US supreme court hobbles government power to limit harmful emissions

  • In Politics
  • 2022-06-30 14:38:19Z
  • By The Guardian
Photograph: David Hawxhurst/Alamy
Photograph: David Hawxhurst/Alamy  

The US supreme court has sided with Republican-led states to in effect hobble the federal government's ability to tackle the climate crisis, in a ruling that will have profound implications for the government's overall regulatory power.

In a 6-3 decision that will seriously hinder America's ability to stave off disastrous global heating, the supreme court, which became dominated by rightwing justices under the Trump administration, has opted to support a case brought by West Virginia that demands the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) be limited in how it regulates planet-heating gases from the energy sector.

The case, which was backed by a host of other Republican-led states including Texas and Kentucky, was highly unusual in that it was based upon the Clean Power Plan, an Obama-era strategy to cut emissions from coal-fired power plants that never came into effect. The Biden administration sought to have the case dismissed as baseless given the plan was dropped and has not been resurrected.

Not only was this case about a regulation that does not exist, that never took effect, and which would have imposed obligations on the energy sector that it would have met regardless. It also involves two legal doctrines that are not mentioned in the constitution, and that most scholars agree have no basis in any federal statute.

However, the supreme court has sided with West Virginia, a major coal mining state, which argued that "unelected bureaucrats" at the EPA should not be allowed to reshape its economy by limiting pollution - even though emissions from coal are helping cause worsening flooding, heatwaves and droughts around the world, as well as killing millions of people through toxic air.

"Capping carbon dioxide emissions at a level that will force a nationwide transition away from the use of coal to generate electricity may be a sensible 'solution to the crisis of the day'," wrote Chief Justice John Roberts in the opinion. "But it is not plausible that Congress gave EPA the authority to adopt on its own such a regulatory scheme in Section 111(d). A decision of such magnitude and consequence rests with Congress itself, or an agency acting pursuant to a clear delegation from that representative body."

Roberts was joined by the conservative justices Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett. The three liberal justices, Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Stephen Breyer dissented. It is the most important climate change case to come before the supreme court in more than a decade.

But the ruling could also have sweeping consequences for the federal government's ability to set standards and regulate in other areas, such as clean air and water, consumer protections, banking, workplace safety and public health. It may prove a landmark moment in conservative ambitions to dismantle the "regulatory state", stripping away protections from Americans across a wide range of areas.

It could fundamentally change what the federal government is and what it does. And, as justice Elena Kagan pointed out in her dissent, it could leave technical decisions to a political body that may not understand them.

"First, members of Congress often don't know enough - and know they don't know enough - to regulate sensibly on an issue. Of course, members can and do provide overall direction. But then they rely, as all of us rely in our daily lives, on people with greater expertise and experience. Those people are found in agencies," she wrote.

Several conservatives on the court have criticized what they see as the unchecked power of federal agencies, concerns evident in orders throwing out two Biden policies aimed at reducing the spread of Covid-19.

Last summer, the six-to-three conservative majority ended a pandemic-related pause on evictions over unpaid rent. In January, the same six justices blocked a requirement that workers at large employers be vaccinated or test regularly for the coronavirus and wear a mask on the job.

The Biden administration was supported in the EPA court case by New York and more than a dozen other Democratic-led states, along with prominent businesses such as Apple, Amazon and Google that have called for a swift transition to renewable energy.

The administration has vowed to cut US emissions in half by the end of this decade but has floundered in its attempts to legislate this outcome, with a sweeping climate bill sunk by the opposition of Republican senators and Joe Manchin, the centrist Democratic senator from West Virginia.

The federal government also had the power of administrative regulations in order to force reductions in emissions but the supreme court ruling will now imperil this ability.


More Related News

Oath Keepers to stand trial on charges of seditious conspiracy
Oath Keepers to stand trial on charges of seditious conspiracy
  • US
  • 2022-10-02 09:00:33Z

Group allegedly discussed paramilitary training and 'quick reaction force' to get weapons to Capitol quickly on January 6

Analysis-Mexico data hack exposes government cybersecurity vulnerability
Analysis-Mexico data hack exposes government cybersecurity vulnerability

A major hack into classified government information in Mexico, including thousands of emails from the armed forces, exposed the country's vulnerability to...

Biden signs government funding bill, averting a partial shutdown
Biden signs government funding bill, averting a partial shutdown

The law also provides $12.5 billion in security and financial assistance to Ukraine.

House OKs bill to avert government shutdown, aid Ukraine
House OKs bill to avert government shutdown, aid Ukraine

The Democratic-led House passed a short-term spending bill on Friday that finances the federal government through mid-December and provides another infusion ...

House sends bill to Biden to avert a government shutdown and further aid Ukraine
House sends bill to Biden to avert a government shutdown and further aid Ukraine

President Biden is now expected to sign the bill into law just hours before the midnight deadline to keep the government open.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • dark web links
    (2022-06-30 19:07:02Z)

    That's why you should take all precautions before trying any links to find out if my social security number was found on the dark web. Make sure you research any website you are thinking of using and make sure you use a trusted search engine

  • deep web
    (2022-06-30 19:43:18Z)

    One day, I was in Google and saw that this site was offering something called a white label. This is when you sign up for a site and instead of using your own information, you sign up for a "real" identity

  • dark web links
    (2022-06-30 19:59:04Z)

    Most people just use their name and address and pay for the results. But there is another option where you can actually register an identity with a website.

  • dark web sites
    (2022-06-30 20:33:45Z)

    If you don't, you could end up sharing your social and financial data with a lot of different places and people that you don't even realize are out there.

  • dark web
    (2022-06-30 20:44:16Z)

    There are many reasons why people might want to conduct a social security search; examples of these reasons could include checking up on a new friend you just met or a new neighbor who lives across the street.

  • work from home jobs
    (2022-06-30 21:08:16Z)

    It can be a little intimidating to dive into affiliate marketing success stories on Reddit. There are so many subscribers and users on this community that you would think the information on this site must be thick and cumbersome

  • affiliate marketing success
    (2022-06-30 21:33:52Z)

    Once you find these forums you will need to take a moment to familiarize yourself with the forum etiquette. I'm sure you have heard of the old saying, "don't ask, don't tell". Well this is especially true when it comes to affiliate marketing on the internet


Top News: Politics