic Republican congressional partisan right now, I am livid at this," Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School in Los Angeles and a former deputy assistant attorney general under President Barack Obama, told HuffPost. "Because what this reliably does is make sure that areas where people are afraid, where there are fast-growing communities, are likely to be undercounted, and those are precisely the areas where Republicans are likely to be in control of redistricting after the next census. ... But if there's not a full count, those are presumptively Republican seats that are gonna vanish."

Fast-growing states are projected to gain congressional seats after the 2020 census. Texas, a Republican stronghold, stands to gain three or four congressional districts, and Florida should gain two. Arizona, Colorado, North Carolina and Oregon should each gain one, according to estimates by Election Data Services based on the latest census data.

A count that excludes non-citizens, however, could reverse some of those gains. California would lose three seats in 2020, Florida and Texas would each lose two, and Arizona would one seat, according to projections by demographer Dudley Poston of Texas A&M University and Amanda Baumle, a sociologist at the University of Houston.

Republican lawmakers dismissed criticism of adding a citizenship question to the census, saying it wiill give a more accurate picture of the U.S. populace.

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), in a statement Tuesday, hailed the move as a "reasonable, commonsense" step, adding that "it is imperative that the data gathered in the census is reliable, given the wide ranging impacts it will have on U.S. policy."

Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) also shrugged off the prospect of electoral repercussions in 2020, arguing that including undocumented people in the count diluted the voting power of legal residents.

The Constitution, however, simply requires a count of the "whole number of persons in each State." At least 12 states, including California and New York, say they will challenge the Trump administration's move on constitutional grounds, arguing they stand to lose billions of dollars in federal funding as well as fair representation in Congress if the census asks respondents about their citizenship.

But the problem could be particularly acute in Texas, which is notoriously hard to count and contains many poor and minority counties. The state also has three metro areas with the largest populations of people living in this country illegally: Houston, Dallas-Fort Worth and Austin.

"This isn't about politics, it's about Texas receiving its fair share of resources and representation. It is not a Democratic issue or a Republican issue ― it's a Texas issue," Democratic state Rep. César J. Blanco, who represents an area of El Paso, said in a statement on Tuesday. He called on Gov. Greg Abbott (R) to join the lawsuit against the Trump administration.

Texas GOP strategist Matt Mackowiak acknowledged a possibility that a citizenship question in the 2020 census could negatively affect the state. But he argued that "the upside of getting a more accurate count [of the state's population] outweighs the downside of risking a new congressional seat."

"Is there a risk to the state of Texas in that perspective? Yes," Mackowiak added. "But again, my guess is … that among the populace and the elected officials, this is going to be popular."

Even Kansas Secretary of State Kris Kobach, who has long claimed without proof there is widespread voter fraud by noncitizens, conceded that adding the question to the census could affect the apportioning of congressional districts in Republican states.

Kobach said Tuesday he suggested to Trump last year that the administration consider adding a citizenship question to the 2020 census. He claimed some states with large immigrant populations, like California, have had their "congressional seats inflated by counting illegal aliens."

Asked whether Texas numbers also may be inflated, Kobach said he was not sure.

"There may be some," he said.

Sam Levine contributed reporting.

COMMENTS

More Related News

Barack and Michelle Obama sign production deal with Netflix
Barack and Michelle Obama sign production deal with Netflix

Another (very) big deal for Netflix: Former U.S. President Barack Obama and

Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick Touts Need To Arm Teachers
Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick Touts Need To Arm Teachers

Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick (R) on Sunday pushed for arming teachers and

Parkland students on Texas: "They
Parkland students on Texas: "They're part of this now"

PARKLAND, Fla. (AP) - Survivors of the school shooting in Parkland, Florida, are expressing outrage and heartbreak after authorities said a student killed 10 people Friday at a high school in Texas.

Ten killed in Texas school shooting after attacker 'walks into art class and opens fire'
Ten killed in Texas school shooting after attacker 'walks into art class and opens fire'

At least 10 people have been killed at a school in Santa Fe in Texas after an armed student burst into an art class and opened fire. Nearly all of those killed were fellow pupils in what is believed to be the 22nd school shooting of the year in the US. The suspect, Dimitrios Pagourtzis, 17, appeared by video link in court on Friday evening when he was denied bail. He was shackled and wore a green jumpsuit, speaking in a quiet voice as he answered questions. #UPDATE Possible explosive devices have been located at the school and off campus. Law enforcement is in the process of rendering them safe. School has been evacuated. Call 911 if you see any suspicious item. #HouNews#SantaFeISD- Santa...

'Loner' student shoots and kills 10 at Texas school
  • US
  • 2018-05-19 02:59:05Z

A 17-year-old student dressed in a trench coat and armed with a shotgun and pistol opened fire at his high school outside Houston on Friday, killing nine students and a teacher, before surrendering to officers, authorities said. Santa Fe High School, southeast of Houston, joined a long list of U.S.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Latin America

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.