NFL's conclusion on Myles Garrett's claim of a slur overlooks one key piece of evidence

  • In Sports
  • 2019-11-22 18:05:37Z
  • By ProFootball Talk on NBC Sports

Regarding Browns defensive end Myles Garrett's claim that Steelers quarterback Mason Rudolph uttered a racial slur before last Thursday night's melee, the NFL has said, "We looked into it and found no such evidence."

Actually, there is evidence. The evidence comes from the version of the events shared by Garrett.

At a time when so many inaccurate things are being said by folks who know better about "hearsay," Garrett hearing Rudolph say a slur becomes direct evience that Rudolph used a slur.

The more accurate explanation would be that the league found no corroboration of Garrett's claim. But that doesn't make Garrett's claim inaccurate.

And finding no corroboration is a far cry from finding evidence that debunks Garrett claim.

If the league truly wanted to get to the bottom of this one, it would be easy to at least try. Bring Garrett and Rudolph to New York (or travel to them), grill them separately, and then make a decision. That's what the league recently did in the Antonio Brown case, where one side claims one thing and the other contends the exact opposite.

One side is right, and one side is wrong. A skilled interrogator would have as good a chance as anyone at getting to the truth.

The broader question is whether the league wants to get to the truth, or whether the league simply prefers that it go away.

The league beefed up its enforcement of rules against the use of slurs several years ago. Only a small handful of players have fined since then.


More Related News

These impressions of Marshawn Lynch and Russell Wilson are spot on
These impressions of Marshawn Lynch and Russell Wilson are spot on

A parody video was created to show how NFL players arrive to the stadium on game days.

At Senior Bowl, Dayton
At Senior Bowl, Dayton's Trautman catches on as NFL prospect

In the year between Saubert and Parham, the Senior Bowl surely took a long look at another PFL tight end, San Diego's Ross Dwelley, who's become a key contributor with the Super Bowl-bound San Francisco 49ers. "I think it's really that late-bloomer thing," Trautman said last week

Tom Brady to meet with other teams in 2020 free agency
Tom Brady to meet with other teams in 2020 free agency

After spending his entire NFL career at Gillette Stadium with the New England Patriots, Tom Brady is entering free agency. Per CBS Sports' Jason La Canfora, Brady is open to talks with other teams for what is to be his last contract of his playing career. Brady has been a staple of the Patriots franchise for 19 years.

Nick Bosa fined for blindside block
Nick Bosa fined for blindside block

The Vikings and 49ers disagreed about whether 49ers defensive end Nick Bosa took a cheap shot at Vikings offensive tackle Brian O'Neill last weekend. The NFL sided with the Vikings The league fined Bosa $28,075 for the illegal blindside block he laid on O'Neill, which also drew a 15-yard penalty. The NFL has emphasized protecting players from blindside blocks this year, and Bosa is one of many players who has been flagged and fined.

NFL playoffs: Who will win Super Bowl LIV?
NFL playoffs: Who will win Super Bowl LIV?

Indeed, the Pats, Denver Broncos, Baltimore Ravens, Pittsburgh Steelers or Indianapolis Colts have represented the AFC in the past 16 Super Bowls, but this year either the Kansas City Chiefs or Tennessee Titans will be in Miami. The NFC has been a more open conference and either the San Francisco 49ers or Green Bay Packers - two of the NFL's most storied organisations - will be the sixth different franchise to win that Championship Game in the past six years. But which team will go on to lift the Lombardi Trophy at Hard Rock Stadium on February 2?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Sports