One Brazilian minister shines as coronavirus clobbers Bolsonaro

By Gabriel Stargardter and Lisandra Paraguassu

RIO DE JANEIRO/BRASILIA (Reuters) - As criticism has grown over President Jair Bolsonaro's handling of the coronavirus pandemic, many Brazilians are turning to another voice for guidance and reassurance.

Health Minister Luiz Henrique Mandetta has emerged from relative obscurity with technocratic daily briefings presenting the latest science, stressing the need for social distancing measures and earning praise from across the political spectrum.

The contrast with Bolsonaro - a right-wing populist who has attacked governors for lockdowns that are causing job losses and played down the threat of what he calls "a little flu" - has been striking.

A former federal lawmaker from the same party as the leaders of both houses of Congress, Mandetta plays up his background as doctor and health official, but allies say his political savvy also make him an important counterweight in the cabinet.

His rise has not gone unnoticed. Tensions boiled over in a tense meeting at the presidential residence over the weekend, according to sources, and on Tuesday Bolsonaro was visibly irked by questions about Mandetta.

"Nobody should forget that I'm the president," he said.

This week, Bolsonaro replaced the Health Ministry briefings, which had been carried live on several TV networks for weeks, in favor of a news conference at the presidential palace where Mandetta is one of a half dozen ministers, often speaking last.

"Mandetta comes out of this crisis much stronger than when he went into it," said Efraim Filho, the head of Mandetta's Democrats party in the lower house. "Now he has the admiration and the respect of a big slice of society that goes beyond ideological lines."

Just 35% of Brazilians called Bolsonaro's handling of the coronavirus crisis "good" or "great," according to a Datafolha survey released last week, compared to 55% support for Mandetta's performance, in line with that of governors.

"He is an important asset for the Bolsonaro government," said Filho, when asked about rising tensions. "Any firing or exit of Mandetta would erode support for the president."

As his public standing has risen, the health minister has more openly contradicted Bolsonaro.

On Saturday, Mandetta warned of the dangers of chloroquine, an anti-malarial that drug Bolsonaro believes could be a cure for the COVID-19 respiratory disease caused by the coronavirus. The health ministry, Mandetta stressed, would be guided solely by science.

According to two sources, Mandetta's frank comments came after a "harsh meeting" with Bolsonaro and other ministers in which he told the president he would not back down on recommending social distancing measures, and asked his boss to stop diminishing the danger of the virus.

Mandetta enjoys the support of various key cabinet ministers including Justice Minister Sergio Moro and Economy Minister Paulo Guedes, according to the sources and press reports.

"Now we are hit by this (coronavirus) wave ... we are under the guidance of Minister Mandetta," Guedes said in a press conference on Tuesday. "People can obey Mandetta's social isolation orders."

In a statement, the justice ministry said it had adopted measures "to deal with the coronavirus pandemic in accordance with the technical guidelines of the health ministry."

The president's office declined to comment, while the health ministry did not respond to questions.


A former doctor and health secretary for the city of Campo Grande, Mandetta became a federal lawmaker in 2010. Hailing from the soy-producing state of Mato Grosso do Sul, he has strong ties to Brazil's powerful agribusiness sector, sources said.

During his time in Congress, he was most well-known for opposing health policies of the leftist Workers Party government, and in particular its "Mais Medicos" program which brought Cuban doctors to Brazil's most far-flung corners.

Senator Humberto Costa, a Workers Party member who was Brazil's health minister from 2003-2005, said he had long clashed with Mandetta due to ideological and policy differences.

Costa said it was only Bolsonaro's "crazy" actions that had allowed Mandetta to shine. The health minister was performing an unremarkable, "rice and beans" job, he said, but it could be worse.

"If he goes, my fear is that someone worse comes next," he said.

Those who know him said Mandetta's emerging reputation as a straight-laced technocrat was not the full picture, adding he was more politically savvy than he appeared.

Arthur Chioro, Brazil's health minister during the leftist administration of former President Dilma Rousseff, said Mandetta had emerged as a potential center-right threat to Bolsonaro.

"Any citizen who is even slightly informed can see that in terms of the federal government, (Mandetta) has positioned himself as a counterpoint to the irresponsibility ... of the president," Chioro said.

"Mandetta comes out of this much stronger," he added. "If he takes the right decisions, it could launch him into becoming a major leader of the Brazilian right."

(Reporting by Gabriel Stargardter and Lisandra Paraguassu; Editing by Brad Haynes and Alistair Bell)


More Related News

Brazil's Bolsonaro accepts little blame for his country's COVID-19 disaster, but he wears a face mask

Brazil now has the world's second-largest outbreak of COVID-19, with 375,000 confirmed cases, putting it a distant No. 2 to the U.S. and its 1.66 million cases. "President Jair Bolsonaro is deflecting all responsibility for the coronavirus crisis, casting blame on mayors, governors, an outgoing health minister, and the media," The Associated Press reports. With one notable exception, he "has avoided acknowledging the potential effects of his actions, particularly in undermining local leaders' stay-at-home recommendations."The exception was in mid-April. "Reopening commerce is a risk I run because, if it (the virus) gets worse, then it lands in my lap,"...

Trump administration suspends travel from Brazil to limit spread of COVID-19
Trump administration suspends travel from Brazil to limit spread of COVID-19

President Trump issued a proclamation barring people who have been in Brazil within 14 days from entering the United States.

Brazil stands by hydroxychloroquine despite WHO
Brazil stands by hydroxychloroquine despite WHO

Brasília (AFP) - Brazil's health ministry said Monday it would not change its recommendation to treat coronavirus with hydroxychloroquine, despite the World Health Organization deciding to suspend trials of the drug over safety concerns. Like his US counterpart Donald Trump, Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro has touted the supposed benefits of hydroxychloroquine and a related drug, chloroquine, against the new coronavirus.

Brazil's Bolsonaro says he expects top court to end probe into his conduct over police

Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro expects the Supreme Court to find no wrongdoing and end an investigation into potential political interference in the federal police, according to a statement from the presidential palace on Monday. An allegation by former Justice Minister Sergio Moro, a popular anti-graft crusader, that Bolsonaro aimed to interfere in police investigations has become a political scandal adding to the public health crisis caused by the coronavirus outbreak.

In Bolsonaro
In Bolsonaro's Brazil, everyone else is to blame for virus
  • World
  • 2020-05-25 19:28:59Z

With Brazil emerging as one of the world's most infected countries, President Jair Bolsonaro is deflecting all responsibility for the coronavirus crisis, casting blame on mayors, governors, an outgoing health minister and the media. Havoc and heartache are unfolding beneath a void of leadership, according to Miguel Lago, executive director of Brazil's Institute for Health Policy Studies, which advises public health officials.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Baseball