'Read My Lips': How George H.W. Bush's Tax Hikes Changed Our Politics

George H.W. Bush
George H.W. Bush's Inauguration in 1989  

The tributes to former President George H.W. Bush have focused on his life of service, his character, his sense of humor, his courage and his leadership. But as the nation mourns and celebrates the life of the 41st president, Bush is also being remembered for his willingness to raise taxes as part of a bipartisan compromise to bring down the deficit - a controversial and politically costly step since it violated his 1988 "read my lips: no new taxes" pledge and infuriated conservatives.

In a eulogy Wednesday at the Washington National Cathedral, former Sen. Alan Simpson remembered Bush's willingness to raise taxes even though he knew "it would be a real punch in the gut" for him and prompt a backlash.

That deal may have set the stage for the '90s boom: "It was the first step to eliminating the Reagan-era deficits," writes David Leonhardt in The New York Times. "Bill Clinton and a Democratic Congress took the next step, in 1993, and by the late 1990s the federal government was running a surplus. The turnaround played a significant (if unknowably large) role in creating the 1990s economic boom - which remains the only period of broad-based income gains over the past 40 years."

A turning point for the Republican Party, and the country: The Washington Post's Charles Lane writes that Bush's 1990 tax increase "sowed a lasting grass-roots distrust of the party establishment that fueled Newt Gingrich's rise to power in the House and culminated, arguably, in Donald Trump's 2016 insurrection." The conservative backlash to the tax hikes certainly reshaped the Republican Party and affected every presidency since Bush's. "No national GOP leader since has accepted that preserving the government services Americans want requires higher taxes," writes CNBC's John Harwood. "Instead, the party has treated the levers of government power as a one-way ratchet down for tax rates."

The last of his kind? The Times' Leonhardt argues that only one major modern Republican figure deserves the label of fiscal conservative, and it's George H.W. Bush. And The Washington Post columnist Catherine Rampell says Bush "may well be the last Republican leader to acknowledge the fundamental fraud of Republican fiscal policy - that tax cuts do not pay for themselves." (She notes that Reagan raised taxes 11 times, undoing about half of his big 1981 tax cut, according to one estimate - but Reagan avoided a backlash by using euphemisms such as "revenue enhancements" or "receipts strengthening" rather than calling them tax hikes. "Incidentally, the Reagan budget official who came up with these euphemisms, and thereby helped paper over the lies of supply-siderism, was a genial young fellow named Larry Kudlow - now President Trump's top economic adviser," Rampell adds.)

Where do we go from here? The Post's Lane argues that the American public is now more worried about the fairness of the federal tax system than about rates being too high. "Bush may have lived just long enough to witness the moment at which tax cuts have finally reached the point of diminishing political returns for Republicans," he writes. "In 1990, it was indeed political suicide for George H.W. Bush to support a tax increase. The situation for Trump and his fellow Republicans now may be even worse: Promising to cut taxes for everyone no longer helps them politically, while promising to raise taxes, on the rich, may help the Democrats in 2020."

Like what you're reading? Sign up for our free newsletter.


More Related News

As 2020 candidates turn left, some Democrats worry about the center
As 2020 candidates turn left, some Democrats worry about the center
  • US
  • 2019-02-23 11:06:47Z

Party activists have been energized as Cory Booker, Kirsten Gillibrand, Kamala Harris and other candidates endorsed plans to provide Medicare coverage to every American, some form of tuition-free college, a national $15 minimum wage and the so-called "Green New Deal" advocated by U.S. Representative

Why North Carolina's Election Fraud Hurts American Democracy
Why North Carolina's Election Fraud Hurts American Democracy

The North Carolina State Board of Elections ordered a new election in the state's Ninth Congressional District.

Around 200 US troops to remain in Syria after pullout: W.House
Around 200 US troops to remain in Syria after pullout: W.House

The US military will keep around 200 troops in Syria after President Donald Trump's pullout from the war-torn country, the White House said Thursday. "A small peace-keeping group of about 200 will remain in Syria for a period of time," White House spokeswoman Sarah Sanders said. The announcement comes amid fierce criticism of Trump's decision to withdraw America's 2,000 or so troops from Syria by April 30, with members of his own Republican Party blasting the move.

GOP candidate
GOP candidate's son had concerns about political operative

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) - The Republican in the last undecided U.S. congressional election ignored repeated warnings from his son against hiring a shady political operator now accused of illegally collecting voter's ballots in a rural North Carolina county and casting the GOP campaign into limbo, the younger man testified Wednesday.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Economy

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.