Judge says the FBI misled FISA court when seeking permission to wiretap a former Trump campaign aide

Judge says the FBI misled FISA court when seeking permission to wiretap a former Trump campaign aide
Judge says the FBI misled FISA court when seeking permission to wiretap a former Trump campaign aide  

WASHINGTON - A secretive court that approves sensitive surveillance issued a rare public rebuke of the FBI on Tuesday, saying the bureau misled the Justice Department and the court when it sought permission to wiretap a former Trump campaign aide.

The FBI's handling of the applications to wiretap Carter Page "was antithetical to the heightened duty of candor" expected of the bureau, Judge Rosemary Collyer of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court wrote in a public opinion released Tuesday.

"The frequency with which representations made by FBI personnel turned out to be unsupported or contradicted by information in their possession, and with which they withheld information detrimental to their case, calls into question whether information contained in other FBI applications is reliable," Collyer wrote.

The judge ordered the FBI to outline by Jan. 10, 2020, any changes it has made or plans to make to improve surveillance allowed under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or FISA. The law, enacted in 1978, outlines procedures investigators must follow when they ask judges for permission to conduct electronic surveillance of people suspected of acting as foreign agents.

Collyer issued the order a week after the Justice Department's watchdog released a damaging report identifying 17 inaccuracies in the applications to wiretap Page in 2016 and 2017. As part of the FBI's inquiry into Russia's efforts to meddle in the 2016 presidential election, investigators conducted surveillance on Page, whom they believed was conspiring with the Russian government.

FISA: A report on FBI surveillance of a former Trump campaign adviser shows dysfunction, not political bias. That's still a problem.

The report debunked claims by the president that the Russia investigation was motivated by political bias. But it revealed a dysfunctional system in which a team of investigators, handpicked to conduct one of the FBI's most sensitive investigations, committed "basic and fundamental errors."

In a statement released late Tuesday afternoon, the FBI said Director Christopher Wray has characterized the inspector general's findings as "unacceptable and unrepresentative" of the bureau.

Wray has ordered more than 40 corrective steps, the FBI said, including some that go beyond what the inspector general recommended.

"FISA is an indispensable tool in national security investigations," the FBI said, "and in recognition of our duty of candor to the court and our responsibilities to the American people, the FBI is committed to working with the FISA court and DOJ to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the FISA process."

The FBI sought four court-ordered wiretaps of Page. Each application contained multiple errors, according to Inspector General Michael Howoritz's report.

Among the most common errors were omissions of important information, including some that contradicted investigators' suspicions that Page was acting as a foreign agent. During Senate testimony last week, Horowitz said the surveillance of Page continued even as investigators gathered new evidence "that weakened the assessment of probable cause."

Horowitz testifies: Review of FBI's surveillance of Trump campaign aide doesn't 'vindicate anybody,' inspector general says

For example, investigators overstated the reliability of a former British intelligence officer whose information they used to justify the warrants. They described Christopher Steele as someone whose information had been "corroborated and used in criminal proceedings." Horowitz's report said that wasn't true.

Investigators didn't provide documentation to back up their assertions to justify the warrants on Page. In some cases, the documents showed their claims were wrong. One supervisor said he didn't necessarily review full documents to make sure they supported what the agents claimed, according to the report.

Horowitz referred a former FBI attorney to prosecutors for possible criminal investigation. The report said the attorney altered an email from a liaison at another government agency confirming that Page had been a source of information. The FBI attorney changed the email to say the opposite, covering up a piece of information that could have undercut the FBI's justification to wiretap Page.

This, Collyer wrote in her order, "gave rise to serious concerns about the accuracy and completeness" of any surveillance warrant applications involving that attorney.

The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court "expects the government to provide complete and accurate information in every filing," Collyer wrote. "Without it, the [court] cannot properly ensure that the government conducts electronic surveillance for foreign intelligence purposes only when there is a sufficient factual basis."

Horowitz's office has started an audit of the FBI's applications for wiretaps like the one used on Page.

Civil rights advocates have called on Congress to reform the surveillance process.

"This is not the first time the government abused its surveillance powers, nor was it the first time the intelligence court was made aware of surveillance abuses," Neema Singh Guliani, the American Civil Liberties Union's senior legislative counsel, said in a written statement.

"Congress must radically reform the FISA process to increase accountability and to ensure there is meaningful opportunity to challenge the government's allegations in FISA applications," she said.

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C. and chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, said reforming FISA will be his priority next year.

"I'll be working with my Republican and Democratic colleagues to reform FISA in a fashion to better protect civil liberties while maintaining our ability to monitor foreign surveillance directed against our economic and national security interests," Graham said in a statement.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: FISA court rebukes FBI over handling of Carter Page surveillance


More Related News

To hunt hackers, FBI works more closely with spy agencies
To hunt hackers, FBI works more closely with spy agencies
  • US
  • 2020-10-01 10:21:45Z

The FBI believes the effort will improve targeting and prosecution of hackers who attack American organizations, even as many continue to escape capture abroad. The decision comes after a year in which the United States' Internet Crime Complaint Center said it received a total of 467,361 complaints, resulting in more than $3.5 billion in losses to individuals and businesses. The FBI's strategy reorganizes the agency's anti cybercrime and foreign cyberespionage workforces.

How the FBI Became a Target of Russian Disinformation
How the FBI Became a Target of Russian Disinformation
  • World
  • 2020-10-01 01:00:08Z

(Bloomberg Opinion) -- Almost a year ago, a former Russia specialist on the National Security Council warned Congress about Russia's nefarious intentions in American politics. The goal of the Russians in 2016, Fiona Hill told the House Intelligence Committee, was to put whoever became president "under a cloud."Not only did the Russians succeed - it was overcast before President Donald Trump even took office - but they also managed to damage the credibility and reputation of the very agency that is supposed to protect against foreign interference in U.S. elections: the Federal Bureau of Investigation.In her testimony last year, Hill warned that the opposition research commissioned by the...

Mexican Senate majority leader favors wiretapping regulation
Mexican Senate majority leader favors wiretapping regulation

A judicial reform in Mexico should include rules to regulate the use of wiretaps and other forms of surveillance, the majority leader in the Mexican Senate said on Tuesday. An earlier wide-reaching judicial reform bill was pulled this year after opponents said measures such as surveillance rules were a risk to privacy. Ricardo Monreal, who leads the ruling National Regeneration Movement (MORENA) party in the upper house, said he hoped a revised version of the bill could be discussed during the current session of Congress, which runs until December.

Sen. Mike Lee Argues FISA Abuse was Inevitable, Demands Statute Be Reformed or Eliminated
Sen. Mike Lee Argues FISA Abuse was Inevitable, Demands Statute Be Reformed or Eliminated

Senator Mike Lee on Wednesday lambasted the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act warrant process, saying the abuse that took place during the FBI's investigation of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia was inevitable given the lack of civil liberties protections included in the statute."You don't install a wasp nest in your child's bedroom and then express surprise when the child gets bitten by wasps. You don't adopt an ex parte process and then express surprise and outrage when it goes completely unsupervised and off the rails," Lee, a member of the the Senate Judiciary Committee, said of the FISA process Wednesday during a hearing of the committee in which former...

GOP lawmakers grill Comey on leadership of Russia probe
GOP lawmakers grill Comey on leadership of Russia probe
  • World
  • 2020-09-30 12:48:57Z

Republican lawmakers on Wednesday confronted former FBI Director James Comey about his oversight of the Trump-Russia investigation during a politically charged hearing that focused attention on problems with the probe that have become a rallying cry for President Donald Trump's supporters. Comey, making his first appearance before Congress since a harshly critical inspector general report on the investigation, acknowledged under questioning that the FBI's process for conducting surveillance on a former Trump campaign adviser was "sloppy" and "embarrassing."

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-05 18:14:59Z)

    play http://cialisoni.com/# - cialis online locate buy online cialis hit

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-08 04:58:21Z)

    last http://cialisle.com/# - buy cialis online approximately cialis online crop

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-09 07:22:34Z)

    concert http://cialisle.com/# - cialis online lifestyle generic cialis online strip
    god https://cialsagen.com/# - viagra online viagra online generic viagra open

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-20 05:19:33Z)

    fighter http://cialisoni.com/# - buy online cialis therefore online cialis spread
    shall https://cialsagen.com/# - viagra online generic viagra what is viagra husband

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-20 18:12:17Z)

    representative http://cialisoni.com/# - cialis tadalafil principal cialis no prescription adapt
    yesterday https://cialsagen.com/# - does generic viagra work generic viagra release date buy viagra suit

  • AHoffGeolla
    (2020-01-21 07:26:13Z)

    development http://cialisle.com/# - cialis 20mg visitor cialis online cigarette
    another https://cialsagen.com/# - sale generic viagra online pills buy cheap viagra on line best place to buy viagra online reviews button

  • lhvzgerzqdcy
    (2020-03-09 03:24:15Z)

    wcwghg click to find out more sidnedafil generico viagra generic 100mg qhrjbc sindilfil cheap viagra cool training

  • fudcftnpyyke
    (2020-03-24 01:19:42Z)

    hxtzxa helpful resources sildenafil citrate buy resource ldwnsi browse around here sildafil citrate Generic Viagra

  • cibrkaxpihon
    (2020-04-18 12:07:00Z)

    uofeil read moreA… sildenafil generic alternative sildenafil citrate online wsmgiq sildenafil synthesis how to buy generic viagra in us silde

  • jxpfdemmlgry
    (2020-05-11 21:34:46Z)

    cialis reviews by men cialis what are the side effects of cialis is there a generic cialis cialis
    cialis pills for men Cialis cialis cialis viagra pills without a doctor's prescription cialis com cialis
    cialis mexico cialis generic without a doctor's prescription cialis generic 5mg taken with viagra Cialis reviews for generic cialis is there a generic drug for cialis yet

  • yccozmwuhnba
    (2020-06-01 23:07:09Z)

    viagra.com canada viagra Viagra
    www viagra com Viagra order viagra from canada buying viagra canada viagra

    canadian pharmacy online viagra Viagra candida viagra sildenafil canadian pharmacy

  • Marielitllovkzewzg
    (2020-06-14 19:26:41Z)

    tadalafil 20mg india cialis pills for men cialis 20 mg lowest price cialis commercial [url=https://www.apolloradio.de/extlink.php?redirect=http://cialisfcanada.com/]online prescription for cialis[/url]
    where' can i buy cialis cialis us cialis online canada purchase cialis without prescription [url=https://mccartney65hals.livejournal.com/1064.html]brand cialis from canada[/url]
    buy cialis online without script generic cialis 40mg cialis do you need a prescription for cialis [url=http://www.hripunova8.ru/go.php?http://cialisfcanada.com/]cialis pills at walmart[/url]
    cialis usa pharmacy canada drug pharmacy buy cialis canada cialis without a doctor [url=http://furnitio.com/go.php?url=http://cialisfcanada.com/]canada cialis[/url]
    female cialis 20mg does cialis work for women buy cialis from canada cialis prescription free [url=https://www.ted.com/profiles/21600507]canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg[/url]

  • montgomery county court case searchfl
    (2020-09-02 02:45:12Z)

    tssiebomclmt maryland court cases search
    pg case search new york unified court system case search palm beach clerk of court case search tucson city courts case search


Top News: Europe