NYC Cabbies Facing Financial Ruin Force City to Mull a Rescue

(Bloomberg) -- New York City Council members are considering laws that would bail out hundreds of taxi drivers facing financial ruin as competition from Uber-like vehicles choke city streets and erode their income.

Dozens of Yellow Cab owner-operators marched on City Hall Monday, when some offered tearful testimony describing how their belief in the American Dream was shattered by predatory lenders and city policies encouraging an inflated market for licensing medallions that burst with the unregulated growth of the electronic-hail industry.

"I think about taking my life -- I really do -- and the only thing that stops me is my kids," Mouhamadou Aliyu, a West African father of four who's been in New York since 1993, said in testimony to the council. He bought a medallion for $700,000 in 2004 that's now worth $100,000, he said.

Aliyu said he's still $54,000 in debt, and his shrinking income isn't enough to repay his medallion loan, the lease on his cab and the mortgage on his Bronx house. "If I lose my house I'm killing myself, period. Because my house is for my kids, my future, please help me."

At least nine drivers have killed themselves since late 2017, including one who took a shotgun to his head near City Hall last year, according to Bhairavi Desai, a political organizer who leads the Taxi Worker Alliance. She told council members to cap medallion loan payments at $900 a month, down from the current average of $2,800. She called for a city task force to determine how much a taxi medallion license is worth and to press lenders to forgive any loans above that amount. The average medallion-owning cabbie loses an average of about $28,000 a year, she said.

Council Transportation Committee Chairman Ydanis Rodriguez offered sympathy but didn't endorse their demands. He invited the drivers to testify, he said, to focus attention on the medallions' value and the "blind eye" taken by city regulators that may have allowed cabbies to fall prey to predatory lending and other corrupt practices.

"These are small business owners, many of them immigrants who invested hundreds of thousands of dollars into a medallion in hopes of achieving their piece of the American Dream," Rodriguez said. "We must also find a way to hold the people responsible for this financial crisis accountable. This crisis was no accident, and we must make sure the taxi medallion owners receive justice."

Rodriguez and Councilman Ritchie Torres, who heads its Oversight Committee, took aim at Bill Heinzen, acting chairman of the city's Taxi and Limousine Commission, for what they termed the regulatory agency's failure to protect drivers.

Although Heinzen touted the agency for capping the number of app-based for-hire vehicles at 80,000 last year, Torres focused on the agency's promotion of medallion auctions in 2014. At that time, the advent of Uber hadn't yet brought on the collapse of the market and the city advertised the $650,000 licenses to potential owners as an investment that was "better than the stock market," guaranteeing a "worry-free retirement."

Torres produced a city memorandum from 2011 warning TLC officials that medallion prices were at risk of collapse. City officials either ignored the advice or weren't aware of it at the time, Heinzen said.

Also under questioning by Torres, Heinzen said the city had no record of how many drivers had filed for bankruptcy or were at risk of financial collapse.

"I don't know the exact number," Heinzen said. "I'm sure it's painfully high."

To contact the reporter on this story: Henry Goldman in New York at

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Flynn McRoberts at, William Selway

For more articles like this, please visit us at

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.


More Related News

Harley Halts Output of Electric Model Pivotal to Revival Bid
Harley Halts Output of Electric Model Pivotal to Revival Bid

(Bloomberg) -- Harley-Davidson Inc. has halted production of LiveWire, the debut electric bike it's counting on to attract new riders.The motorcycle maker recently discovered an issue during final quality checks, according to an emailed statement that doesn't provide details. Harley said it stopped production

Johnson Stumbles in Bid for Brexit Deal as EU Demands Answers
Johnson Stumbles in Bid for Brexit Deal as EU Demands Answers
  • World
  • 2019-10-14 05:43:22Z

(Bloomberg) -- Sign up to our Brexit Bulletin, follow us @Brexit and subscribe to our podcast.Boris Johnson's attempt to secure a Brexit deal ran into trouble after the European Union warned the talks were still a long way from a breakthrough and the British prime minister's political allies distanced themselves from his plans. The pound fell. After a weekend of intensive negotiations in Brussels, the EU's chief Brexit negotiator, Michel Barnier, told a meeting of envoys on Sunday that the U.K.'s proposals for breaking the deadlock over the Irish border lacked detail and risked leaving the single market vulnerable to fraud, officials said. The unionist party that backs Johnson's minority...

Billionaires Could Face Tax Rates Up to 97.5% Under Sanders
Billionaires Could Face Tax Rates Up to 97.5% Under Sanders

(Bloomberg) -- Billionaires may have much more to fear from a Bernie Sanders presidency than they do from an Elizabeth Warren administration, according to two economists advising both candidates.That's one of the conclusions of a new interactive website developed by University of California, Berkeley professors Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman.If Sanders had his way, they calculate that the 400 richest Americans, on average, would have an effective tax rate of 97.5%. That includes not only their income, but also a wealth tax that whittles away at the family fortune.The 97.5% average effective tax rate under his plans compares with 23% now and 62% under Warren's proposals, according to the...

China Denied U.S. Lawmakers Visas Over Taiwan Visit
China Denied U.S. Lawmakers Visas Over Taiwan Visit

(Bloomberg) -- China denied entry visas to a U.S. congressional delegation, with Chinese officials telling one congressman's staff members the visas would be granted for their trip only if they canceled a stop in Taiwan.Representative Sean Patrick Maloney, a New York Democrat, said in a Wall Street Journal op-ed that the quid pro quo amounted to "visa blackmail, designed to stanch the longstanding tradition of robust U.S. congressional engagement with Taiwan."Maloney warned Beijing that "ham-handed and obtusely enforced pressure campaigns" will only "invigorate congressional support for Taiwan." He said he will be exploring ways for Congress to "reinforce U.S. support for Taiwan" in the...

Schiff Says Secret Testimony Aimed at Keeping Trump in the Dark
Schiff Says Secret Testimony Aimed at Keeping Trump in the Dark

(Bloomberg) -- House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff defended holding testimony behind closed doors in the impeachment inquiry he's heading up against President Donald Trump, likening this phase of the investigation to a "grand jury.""We want to make sure that we meet the needs of the investigation and not give the president or his legal minions the opportunity to tailor their testimony and in some cases fabricate testimony to suit their interests," the California Democrat said Sunday on CBS's "Face the Nation."Schiff said they may call some or all of the witnesses to return to testify in public later, though that might not include the whistle-blower who triggered the...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Economy

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.