NFL needs someone who can explain, defend, apologize for questionable calls

  • In Sports/Football
  • 2019-10-15 14:30:02Z
  • By ProFootball Talk on NBC Sports

When it comes to mistakes routinely made by game officials, the NFL is less transparent than construction paper. Fearful of the potential negative impact of admitting what is often obvious, the NFL unreasonably protects officials by never acknowledging their blunders publicly.

This refusal to be candid regarding bad calls hurts the league in various ways. Among other things, it invites the tin-foil hat crowd to think that the league wants certain teams to win, and other teams to lose. Although I'll never believe that happens (indeed, it would be nearly impossible to pull it off seamlessly and even harder to keep someone from blabbing about it in off-the-record discussions, a tell-all book, and/or a deathbed confession), people who are wired to presume the worst will, in the absence of a reasonable, clear, and cogent explanation to the contrary.

So here's the solution: The NFL needs to hire someone who will serve capably as a spokesperson for officiating matters, available to radio shows, TV, podcasts, etc. and willing to face tough questions and to answer them in a way that inspires confidence in the game.

When, for example, officials throw a flag for an illegal hit to the head of a defenseless receiver and broadcasters mistakenly rail against the fact that the defender was simply trying to catch the ball, the officiating spokesperson needs to be able to say, calmly and persuasively, that intent doesn't matter when a defenseless receiver is struck in the head or neck area. When, for example, the officials make a mistake, the officiating spokesperson needs to admit that a mistake was made, explain how and why it happened, and move on.

The league used to have something like an officiating spokesperson when Mike Pereira and, after Carl Johnson, Dean Blandino served as the V.P. of officiating. Pereira and Blandino routinely appeared on NFL Network, and often elsewhere, to discuss candidly the calls that drive fan and media discussion in various formats. Al Riveron isn't available nearly as frequently; instead, he produces periodic, broad-brush social-media videos to explain specific calls of interest, along with a weekly officiating video for the media that rarely addresses the most controversial decisions, highlighting instead examples of proper rules application that involved no mistakes and created no uproar.

The current uproar in the aftermath of Lions-Packers demonstrates how important it is for the league to have someone who can quickly mobilize for day-after interviews, not to spin but to embrace the kind of candid truth that allows fans to realize that, yes, mistakes happen and that, no, it doesn't mean that the league office instructed the officials that it would be preferred for Green Bay to win the game.


More Related News

PGA, NFL stars attract nearly 6 million viewers in TV match
PGA, NFL stars attract nearly 6 million viewers in TV match

Two of the biggest names from the PGA Tour and the NFL proved to be must-see TV. Turner Sports said the Sunday telecast of ''The Match: Champions for Charity'' attracted an average of 5.8 million viewers across four of its networks. Turner says it was the most-watched golf telecast in cable TV history.

How to fix NFL
How to fix NFL's 'broken system' for minority hiring

Peter King dives into the NFL's minority hiring problem and looks at what can be done to fix it.

NFL failed miserably with pass interference replay, Troy Vincent says
NFL failed miserably with pass interference replay, Troy Vincent says

For the first time in 2019, pass interference was reviewable on replay. That worked so poorly that in 2020, it won't be. And NFL Executive Vice President of Football Operations Troy Vincent says the NFL needs to learn from its mistake. Vincent told Peter King for Football Morning in America that the league has to [more]

Dispelling 10 long-standing Eagles myths
Dispelling 10 long-standing Eagles myths

For whatever reason, everyone seems to think these things are true. They're not. Time to dispell some Eagles myths. By Reuben Frank

Why 49ers
Why 49ers' toughest NFC West foe might be Cardinals in 2020 NFL season

The Cardinals could sneak up on the 49ers in 2020.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Football