Decisions on same-sex marriage, contraception could be threatened by abortion ruling




  • In Business
  • 2021-12-04 12:08:12Z
  • By USA TODAY
Stephen Parlato of Boulder, Colo.
Stephen Parlato of Boulder, Colo.  

WASHINGTON - When the Supreme Court hands down its ruling next year in Mississippi's blockbuster challenge to Roe v. Wade the bulk of the decision will be focused on interpreting what the Constitution says - or doesn't say - about abortion.

But lurking just below the surface of that already fraught debate are questions about other rights experts say could be implicated if the high court overturns its landmark Roe decision, including access to contraception and the legality of same-sex marriage.

That's because the legal principles that the Supreme Court said in 1973 are the basis for the constitutional right to abortion are the same ones it relied on to recognize other rights not explicitly noted in the Constitution but understood by many to be between the lines.

Roe v. Wade: Supreme Court signals support for Mississippi 15-week abortion ban

Impact: Supreme Court's decision in abortion case will affect dozens of states

"There are huge stakes on the question of the right to abortion but that's only part of it," said David Gans with the liberal Constitutional Accountability Center. "There's a giant question about does the 14th Amendment protect basic, fundamental rights even though they're not explicitly laid out in the Bill of Rights or in another part of the Constitution."

A majority of the justices signaled during nearly two hours of argument this week that they are prepared to shift the way the court has viewed abortion for more than a generation, potentially not only upholding Mississippi's ban on the procedure after 15 weeks of pregnancy but perhaps overturning the Roe v. Wade decision itself.

Mississippi says the high court could overturn Roe without relitigating other rights.

"These are cases that draw clear rules: You can't ban contraception, you can't ban intimate romantic relationships between consenting adults," Scott Stewart, Mississippi's solicitor general, told the court about the potential fallout of abandoning Roe. "None of them involve the purposeful termination of a human life."

But that isn't universally accepted, even on the right. Texas Right to Life encouraged the court this year to reconsider same-sex marriage when it looks at abortion. The group's brief targeted two watershed Supreme Court decisions, among others, the 2015 ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges that legalized same-sex marriage nationally and the 2003 ruling in Lawrence v. Texas that invalidated state prohibitions on sodomy.

"This is not to say that the court should announce the overruling of Lawrence and Obergefell if it decides to overrule Roe," the group argued. "But neither should the court hesitate to write an opinion that leaves those decisions hanging by a thread."

Anti-abortion protester holding a cross, demonstrates in front of the U.
Anti-abortion protester holding a cross, demonstrates in front of the U.  

The Constitution doesn't explicitly guarantee a right to abortion, but a 7-2 majority in Roe held that the 14th Amendment's protection of "liberty" includes the right to terminate a pregnancy. Several of the justices in that case drew on another landmark opinion decided eight years earlier that legalized contraception for married couples.

In Griswold v. Connecticut, the Supreme Court invalidated a law that forbid contraception, finding the Bill of Rights created "zones of privacy" for married couples.

The potential for a legal fight over contraception in a post-Roe world may be particularly high, experts say. That's because contraception was at the heart of the 2014 Hobby Lobby case in which the court ruled companies with religious objections cannot be forced to offer insurance for certain birth control methods they equate with abortion.

But access to contraception isn't the only right not specifically included in the text of the Constitution that could be in play. The court in 2015 cited Griswold, Lawrence and other cases and found the 14th Amendment requires states to license same-sex marriages.

During the court's occasionally heated arguments this week, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked about the fate of those decisions if Roe is overturned. A lot of accepted constitutional rights, she noted, are not written into the nation's founding document.

Would those rights also be in jeopardy in some future case, she asked.

Demonstrators rally outside the Supreme Court ahead of arguments in Dobbs v.
Demonstrators rally outside the Supreme Court ahead of arguments in Dobbs v.  

"We have recognized that sense of privacy in people's choices about whether to use contraception or not. We've recognized it in their right to choose who they're going to marry," said Sotomayor, who was nominated to the court by President Barack Obama in 2009. "I fear none of those things are written in the Constitution."

Stewart said those decisions were different in part because they set clear boundaries - a state can't ban contraception for adults or can't prohibit same-sex marriages - and that those rules have proven workable. And marriage broadly - if not same-sex marriage specifically - is deeply rooted in the nation's tradition and history, he said.

Abortion, Stewart told the justices, has by contrast vexed courts for decades.

"He was drawing the substantive distinction that the right to abortion is qualitatively different from these other rights," said O. Carter Snead, law professor at the University of Notre Dame.

That's because abortion, Snead and anti-abortion advocates say, involves ending a life. That assertion, however, immediately runs into another vexing question.

"The issue of when life begins has been hotly debated by philosophers since the beginning of time," Sotomayor noted.

But Snead said the idea that Roe's potential demise would lead to other rights being overturned is more of "a rhetorical strategy than a doctrinal analysis." That's partly because, he said, states would have to pass a law to ban contraception or same-sex marriage - likely a tall order politically even in many of the nation's reddest states.

"I am not aware of any such efforts currently," he said, "and am quite skeptical that there are plans to pursue such state action in the future."

Stewart and Sotomayor debated that very question during arguments.

"Do you think that no state is going to think otherwise, that no people in the population aren't going to challenge those cases in court?" Sotomayor asked.

"Your honor," Stewart responded, "we'll always have a diversity of views."

Sotomayor shot back: "That's the point."

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Abortion fallout: Could same-sex marriage, contraception be next?

COMMENTS

More Related News

Voting rights: Supreme Court to dig into claims of racial gerrymandering in Alabama
Voting rights: Supreme Court to dig into claims of racial gerrymandering in Alabama

A challenge to Alabama's newly drawn congressional districts is one of several cases before the Supreme Court this term that deal with race.

Supreme Court to hear challenge to law that shields internet companies from lawsuits
Supreme Court to hear challenge to law that shields internet companies from lawsuits

The 1996 law shielding internet firms from liability for user-generated content on their platforms has drawn criticism from Republicans and Democrats.

Supreme Court leaves Don Blankenship conviction in place
Supreme Court leaves Don Blankenship conviction in place
  • US
  • 2022-10-03 14:25:16Z

The Supreme Court says it won't review the conviction of former coal CEO Don Blankenship, who was found guilty of conspiring to violate safety standards at...

U.S. Supreme Court rejects Trump ally Lindell
U.S. Supreme Court rejects Trump ally Lindell's defamation case appeal
  • US
  • 2022-10-03 14:01:26Z

Mike Lindell, a prominent ally of former President Donald Trump, must face a $1.3 billion lawsuit by Dominion Voting Systems Inc accusing him of defamation...

Supreme Court to scrutinize U.S. protections for social media
Supreme Court to scrutinize U.S. protections for social media
  • US
  • 2022-10-03 13:59:04Z

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a challenge to federal protections for internet and social media companies freeing them...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • cialis support 365
    (2021-12-04 23:52:02Z)

    buy cialis usa https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis alternative

    REPLY
  • cialis generic
    (2021-12-04 23:57:58Z)

    cialis tadalafil & dapoxetine https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis pills

    REPLY
  • cialis coupon
    (2021-12-05 00:31:50Z)

    cialis price https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis 20mg

    REPLY
  • cialis alternative
    (2021-12-05 00:54:41Z)

    cialis without a doctor prescription https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis price

    REPLY
  • cialis dosage
    (2021-12-05 03:13:05Z)

    buy cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis coupon

    REPLY
  • cialis price
    (2021-12-05 03:51:12Z)

    cialis alternative https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis tablets

    REPLY
  • cialis generic
    (2021-12-05 04:19:24Z)

    cialis tadalafil & dapoxetine https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis pills

    REPLY
  • cialis generic
    (2021-12-05 04:41:18Z)

    cialis 20mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis generic

    REPLY
  • fastest delivery of cialis
    (2021-12-05 06:42:51Z)

    buy cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# generic cialis

    REPLY
  • can ubuy cialis on streets
    (2021-12-05 07:15:12Z)

    cheap cialis https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# buy cialis usa

    REPLY
  • cialis black is it safe
    (2021-12-05 07:15:22Z)

    can ubuy cialis on streets https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis pills

    REPLY
  • cialis with dapoxetine overnight to
    (2021-12-05 08:04:44Z)

    cialis dosage https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis 20 mg

    REPLY
  • cialis support 365
    (2021-12-05 08:29:43Z)

    can i take cialis with daxpoteine https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis coupon

    REPLY
  • cialis generic
    (2021-12-05 08:41:36Z)

    cialis generic https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis alternative

    REPLY
  • can i take cialis with daxpoteine
    (2021-12-05 09:57:12Z)

    can i take cialis with daxpoteine https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription

    REPLY
  • cialis 20mg
    (2021-12-05 10:22:58Z)

    cialis dosage https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis price

    REPLY
  • cialis support 365
    (2021-12-05 10:42:56Z)

    cialis alternative https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • buy cialis usa
    (2021-12-05 10:45:46Z)

    cialis 20 mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# buy cialis online

    REPLY
  • cialis 20mg
    (2021-12-05 11:27:46Z)

    fastest delivery of cialis https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cheap cialis

    REPLY
  • can i take cialis with daxpoteine
    (2021-12-05 11:34:57Z)

    cialis dosage https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis pills

    REPLY
  • cialis 20 mg
    (2021-12-06 16:15:52Z)

    buy cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis tablets

    REPLY
  • can i take cialis with daxpoteine
    (2021-12-06 17:05:47Z)

    buy cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cheap cialis

    REPLY
  • buy cialis online
    (2021-12-06 17:19:14Z)

    cialis generic https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cheap cialis

    REPLY
  • cialis without a doctor prescription
    (2021-12-06 17:36:14Z)

    cialis dosage https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cheap cialis

    REPLY
  • cialis tadalafil & dapoxetine
    (2021-12-06 18:33:30Z)

    can ubuy cialis on streets https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis pills

    REPLY
  • best prices for cialis 20mg
    (2021-12-06 18:37:40Z)

    cialis 20 mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# generic cialis

    REPLY
  • generic cialis
    (2021-12-06 19:49:18Z)

    can ubuy cialis on streets https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis alternative

    REPLY
  • cialis tablets
    (2021-12-06 20:54:06Z)

    cialis generic https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cheap cialis

    REPLY
  • cialis pills
    (2021-12-06 22:40:32Z)

    generic cialis https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis online

    REPLY
  • cheap cialis
    (2021-12-06 23:05:51Z)

    best prices for cialis 20mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • best prices for cialis 20mg
    (2021-12-06 23:28:43Z)

    cialis without a doctor prescription https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cheap cialis
    (2021-12-07 00:21:32Z)

    cialis 20 mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cialis dosage
    (2021-12-07 01:43:08Z)

    cialis alternative https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cialis generic
    (2021-12-07 02:03:43Z)

    cialis 20mg https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription

    REPLY
  • cheap cialis
    (2021-12-07 02:16:40Z)

    cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis online

    REPLY
  • cialis black is it safe
    (2021-12-07 02:30:25Z)

    generic cialis https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cialis support 365
    (2021-12-07 02:49:04Z)

    cialis black is it safe https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis 20mg

    REPLY
  • cialis support 365
    (2021-12-07 03:22:51Z)

    cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cialis black is it safe
    (2021-12-07 03:36:00Z)

    cialis online https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis online

    REPLY
  • cialis black is it safe
    (2021-12-07 03:42:10Z)

    cialis alternative https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# cialis dosage

    REPLY
  • cialis dosage
    (2021-12-07 03:54:35Z)

    cialis pills https://cialiswithdapoxetine.com/# buy cialis online

    REPLY
  • fmcljlzm
    (2022-06-13 12:02:35Z)

    http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine for sale mexico shipping

    REPLY
  • hdehltwc
    (2022-06-13 12:09:53Z)

    buy hydroxychloroquine 200 mg hydroxychloroquine tablets buy hydroxychloroquine mexico pharmacy

    REPLY
  • dtjptcuy
    (2022-06-13 12:26:54Z)

    buy plaquenil 200mg http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • lzbsaflq
    (2022-06-13 12:42:02Z)

    plaquenil tablets buy plaquenil 200mg buy plaquenil pills

    REPLY
  • qnnnqhtl
    (2022-06-13 12:54:12Z)

    https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine tadalafil

    REPLY
  • evgctjll
    (2022-06-13 13:12:02Z)

    http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ how to get hydroxychloroquine prescription

    REPLY
  • pqzlvfqy
    (2022-06-13 13:23:34Z)

    where can i buy plaquenil https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • ngzmkfgy
    (2022-06-13 13:39:56Z)

    https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ buy generic plaquenil online

    REPLY
  • pktwfgdt
    (2022-06-13 13:46:55Z)

    plaquenil pills http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • rtsouarl
    (2022-06-13 14:12:32Z)

    generic plaquenil 200 mg hydroxychloroquine for sale from canada

    REPLY
  • wdnxnjxo
    (2022-06-13 14:16:14Z)

    can hydroxychloroquine be purchased over the counter generic hydroxychloroquine

    REPLY
  • qpxlvajv
    (2022-06-13 14:21:35Z)

    hydroxychloroquine purchase online http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • kjdojeou
    (2022-06-13 14:32:30Z)

    hydroxychloroquine canada online do you need a prescription for hydroxychloroquine

    REPLY
  • wkrvrjva
    (2022-06-13 15:07:03Z)

    http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ plaquenil generic name

    REPLY
  • pkshxikt
    (2022-06-13 15:47:16Z)

    generic name for plaquenil

    REPLY
  • pphbznaa
    (2022-06-13 15:54:35Z)

    hydroxychloroquine without a doctor prescription hydroxychloroquine tablets

    REPLY
  • huuxibyv
    (2022-06-13 16:10:24Z)

    can you get hydroxychloroquine otc hydroxychloroquine pills

    REPLY
  • ksmzyhjt
    (2022-06-13 16:40:42Z)

    buy plaquenil online cheap alberta hydroxychloroquine 200mg for sale buy hydroxychloroquine over the counter

    REPLY
  • zrurbfee
    (2022-06-13 16:53:16Z)

    order plaquenil pills order hydroxychloroquine online buy hydroxychloroquine online cheap dr collins

    REPLY
  • huyxaspy
    (2022-06-13 17:02:04Z)

    https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ plaquenil cheap

    REPLY
  • iufcuoln
    (2022-06-13 17:06:31Z)

    where to get plaquenil buy 200 mg plaquenil

    REPLY
  • glciwjcb
    (2022-06-13 17:26:13Z)

    buy 200mg hydroxychloroquine hydroxychloroquine generic names

    REPLY
  • sdrhtekj
    (2022-06-13 17:27:49Z)

    http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ buy 200mg hydroxychloroquine

    REPLY
  • najquzma
    (2022-06-13 17:50:46Z)

    buy hydroxychloroquine pills http://hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • pnauhkir
    (2022-06-13 17:56:58Z)

    hydroxychloroquine sulfate 200 mg http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/

    REPLY
  • ccrixsqh
    (2022-06-13 18:18:54Z)

    what is hydroxychloroquine where can i buy plaquenil buy generic hydroxychloroquine

    REPLY
  • ildfjssz
    (2022-06-13 18:56:48Z)

    hydroxychloroquine pharmacy hydroxychloroquine where to buy online

    REPLY
  • xyqkwfym
    (2022-06-13 18:58:31Z)

    http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ buy plaquenil for sale kiteboarding

    REPLY
  • unmybthm
    (2022-06-13 19:19:51Z)

    hydroxychloroquine tablets buy online buy hydroxychloroquine online buy plaquenil pill kiteboarding

    REPLY
  • hicpytqc
    (2022-06-13 19:37:31Z)

    buy hydroxychloroquine usa hydroxychloroquine mexico pharmacy

    REPLY
  • eknqahyj
    (2022-06-13 20:21:39Z)

    buy hydroxychloroquine over the counter hydroxychloroquine without a doctor prescription

    REPLY
  • xoewlryw
    (2022-06-13 21:02:21Z)

    https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ order hydroxychloroquine online cheap alberta

    REPLY
  • artutgzg
    (2022-06-13 21:04:38Z)

    https://hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine otc

    REPLY
  • fznopico
    (2022-06-13 22:38:39Z)

    http://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ hydroxychloroquine online sale

    REPLY
  • rxbauzrz
    (2022-06-13 23:13:08Z)

    buy plaquenil canada buy hydroxychloroquine 200mg

    REPLY
  • jautxpth
    (2022-06-13 23:55:44Z)

    hydroxychloroquine tablets hydroxychloroquine sulfate

    REPLY
  • yfpjahtq
    (2022-06-13 23:58:07Z)

    where can one get hydroxychloroquine hydroxychloroquine sulfate over the counter

    REPLY
  • nluoehhs
    (2022-06-14 01:52:48Z)

    hydroxychloroquine hcq over the counter

    REPLY
  • gagrzyfz
    (2022-06-14 01:57:13Z)

    https://www.hydroxychloroquinex.com/ plaquenil

    REPLY
  • fwxroesx
    (2022-06-14 02:04:43Z)

    hydroxychloroquine canada plaquenil stock price

    REPLY

Top News: Business