Monsanto: Roundup substantial factor in man's cancer, jury finds in key verdict

  • In Business
  • 2019-03-19 22:09:47Z
  • By The Guardian

A federal jury in San Francisco found Monsanto's Roundup herbicide was a substantial factor in causing the cancer of a California man, in a landmark verdict that could affect hundreds of other cases.

Edwin Hardeman of Santa Rosa was the first person to challenge Monsanto's Roundup in a federal trial and alleged that his exposure to Roundup caused him to develop non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL), a cancer that affects the immune system.

In the next phase of the case, the jury will weigh liability and damages, and Hardeman's lawyers will present arguments about Monsanto's influence on government regulators and cancer research.

During the trial, the 70-year-old Santa Rosa man testified that he had sprayed the herbicide for nearly three decades and at one time got it on his skin before he was diagnosed with cancer. He used the chemical to control weeds and poison oak on his properties, starting in 1986.

Hardeman's case is considered a "bellwether" trial for hundreds of other plaintiffs in the US with similar claims, which means the verdict could affect future litigation and other cancer patients and families. Monsanto, now owned by the German pharmaceutical company Bayer, is facing more than 9,000 similar lawsuits across the US.

The unanimous ruling on Tuesday follows a historic verdict last August in which a California jury in state court ruled that Roundup caused the terminal cancer of Dewayne Johnson, a former school groundskeeper. That jury said Monsanto failed to warn Johnson of Roundup's health hazards and "acted with malice or oppression", awarding Johnson $289m in damages.

Hardeman's trial has been more limited in scope. While Johnson's attorneys argued that Monsanto had "bullied" scientists and fought to suppress negative studies about its product, the federal judge barred Hardeman's lawyers from discussing Monsanto's alleged influence on research and regulations during the hearings.

The US judge Vince Chhabria went so far as to sanction Hardeman's lawyer for bringing up Hardeman's "personal history", referring to internal Monsanto documents, and explaining the process behind various regulatory decisions about glyphosate in her opening remarks. With Hardeman's trial limited to a strict discussion of whether Roundup exposure caused his cancer, his attorneys have argued they were facing a significant disadvantage.

Monsanto has continued to argue that Roundup is safe to use and does not cause NHL.

Although the judge restricted the first part of the trial to a limited discussion of Hardeman's cancer, he issued something of a rebuke of the company in one procedural order last week, saying: "Although the evidence that Roundup causes cancer is quite equivocal, there is strong evidence from which a jury could conclude that Monsanto does not particularly care whether its product is in fact giving people cancer, focusing instead on manipulating public opinion and undermining anyone who raises genuine and legitimate concerns about the issue."

Bayer expects to prevail later in the trial, a spokesperson said following Tuesday's ruling. "We are disappointed with the jury's initial decision, but we continue to believe firmly that the science confirms glyphosate-based herbicides do not cause cancer", spokesman Dan Childs said in a statement. "We are confident the evidence in phase two will show that Monsanto's conduct has been appropriate and the company should not be liable for Mr Hardeman's cancer".

Child also argued the decision would not impact future cases, "because each one has its own factual and legal circumstances".

Jennifer Moore and Aimee Wagstaff, Hardeman's attorneys, said they were prepared to show the jury examples of Monsanto's "bad conduct" in the next phase of the trial. "Now we can focus on the evidence that Monsanto has not taken a responsible, objective approach to the safety of Roundup", they wrote in a statement.

Environmental advocates were quick to celebrate the verdict. Ken Cook, the president of the Environmental Working Group, said the ruling supported previous conclusions that "glyphosate causes cancer in people".

"As similar lawsuits mount, the evidence will grow that Roundup is not safe, and that the company has tried to cover it up", he added.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • StepSuece
    (2019-06-04 03:37:32Z)

    Comparaison Cialis Levitra Amoxil Needs Refrigeration Fast Delivery On Doxycyclene cialis overnight shipping from usa Cheap Viagra Jelly Uk Buy Celexa Uk Cheapest Pharmacy For Viagra

  • StepSuece
    (2019-07-03 05:17:15Z)

    Buy Accutane Mastercard Propecia Dhea Thinning Hair Cheap Vigora cialis 5mg Non Presciption Cephalexin England Study Gonorrhea Amoxicillin Levitra Medicinale

  • StepSuece
    (2019-07-08 17:32:25Z)

    Pastillas Cialis Funciona Viagra Apotheke Nl Side Effects For Cephalexin [url=]achat viagra belgique[/url] Celadrin Singapore Cheap Cialis Online Canadian P Commande Viagra Pfizer

  • StepSuece
    (2019-07-17 23:32:08Z)

    Finasteride Worldwide Proscar Propecia Finasteride Accutaine [url=]viagra[/url] Cialis Sin Receta En Farmacia

  • StevGuaw
    (2019-10-05 19:50:03Z)

    Viagra Sur Homme Precio Cialis Cialis buy priligy Non Prescription Viagra Substitute Where Can I Buy Levaquin No Prescription

  • StevGuaw
    (2020-01-21 14:45:21Z)

    Meds Without Perscription - canadian pharmacy cialis Best Place To Buy Propecia cheap cialis Viagra Prix Paris En Lyon

  • Kelevasia
    (2020-01-28 07:04:33Z)

    Amoxicillin Safe With Metamucil - Cialis Generic Cod Only Stendra In Internet No Doctor Boston Cialis Amoxicillin For Sinus Infection

  • vfbifrags
    (2020-02-10 19:59:30Z)

    coursework writing uk - design and technology gcse coursework design coursework coursework writing help coursework questions

  • grhresorn
    (2020-02-11 12:20:49Z)

    college papers for sale - pay someone to write a paper some to write my paper who can write my paper for me write my paper in 3 hours

  • bslohAulk
    (2020-02-12 05:49:52Z)

    Haldol - Doxazosin Casodex Super P-Force Uroxatral

  • fegochews
    (2020-02-13 07:41:16Z)

    custom essay - essay about service cheapest essay writers top rated essay writing websites mba essay services

  • nuloexall
    (2020-02-14 05:49:30Z)

    Thorazine - Trental Primaquine Sustiva Epitol

  • bukshAulk
    (2020-02-17 16:10:19Z)

    research paper services - buy research paper cheap can i buy a research paper write my research paper help to write a research paper

  • gbolfrags
    (2020-02-19 00:42:12Z)

    write my term papers - term papers help custom written term papers buy custom term paper custom written term papers

  • htbgexall
    (2020-02-19 11:39:44Z)

    thesis proposal writing service - good thesis statement write thesis thesis only phd thesis writing practice

  • htoilesorn
    (2020-03-04 06:43:12Z)

    cash advance loans quick - quick cash loans centrelink quick cash loans complaints does capital one quicksilver have cash advance quick cash loans 1 hour

  • efefchews
    (2020-03-04 08:08:03Z)

    payday loans no credit - low interest payday loans payday loans in uk payday loans quick payday loans colorado

  • hrloesorn
    (2020-03-08 00:55:57Z)

    canadian pharmacy viagra - viagra samples viagra 100mg female viagra viagra pill

  • hrjyhAulk
    (2020-03-08 14:01:43Z)

    viagra price - buy viagra online name brand viagra sample viagra viagra generic

  • fbhfesorn
    (2020-03-10 17:45:34Z)

    viagra 100mg - canadian viagra viagra price viagra without a doctor prescription generic viagra cost

  • nxuqnzef
    (2020-04-25 23:24:15Z)

    coronavirus italie walmart minimum wage coronavirus ‌‌coronavirus drug coronavirus symptoms italy coronavirus

    ms zaandam coronavirus michigan coronavirus coronavirus new york update cdc coronavirus coronavirus aktuell - coronavirus cases

  • yqxubzef
    (2020-04-30 04:17:17Z)

    coronavirus aid checks 3 weeks italy coronavirus ‌‌buy coronavirus katze coronavirus ohio coronavirus

    coronavirus updates today italy coronavirus update coronavirus treatment coronavirus italy update boris johnson coronavirus - ‌‌buy coronavirus

  • zktnmzef
    (2020-05-03 14:52:12Z)

    work at home jobs work from home opportunities walmart to walmart money transfer online how to make money on youtube best ways to make money online

    make money online free work from home jobs work from home data entry how much money do youtubers make make money online - passive income streams

  • okiptvvek
    (2020-05-04 04:10:16Z)

    COVID-19 pills coronavirus in infants coronavirus disease coronavirus in puppies define coronavirus

    coronavirus isolation precautions coronavirus treatment coronavirus canine symptoms of coronavirus in cats human coronavirus - fip coronavirus

  • lnbahzef
    (2020-05-04 09:24:20Z)

    make money from home how did jerry jones make his money sykes work at home online surveys for money make money online

    make extra money how to make money online how does craigslist make money western union online send money make money at home - how does facebook make money

  • bvawcxvek
    (2020-05-04 23:43:46Z)

    rhinovirus vs coronavirus coronavirus sars fip coronavirus coronavirus in humans novel coronavirus

    mers coronavirus coronavirus structure COVID-19 pills bovine coronavirus feline coronavirus test - coronavirus test

  • mtjmyzef
    (2020-05-05 03:12:18Z)

    making money with pornhub how did jerry jones make his money free money online work from home jobs how did jerry jones make his money

    how to make money on youtube send money online real work from home jobs work from home companies make money online from home - make money online free

  • xncirzef
    (2020-05-06 04:55:11Z)

    kirsten vangsness weight loss kevin smith weight loss medi weight loss best weight loss pill golo weight loss

    weight loss calculator healthy snacks for weight loss weight loss diet weight loss calorie calculator aretha franklin weight loss - best diet for weight loss

  • nkkzozef
    (2020-05-06 06:02:55Z)

    cialis online

    cialis buy cialis online - cialis cialis generic

  • khlwqzef
    (2020-05-06 23:49:54Z)

    cheap cialis

    buy cialis online - buy cialis online

  • dvkelzef
    (2020-05-07 14:43:18Z)

    boogie2988 weight loss weight loss plateau best weight loss pills honey boo boo weight loss weight loss tips

    eddie lacy cash for weight loss kelly clarkson weight loss 2018 weight loss golo weight loss weight loss drugs - weight loss

  • giozizef
    (2020-05-07 16:33:38Z)

    generic cialis 20mg

    buy cialis - cialis cialis online

  • vefvqzef
    (2020-05-08 09:28:00Z)

    cialis online

    generic cialis 20mg - buy cialis online

  • rfyzfzef
    (2020-05-08 20:51:36Z)

    yoga for weight loss jorge garcia weight loss weight loss calculator weight loss plan weight loss shakes

    eddie lacy cash for weight loss morning smoothies for weight loss and energy best weight loss pills apple cider vinegar weight loss drink yoga for weight loss - weight loss supplements

  • zyxagzef
    (2020-05-09 03:31:23Z)

    cialis online

    generic cialis online - generic cialis

  • ghfsjzef
    (2020-05-10 23:44:36Z)

    apple cider vinegar for weight loss weight loss quotes keto weight loss unexplained weight loss weight loss meal plan

    best weight loss apps meal plan for weight loss weight loss programs best weight loss program medi weight loss - weight loss before and after

  • aofvgzef
    (2020-05-13 03:55:58Z)

    teva pharmaceuticals generic viagra mister viagra viagra rhino instead of viagra side effects of viagra

    viagra without a doctor prescription fast vitamins that work like viagra viagra viagra penis before and after multiple erections and viagra - viagra

  • jvcmszef
    (2020-05-13 23:16:01Z)

    where to buy viagra pills now in colorado homemade viagra fucking viagra before after viagra buy viagra cialis

    viagra creampie mayo clinic , is viagra good for your heart also, small daily dose ? viagra viagra from canada stepmom helps son viagra boner - viagra

  • kqmlvwaype
    (2020-05-14 17:51:36Z)

    tadalafil biogaran prix vardenafil vs tadalafil cheap tadalafil tadalafil 5 mg tadalafil biogaran prix

    sildenafil vs tadalafil tadalafil generic vs cialis liquid tadalafil tadalafil liquid tadalafil tablets 20 mg - tadalafil dosage

    tadalafil generic cialis 20 mg side effects for tadalafil buy tadalafil online cialis-impuissance tadalafil buy tadalafil online

    cialis generic tadalafil tadalafil prix tadalafil dosage tadalafil 20 mg tablet what is tadalafil - generic tadalafil

  • hxfyxwaype
    (2020-05-15 21:18:11Z)

    tadalafil 20 mg tablet generic tadalafil liquid tadalafil tadalafil powder tadalafil citrate

    tadalafil tablets tadalafil 5mg tadalafil 20mg tadalafil avis tadalafil vs viagra - buy tadalafil online

    tadalafil vs sildenafil tadalafil generic usa tadalafil reviews tadalafil lilly 5mg prix tadalafil vs sildenafil

    tadalafil mylan tadalafil vs viagra tadalafil 5mg tadalafil tablets tadalafil biogaran 20 mg prix - cialis tadalafil

  • gzvfhzef
    (2020-05-16 03:12:47Z)

    how to reduce weight best weight loss pills celine dion weight loss weight loss programs fastest way to lose weight

    lose weight fast healthy smoothies for weight loss how to lose weight quickly weight loss surgery best weight loss pills - healthy diet

  • jrchpwaype
    (2020-05-16 21:11:30Z)

    buy tadalafil tablets tadalafil liquid generic tadalafil tadalafil for women tadalafil 20mg prix

    tadalafil 20 mg best price tadalafil side effects tadalafil dosage generic for cialis tadalafil tadalafil 20 mg tablet - liquid tadalafil

    tadalafil cost cvs tadalafil 5mg prix cheap tadalafil cialis-impuissance tadalafil tadalafil 40 mg

    tadalafil generique en pharmacie tadalafil liquid tadalafil 20mg tadalafil generic tadalafila - tadalafil 20mg

  • hbddwwaype
    (2020-05-17 21:13:01Z)

    generic tadalafil generic for cialis tadalafil cheap tadalafil prix tadalafil tadalafil for women

    tadalafil reviews tadalafil 20 mg wirkungsdauer tadalafil liquid cheap tadalafil generic cialis tadalafil 20mg - tadalafil 20 mg

    tadalafil lilly 5mg prix side effects for tadalafil buy tadalafil online side effects for tadalafil tadalafil pronunciation

    liquid tadalafil tadalafil powder cialis tadalafil tadalafil 20 mg best price tadalafil for women - tadalafil dosage

  • mqyyvzef
    (2020-05-20 11:35:49Z)

    vardenafil levitra levitra 10mg viagra vs cialis levitra generic levitra com

    levitra 20mg online levitra cialis 20mg levitra price online levitra - buy levitra online

  • sbbwnwaype
    (2020-05-20 20:42:38Z)

    testosterone supplements for men increase testosterone naturally low testosterone testosterone nation francine niyonsaba testosterone condition

    how to boost testosterone testosteron testosterone gel low testosterone la testosterone - testosterone definition

  • rewmdzef
    (2020-05-22 07:06:53Z)

    order levitra levitra 20 generic levitra online vardenafil levitra levitra

    viagra vs cialis vardenafil levitra levitra online levitra levitra coupon - levitra pills

  • dccucwaype
    (2020-05-22 17:49:38Z)

    que es testosterona testosterone pellets best testosterone supplements for men androgel testosterone propionate que es la testosterona

    male hormones boost testosterone naturally testosterone booster how to increase testosterone naturally testosterone booster reviews - what is testosterone

  • hlnbwwaype
    (2020-05-30 00:32:58Z)

    avg free antivirus windows antivirus - avastsvc.exe avast antivirus service george zimmerman dating apps adult dating sites - free dating pch sweepstakes #8800 hgtv sweepstakes 2019 - the balance sweepstakes


Top News: Business