Newly uncovered letter casts doubt over sole testimony in Oklahoma death row




  • In US
  • 2022-08-12 06:00:05Z
  • By The Guardian

A handwritten letter has come to light casting doubt on the critical testimony of a self-confessed murderer who provided the only implicating evidence at the trial of Richard Glossip, a death row inmate in Oklahoma who is to be executed in six weeks' time.

The letter was written in 2007 by Justin Sneed, a motel handyman who by his own admittance bludgeoned to death Barry Van Treese, the owner of a Best Budget, a decade earlier. Sneed's testimony that Glossip, the manager of the motel, had put him up to the murder with a promise of $10,000 was central to the state's case - with no other forensic or corroborating evidence to back it up.

As a result, Glossip was sentenced to death in his second capital trial in 2004. By contrast Sneed, the killer, was given life without parole.

In the handwritten letter, Sneed writes to his own defense lawyer three years later expressing deep anxiety about the case and his role in it. "There are a lot of things right now that are eating at me," he begins.

"Somethings I need to clean up," he goes on. Then he writes: "I think you know were (sic) I'm going it was a mistake reliving this."

The letter was uncovered recently by Reed Smith, an international law firm that was asked by Oklahoma state lawmakers to carry out an independent investigation into the Glossip case. In recent days concern that the state might be about to kill an innocent man has reached fever pitch, with 61 legislators - most of them pro-death penalty Republicans - pleading with the state's attorney general to hold a special hearing to consider the new evidence.

Photo of man in white t shirt smiling
Photo of man in white t shirt smiling  

In its 343-page report, released in June, the law firm revealed that prosecutors had intentionally destroyed crucial evidence before trial in a gross violation of due process. The review concluded that "no reasonable juror hearing the complete record would have convicted Richard Glossip of first-degree murder".

Sneed's newly uncovered letter, contained in a supplemental report released by Reed Smith on Thursday, raises further disturbing questions. What precisely was "eating at" him, and what did he want to "clean up"? Most importantly, what did he mean by "it was a mistake"?

Yet Gina Walker, Sneed's lawyer from the Oklahoma county public defender's office, to whom he wrote the letter, did not raise any of these questions with him. Instead Walker, who died in 2020, effectively closed down the conversation.

"I can tell by the tone of your letter that some things are bothering you," she wrote back to Sneed in August 2007. "I know that it was very hard for you to testify at the second trial."

She went on to accuse Glossip's defense lawyers of trying to talk Sneed out of testifying, saying that went "totally against your best interests to the benefit of their client. Had you refused [to testify], you would most likely be on death row right now."

She added: "I hope [Glossip] has not or his lawyers have not tried to make you feel responsible for the outcome of his case".

Kevin McDugle, a Republican representative in the Oklahoma legislature who has led the call for a pause in the approaching execution, said the letter amounted to compelling new evidence. It strongly suggested, he said, that "Sneed wanted to recant his statement implicating Richard Glossip, and his attorney shut him down".

COMMENTS

More Related News

College football Week 5 odds, opening spreads and new AP Top 25 poll
College football Week 5 odds, opening spreads and new AP Top 25 poll

We're a third of the way through the college football season, and in Week 5 conference play ramps up with several excellent matchups. Here are the opening spreads for every game featuring a team ranked in the new AP top 25 poll.

'A search for the truth.' Trial begins for State College man accused of child rape
  • US
  • 2022-09-26 19:33:47Z

Centre County prosecutors and a defense lawyer sketched dueling portraits of the man as the trial began.

Tennessee
Tennessee's bowl projections following Week 4, win against Florida

A look at Tennessee football's bowl projections following Week 4 and the Vols' win against Florida.

Will U.S. Supreme Court hear another case from Oklahoma linked to McGirt ruling?
Will U.S. Supreme Court hear another case from Oklahoma linked to McGirt ruling?
  • US
  • 2022-09-26 13:00:43Z

U.S. Supreme Court is being urged by Oklahoma to issue a ruling on the definition of 'Indian' under federal criminal law.

Guest column: Oklahoma needs criminal justice reform; poll shows Republicans agree
Guest column: Oklahoma needs criminal justice reform; poll shows Republicans agree
  • US
  • 2022-09-25 15:00:18Z

The message from Oklahoma voters is clear - they support conservative criminal justice reforms that work.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • casinocommunity
    (2022-08-12 10:28:47Z)

    Of course, your article is good enough, casinocommunity but I thought it would be much better to see professional photos and videos together. There are articles and photos on these topics on my homepage, so please visit and share your opinions.

    REPLY

Top News: US