Pete Buttigieg's Christmas tweet inadvertently sparked a war over whether Jesus was a poor refugee




Pete Buttigieg\
Pete Buttigieg\'s Christmas tweet inadvertently sparked a war over whether Jesus was a poor refugee  

Pete Buttigieg, mayor of South Bend, Indiana, and top-tier 2020 Democratic presidential candidate, tweeted a Christmas message: "Today I join millions around the world in celebrating the arrival of divinity on earth, who came into this world not in riches but in poverty, not as a citizen but as a refugee. No matter where or how we celebrate, merry Christmas." In 2019, those are apparently fighting words.

Some conservative Christians protested that Joseph, the terrestrial father of Jesus of Nazareth, wasn't poor - though it's hard to see how a carpenter from an otherwise insignificant village in Galilee would be well-off - or faulted Buttigieg for not saying "Jesus" in his tweet. "But it was perhaps Buttigieg's classification of Jesus as a refugee - a common line among the Christian left - that received almost immediate pushback from evangelicals," says The Washington Post's Eugene Scott.

The Daily Wire's Matt Walsh tied the criticisms together in one tweet, and he got some pushback from Jack Jenkins, a religion reporter with a master's degree in divinity from Harvard.



Walsh, who is Catholic, argued back that Jesus wasn't a refugee because Galilee and Egypt were both part of the Roman Empire. Fr. James Martin, a Jesuit priest who's nobody's idea of a theological conservative, explained in 2017 why Jesus and his family were clearly refugees, at least according to the Gospel of Matthew. And fellow Jesuit priest Jeremy Zipple noted that Pope Benedict XVI - nobody's idea of a liberal - disagrees with Walsh, as did Pope Pius XII.



Jesus' citizenship status "has real implications for how Christians on both sides of the aisle conduct policy" and view President Trump's hardline, restrictive immigration and refugee policies, Scott reports. And Buttigieg dropped his Christmas tweet into a tender moment for evangelicals being internally challenged to square their faith with their fealty to an unrepentantly flawed president. Read The Week's Bonnie Kristian on how evangelicals might fix this moral dissonance.

More stories from theweek.com
A more honest evangelical defense of Trump
5 scathingly funny cartoons about Trump's holiday season
5 political clichés we should leave in the 2010s

COMMENTS

More Related News

Obama warned Trump was
Obama warned Trump was 'fascist' in 2016, according to Hillary film
  • World
  • 2020-01-27 15:05:36Z

* Tim Kaine quotes Obama in forthcoming Hulu documentary * Trump's standing against Democrats improves, poll showsBarack Obama called Donald Trump a "fascist" during the 2016 election, according to Virginia senator Tim Kaine.The incendiary comment is included in Hillary, a forthcoming Hulu documentary which has already stoked controversy.Remarks Hillary Clinton made about Bernie Sanders, her challenger for the Democratic nomination four years ago, went viral last week.This weekend, NBC News, the Atlantic and other outlets reported that the film, which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on Saturday, shows Kaine, Clinton's pick for vice-president, in conversation with his running mate...

Pro-Life Dem Confronts Buttigieg over Party
Pro-Life Dem Confronts Buttigieg over Party's Commitment to Abortion: 'We Have No Part in the Party'

South Bend mayor Pete Buttigieg was confronted by a pro-life Democratic voter over the party's position on abortion during a Fox News town hall event on Sunday."I am a proud pro-life Democrat," audience member Kristin Day said. "Would you support more moderate platform language [regarding abortion] in the Democratic Party to ensure that the party of diversity and inclusion really does include everybody?" Currently, the Democratic party platform supports abortion up to nine months into pregnancy."I support the position of my party, that this kind of medical care needs to be available to everyone, and I support the Roe vs. Wade framework that holds that early in pregnancy there are very few...

Poll: A week before the caucuses, Joe Biden leads an Iowa race that remains unsettled
Poll: A week before the caucuses, Joe Biden leads an Iowa race that remains unsettled

One week before the opening Iowa caucuses, Joe Biden has pulled into the lead in Iowa, ahead of Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren in a fluid field.

Biden, Sanders Pull Further Ahead in ABC-WaPost National Poll
Biden, Sanders Pull Further Ahead in ABC-WaPost National Poll

(Bloomberg) -- Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders, who represent rival visions for the Democratic Party, are solidifying their status as frontrunners in the crowded presidential field, according to a Washington Post-ABC News national poll.Coming just a week before voters finally get to have their say in the Iowa caucuses, the polls show Biden with a solid 32% overall among registered voters who lean Democratic, while Sanders registered support from 23%. Both are doing slightly better than in the same poll in October.Senator Elizabeth Warren, who was once considered a front-runner and earned endorsements from the New York Times a week ago and from the Des Moines Register in Iowa on Saturday, has...

Warren Says She
Warren Says She's Ready to Fight After Major Iowa Endorsement

(Bloomberg) -- The Des Moines Register endorsed progressive favorite Senator Elizabeth Warren a little more than a week before the Iowa caucuses on Feb. 3, saying the Massachusetts lawmaker would "push an unequal America in the right direction." The influential newspaper in Iowa's largest city revealed its pick for the first-in-the-nation nominating contest on its website Saturday evening."At this moment, when the very fabric of American life is at stake, Elizabeth Warren is the president this nation needs," the Register's editorial board said.The Register said that many of Warren's ideas "are not radical. They are right.  They would improve life in America, and they are...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-08 13:52:37Z)

    knife [url=http://cialisle.com/#]cialis online buy[/url] either buy online cialis diversity

    REPLY

Top News: Latin America