Rachel Maddow Defends Niger Theory After Experts Call It 'Conspiracymongering'




Rachel Maddow Defends Niger Theory After Experts Call It 'Conspiracymongering'
Rachel Maddow Defends Niger Theory After Experts Call It 'Conspiracymongering'  

Rachel Maddow on Friday doubled down on her controversial reporting on the deadly Niger ambush on U.S. troops, in which she linked President Donald Trump's travel ban with the deaths of four soldiers.

Maddow's report, delivered Thursday and reiterated Friday, strongly suggested that Trump's addition of Chad to his travel ban prompted the country to withdraw its U.S.-partnered counterterrorism troops in Niger, thus causing an increase in attacks by the self-described Islamic State in the area.

"Over the course of the day today lots of people have been very upset with me for reporting that last night, which is fine. I didn't know you cared," Maddow said in her Friday segment.

"But the upset over my reporting doesn't mean that anything I reported wasn't true. Everything I reported was true."

Watch Maddow's original Niger report from Thursday below.

Andrew Lebovich, a PhD candidate in African History at Columbia University and a visiting fellow with the European Council on Foreign Relations, called out the segment on Twitter, arguing, "these things are not linked, they have to do with areas on literal opposite ends of the country."

The MSNBC host on Friday also briefly attempted to hedge her speculation, before adamantly reinforcing her theory once again.

"Now, this doesn't mean that Chad withdrawing their troops was necessarily the cause of what happened to those U.S. troops who were ambushed," Maddow said.

Then, spinning off into another tangent, she added:

Four U.S. soldiers were killed in Niger after a group of 50 militants affiliated with the so-called Islamic State in the Greater Sahara ambushed the patrol team during a routine train-and-advise mission.

More than two weeks after the ambush, still not much is known about why the troops were under-protected and why they were there in the first place.

Maddow's theory on the ambush drew sharp criticism from experts familiar with the region, including assistant professor Laura Seay of Colby College's Department of Government, who spoke to HuffPost's Willa Frej after Maddow's segment aired.

"No, that's crazy," Seay said of Maddow's suggestion that Chadian troops were battling ISIS in Niger. "Everybody that I know is appalled by this. I would like to think that Maddow's researchers are more responsible."

After Maddow defended her Niger reporting on Friday, Seay tweeted at the MSNBC host to "sort out the facts."

Maddow "told her audience that the Chadians were protecting civilians from ISIS," Seay wrote. "They were not."

In a column for Slate, Seay warned that Maddow's "irresponsible conspiracymongering" could lead left-leaning individuals down a rabbit hole similar to conservatives who blame the deadly attack on the U.S. consulate in Benghazi on the Obama administration.

Seay wrote: "Maddow's approach to this story - 'just asking questions' that are neither based in evidence nor likely to contribute to an accurate understanding of what happened in Niger and why - drags liberals down the same path that conservatives traveled with Benghazi, one of irrational, fearmongering claims that only serve to prolong the suffering of the families of the fallen while doing nothing to explain the root causes of the event."

"In doing so," she added, "Maddow also preyed upon Americans' lack of knowledge about Africa, a widespread problem that ranges from not understanding how large the continent is to major news organizations mislabeling maps for national broadcast."

COMMENTS

More Related News

Warren DNA analysis points to Native American heritage
Warren DNA analysis points to Native American heritage

BOSTON (AP) - Sen. Elizabeth Warren on Monday released the results of a DNA analysis that she said indicated she has some Native American heritage, a direct rebuttal to President Donald Trump, who has long mocked her ancestral claims and repeatedly referred to her as "Pocahontas."

Trump says climate change not a hoax, not sure of its source
Trump says climate change not a hoax, not sure of its source

In an interview with CBS' "60 Minutes" that aired Sunday night, Trump said he doesn't want to put the U.S. at a disadvantage in responding to climate change. Trump called climate change a hoax in November 2012 when he sent a tweet stating, "The concept of global warming was created

Trump celebrates return of American pastor from Turkey
Trump celebrates return of American pastor from Turkey

WASHINGTON (AP) - President Donald Trump welcomed American pastor Andrew Brunson to the Oval Office on Saturday, celebrating his release from nearly two years of confinement in Turkey that had sparked a diplomatic row with a key ally and outcry from U.S. evangelical groups.

Trump: More At Stake Over Jamal Khashoggi Disappearance Because He
Trump: More At Stake Over Jamal Khashoggi Disappearance Because He's A Reporter

President Trump warned there will be repercussions if Saudi Arabia is responsible for the disappearance of U.S. resident Jamal Khashoggi.

Trump vows to unearth truth about Khashoggi disappearance
Trump vows to unearth truth about Khashoggi disappearance

President Donald Trump declared Friday the U.S. will uncover the truth about what happened to journalist and U.S. resident Jamal Khashoggi, whose possible murder at Saudi hands after disappearing in Istanbul has captured worldwide attention. "We're going to find out what happened," Trump

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Latin America

facebook
Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.