Justices raise doubts on race-conscious college admissions

  • In World
  • 2022-10-31 04:06:23Z
  • By Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) - The survival of affirmative action in higher education appeared to be in serious trouble Monday at a conservative-dominated Supreme Court after hours of debate over difficult questions of race.

The court is weighing challenges to admissions programs at the University of North Carolina and Harvard that use race among many factors in seeking a diverse student body.

The court's six conservative justices all expressed doubts about the practice, while the three liberals defended the programs, which are similar to those used by many other private and public universities.

Arguments in the North Carolina case topped 2 hours and 45 minutes, having been scheduled for 90 minutes.

Following the overturning of the half-century abortion precedent of Roe v. Wade in June, the cases offer a big new test of whether the court now dominated 6-3 by conservatives will jolt the law to the right on another of the nation's most contentious cultural issues.

Justice Clarence Thomas, the court's second Black justice who has a long record of opposition to affirmative action programs, noted he didn't go to racially diverse schools. "I've heard the word 'diversity' quite a few times, and I don't have a clue what it means," the conservative justice said at one point. At another, he challenged defenders: "Tell me what the educational benefits are."

Justice Amy Coney Barrett, another conservative, pointed to one of the court's previous affirmative action cases and said it anticipated a halt to its use in declaring that it was "dangerous" and had to have an end point. When, she asked, is that end point?

Justice Samuel Alito likened affirmative action to a race in which a minority applicant gets to "start five yards closer to the finish line." But liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the court's first Hispanic justice, rejected that comparison saying what universities are doing is looking at students as a whole.

Likewise, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, the court's newest justice and its first Black woman, also said that race was being used at the University of North Carolina as part of a broad review of applicants along 40 different factors.

"They're looking at the full person with all of these characteristics," she said.

Justice Elena Kagan called universities the "pipelines to leadership in our society" and suggested that without affirmative action minority enrollment will drop.

"I thought part of what it meant to be an American and to believe in American pluralism is that actually our institutions, you know, are reflective of who we are as a people in all our variety," she said.

The Supreme Court has twice upheld race-conscious college admissions programs in the past 19 years, including just six years ago.

But that was before the three appointees of former President Donald Trump joined. Jackson was chosen this year by President Joe Biden.

Lower courts have upheld the programs at both UNC and Harvard, rejecting claims that the schools discriminated against white and Asian-American applicants.

The cases are brought by conservative activist Edward Blum, who also was behind an earlier affirmative action challenge against the University of Texas as well as the case that led the court in 2013 to end the use of a key provision of the landmark Voting Rights Act.

Blum formed Students for Fair Admissions, which filed the lawsuits against both schools in 2014.

The group argues that the Constitution forbids the use of race in college admissions and calls for overturning earlier Supreme Court decisions that said otherwise.

Colleges and universities can use other, race-neutral ways to assemble a diverse student body, including by focusing on socioeconomic status and eliminating the preference for children of alumni, Students for Fair Admissions argues.

The schools contend that they use race in a limited way, but that eliminating it as a factor altogether would make it much harder to achieve a student body that looks like America.

The Biden administration is urging the court to preserve race-conscious admissions. The Trump administration had taken the opposite position in earlier stages of the cases.

UNC says its freshman class is about 65% white, 22% Asian American, 10% Black and 10% Hispanic. The numbers add to more than 100% because some students report belonging to more than one category, a school spokesman said.

White students are just over 40% of Harvard's freshman class, the school said. The class also is just under 28% Asian American, 14% Black and 12% Latino.

Nine states already prohibit any consideration of race in admissions to their public colleges and universities: Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Michigan, Nebraska, New Hampshire, Oklahoma and Washington.

In 2020, California voters easily rejected a ballot measure to bring back affirmative action.

Public opinion on the topic varies depending on how the question is asked. A Gallup Poll from 2021 found 62% of Americans in favor of affirmative action programs for racial minorities. But in a Pew Research Center survey in March, 74% of Americans, including majorities of Black and Latino respondents, said race and ethnicity should not factor into college admissions.

Jackson and Chief Justice John Roberts received their undergraduate and law degrees from Harvard. Two other justices went to law school there.

Jackson is sitting out the Harvard case because she was until recently a member of an advisory governing board there.

A decision in the affirmative action cases is not expected before late spring.


More Related News

Federal appeals court strikes down domestic violence gun law
Federal appeals court strikes down domestic violence gun law
  • World
  • 2023-02-03 02:14:44Z

A federal appeals court ruled Thursday that the government can't stop people who have domestic violence restraining orders against them from owning guns...

US tracking suspected Chinese surveillance balloon
US tracking suspected Chinese surveillance balloon

Pentagon officials say they have decided against blowing the alleged spy craft out of the sky - for now.

With rare China trip, Blinken aims to steady rocky relationship
With rare China trip, Blinken aims to steady rocky relationship

(Reuters) -When U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken meets his Chinese counterpart in Beijing next week there will be plenty to disagree about, from Taiwan...

Gwen Moore invites former Bucks player Sterling Brown to State of the Union to call attention to police violence
Gwen Moore invites former Bucks player Sterling Brown to State of the Union to call attention to police violence
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 21:47:22Z

U.S. Rep. Gwen Moore has invited ex Bucks player Sterling Brown to attend the State of the Union in an attempt to call attention to police violence.

People under domestic violence orders can own guns -U.S. appeals court rules
People under domestic violence orders can own guns -U.S. appeals court rules
  • US
  • 2023-02-02 21:37:31Z

A U.S. appeals court on Thursday declared unconstitutional a federal law making it a crime for people under domestic violence restraining orders to own...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • Ivdiur
    (2022-11-04 22:27:20Z)

    calcitriol 0.25mg us cheap calcitriol 0.25mg rocaltrol tablet

  • Uewhuo
    (2022-11-05 01:29:58Z)

    calcitriol price calcitriol us rocaltrol 0.25mg oral

  • Yndelr
    (2022-11-08 05:13:51Z)

    azithromycin 500mg drug where can i buy prednisolone generic gabapentin 800mg

  • Dbdmbn
    (2022-11-09 08:01:24Z)

    furosemide over the counter order furosemide online ivermectin 12mg over the counter

  • Mcxloj
    (2022-11-10 11:16:43Z)

    purchase plaquenil without prescription cheap metformin ivermectin 15 mg

  • Aebhzf
    (2022-11-11 18:35:29Z)

    lipitor drug sildenafil medication order sildenafil online cheap

  • Dhpfrg
    (2022-11-12 21:17:58Z)

    buy lisinopril pill amlodipine 5mg price order tadalafil without prescription

  • Uribsn
    (2022-11-13 23:57:14Z)

    buy metoprolol sale buy generic levitra methylprednisolone 16mg over counter

  • Hfiots
    (2022-11-16 08:09:02Z)

    purchase aristocort online cheap cost aristocort 10mg priligy 30mg price

  • Lksxjv
    (2022-11-17 18:39:21Z)

    order misoprostol pill buy xenical 60mg pill buy synthroid 100mcg pills

  • Mvwqbj
    (2022-11-19 16:13:18Z)

    zovirax online order allopurinol 100mg for sale buy allopurinol 100mg generic

  • Zgyqje
    (2022-11-21 16:19:36Z)

    crestor 10mg tablet buy crestor 10mg sale tetracycline order

  • Snoucb
    (2022-11-23 11:33:36Z)

    purchase baclofen without prescription order sildenafil 100mg pills order viagra 150mg online cheap

  • Gpytem
    (2022-11-25 07:18:41Z)

    buy generic cialis 40mg tadalafil oral buy toradol without prescription

  • Heygkw
    (2022-11-25 14:36:55Z)

    buy cialis 5mg pills overnight delivery cialis buy toradol 10mg generic

  • Blxgae
    (2022-11-27 21:19:06Z)

    buy gloperba sale order plavix for sale order generic methotrexate 5mg

  • Lznvcr
    (2022-11-29 21:37:46Z)

    buy losartan 25mg without prescription topamax tablet sumatriptan 25mg tablet

  • Gugstb
    (2022-12-02 09:50:03Z)

    buy avodart 0.5mg without prescription buy avodart 0.5mg sale zofran pills

  • Haneew
    (2022-12-03 17:33:07Z)

    order aldactone 100mg generic order spironolactone sale diflucan 100mg uk

  • Linnlm
    (2022-12-05 00:54:48Z)

    buy ampicillin 500mg for sale buy erythromycin sale erythromycin 250mg price

  • Rthxvj
    (2022-12-06 08:16:44Z)

    sildenafil 100mg without prescription buy sildenafil 100mg generic methocarbamol 500mg pill

  • Cfwsul
    (2022-12-07 15:40:08Z)

    sildenafil 100mg us estrace over the counter estradiol 1mg canada

  • Qiahlz
    (2022-12-08 21:49:38Z)

    buy lamotrigine 50mg online cheap buy tretinoin cream without prescription tretinoin price

  • Ksclmu
    (2022-12-10 02:42:10Z)

    tadalis 10mg brand order diclofenac 50mg online order diclofenac 100mg pills

  • Pgagcj
    (2022-12-11 01:57:30Z)

    buy accutane sale accutane 20mg pills order zithromax 500mg generic

  • Jvnlfa
    (2022-12-11 07:57:30Z)

    buy indocin 50mg online order generic trimox 250mg trimox 250mg tablet

  • Nypwjc
    (2022-12-12 14:41:04Z)

    buy tadalafil 40mg pill cialis coupons sildenafil for men

  • Jqamlf
    (2022-12-12 19:10:37Z)

    order generic arimidex 1 mg fedeltry healthcare viagra cheap sildenafil without prescription

  • Fxwfnp
    (2022-12-13 21:13:59Z)

    cialis 40mg en france tadalafil 40mg pas cher sildenafil 50mg generique pas cher

  • Wpfhsh
    (2022-12-13 22:51:04Z)

    buy prednisone pill real viagra pills order viagra 100mg generic

  • Hgunub
    (2022-12-15 10:14:05Z)

    cialis 20mg für frauen original viagra 100mg rezeptfrei sicher kaufen viagra 50mg für männer

  • Duntzp
    (2022-12-15 23:16:13Z)

    isotretinoin 10mg sale purchase stromectol online cheap ivermectin drug

  • Rfwdpy
    (2022-12-16 13:52:45Z)

    provigil oral Buy cialis generic acetazolamide 250 mg pill

  • Bihjqc
    (2022-12-17 02:09:47Z)

    doxycycline cost cheap clomiphene 100mg furosemide for sale online

  • Bwvgpo
    (2022-12-17 10:53:48Z)

    buy ramipril generic order azelastine 10ml sale azelastine order

  • Jtveti
    (2022-12-18 05:19:46Z)

    clonidine online antivert 25mg without prescription order generic tiotropium bromide

  • Jtygmg
    (2022-12-18 15:02:25Z)

    buspar brand dilantin for sale online ditropan 5mg oral

  • Jwpgpc
    (2022-12-19 09:06:23Z)

    hytrin online order hytrin cheap purchase azulfidine online cheap

  • Kziwop
    (2022-12-19 19:44:16Z)

    alendronate 70mg drug buy famotidine 40mg pill buy famotidine

  • Ogpmbq
    (2022-12-20 13:23:51Z)

    benicar 10mg tablet divalproex tablet buy acetazolamide 250mg online cheap

  • Swxvso
    (2022-12-21 00:21:07Z)

    tacrolimus 1mg price urso price ursodiol buy online

  • Djpjlo
    (2022-12-21 17:29:22Z)

    order isosorbide 40mg sale azathioprine online order telmisartan 80mg online cheap

  • Ixmswz
    (2022-12-22 05:57:42Z)

    bupropion tablet cetirizine medication buy seroquel 50mg pill

  • Fticee
    (2022-12-23 02:02:17Z)

    buy molnunat 200mg sale lansoprazole buy online prevacid online order

  • Styfde
    (2022-12-23 15:19:10Z)

    buy sertraline pills buy sildenafil 100mg generic buy viagra 100mg online

  • Tvpbpb
    (2022-12-24 04:58:11Z)

    order imuran 100 mcg sale buy sildenafil 50mg generic purchase sildenafil generic

  • Pulajo
    (2022-12-24 19:47:29Z)

    cialis online order buy viagra discover card viagra 50mg over the counter

  • Rcxceh
    (2022-12-25 07:44:11Z)

    cheap generic tadalafil tadalafil for sale online order amantadine sale

  • Pblxbw
    (2022-12-25 23:57:26Z)

    oral revia 50mg order albendazole 400mg online order abilify 30mg without prescription

  • Tmtdqb
    (2022-12-26 11:45:26Z)

    order avlosulfon 100mg pills nifedipine 10mg drug aceon 8mg drug

  • Npesqc
    (2022-12-27 04:08:43Z)

    buy medroxyprogesterone pill cyproheptadine canada cyproheptadine 4 mg generic

  • Rldaza
    (2022-12-28 01:12:58Z)

    buy provigil 200mg online cheap modafinil uk ivermectin for sale

  • Fdrxdb
    (2022-12-28 08:11:47Z)

    buy luvox ketoconazole 200 mg drug order glipizide

  • Ejuwzh
    (2022-12-29 05:56:52Z)

    accutane generic order amoxicillin online cheap generic prednisone 5mg

  • Thanoi
    (2022-12-29 20:49:13Z)

    piracetam 800 mg generic nootropil pills sildenafil usa

  • Ydiogv
    (2022-12-30 09:43:17Z)

    zithromax cheap neurontin online order gabapentin 600mg online cheap

  • Cfwdmh
    (2022-12-31 00:39:07Z)

    cialis online canada cialis price walmart viagra pills 50mg

  • Prxnlf
    (2022-12-31 13:36:15Z)

    lasix online order order hydroxychloroquine 200mg online cheap cheap plaquenil 200mg

  • Gqslmm
    (2023-01-01 03:53:51Z)

    tadalafil over counter brand clomipramine anafranil 50mg cheap

  • Emvzjo
    (2023-01-01 16:57:22Z)

    buy chloroquine 250mg online cheap cenforce 100mg without prescription baricitinib 4mg cheap

  • Caslxz
    (2023-01-02 08:35:42Z)

    sporanox 100 mg canada cheap tinidazole 500mg generic tinidazole

  • Ccqgpy
    (2023-01-02 21:02:04Z)

    order glycomet generic glycomet 1000mg over the counter order tadalafil sale

  • Pvoier
    (2023-01-03 12:39:58Z)

    olanzapine usa brand olanzapine 10mg diovan drug

  • Bxkvmc
    (2023-01-04 01:04:40Z)

    order amlodipine 10mg online amlodipine 5mg for sale cialis brand

  • Uxjhcu
    (2023-01-04 16:50:05Z)

    buy generic clozaril 100mg ipratropium 100 mcg pill decadron brand

  • Ujeolm
    (2023-01-05 05:17:51Z)

    buy viagra pfizer viagra order lisinopril

  • Qxkvbv
    (2023-01-05 21:04:31Z)

    buy linezolid 600mg black jack card game free live dealer blackjack

  • Bqtxmw
    (2023-01-06 09:29:22Z)

    omeprazole 10mg brand best essay writing websites jackpot party casino

  • Xkizzb
    (2023-01-07 13:11:40Z)

    lopressor 50mg pills brand vardenafil 20mg buy levitra without prescription

  • Tvqdlp
    (2023-01-08 14:11:02Z)

    buy custom research papers play online casino real money online gambling casinos

  • Fqelou
    (2023-01-09 02:44:35Z)

    order levitra 20mg generic medrol uk medrol without prescription

  • Cguodz
    (2023-01-09 20:12:16Z)

    order essays online money can t buy everything essay cheap sildenafil pills

  • Koaigy
    (2023-01-10 08:38:47Z)

    clomid 100mg cost big fish casino online roulette wheel online

  • Apdplu
    (2023-01-11 10:36:52Z)

    cialis overnight cialis 10mg uk sildenafil canada

  • Zvjwfd
    (2023-01-11 14:23:26Z)

    triamcinolone 4mg sale order aristocort 4mg pills clarinex 5mg pills

  • Ejatoa
    (2023-01-12 19:42:02Z)

    order priligy 60mg order synthroid pill levothyroxine canada

  • Gvjetz
    (2023-01-12 21:18:07Z)

    cialis 10mg pill viagra 50mg tablet order generic sildenafil 100mg

  • Apspgd
    (2023-01-14 01:19:56Z)

    orlistat pill zovirax brand buy zovirax 400mg for sale

  • Wgazyh
    (2023-01-14 01:41:20Z)

    cheap tadalafil pills cheap propranolol clopidogrel 150mg price

  • Fqaqyz
    (2023-01-15 05:33:08Z)

    allopurinol ca ezetimibe 10mg drug zetia 10mg oral

  • Zxgjon
    (2023-01-15 19:40:32Z)

    methotrexate 10mg brand order metoclopramide 20mg generic order reglan 20mg generic

  • Yyvnjh
    (2023-01-16 10:07:06Z)

    domperidone online order order flexeril 15mg online cost cyclobenzaprine

  • Xkwsyq
    (2023-01-17 00:09:05Z)

    order losartan 25mg online cheap losartan oral order topamax 100mg online

  • Zfwzzi
    (2023-01-17 14:59:03Z)

    baclofen 25mg uk toradol pills buy ketorolac pills

  • Kohfgr
    (2023-01-18 04:45:10Z)

    brand imitrex 25mg order avodart 0.5mg without prescription order avodart generic

  • Xovdhl
    (2023-01-18 20:04:16Z)

    gloperba generic free games poker online online casinos for real money

  • Hrbatl
    (2023-01-19 09:42:23Z)

    order zantac 150mg celebrex 200mg us order celebrex 100mg online

  • Xicyrh
    (2023-01-20 01:14:08Z)

    online casino usa real money play roulette free for fun money slots

  • Tujyrb
    (2023-01-20 14:34:31Z)

    tamsulosin 0.2mg tablet buy aldactone 100mg generic buy spironolactone 100mg generic

  • Vventl
    (2023-01-21 15:03:54Z)

    tadalafil 5mg price order tadalafil 10mg sale cipro 500mg pill

  • Pdnxyg
    (2023-01-22 11:08:54Z)

    order simvastatin 10mg pill order finasteride 5mg propecia 5mg pills

  • Gqohzv
    (2023-01-22 19:50:58Z)

    metronidazole 200mg oral flagyl 200mg pills buy sulfamethoxazole

  • Fsgpgv
    (2023-01-23 15:51:51Z)

    buy fluconazole 100mg pill order diflucan 200mg for sale viagra buy online

  • Jfvepe
    (2023-01-24 00:47:36Z)

    keflex 250mg brand buy erythromycin 500mg erythromycin 500mg uk

  • Vukdtk
    (2023-01-25 02:20:36Z)

    sildenafil without prescription purchase sildenafil online order tadalafil 10mg without prescription

  • Ojawou
    (2023-01-25 22:57:26Z)

    order ceftin 500mg for sale methocarbamol canada cheap methocarbamol

  • RandallHix
    (2023-01-26 09:58:22Z)

    Hello bro!Show more!
    пансионат для пожилых людей
    Пансионат для пожилых людей - это тип жилья для престарелых, где они могут жить независимо, но получать регулярную медицинскую и социальную помощь. Пансионаты обычно оборудованы спальнями и комнатами для общения, а также обеспечивают питание, гигиену и уборку. В некоторых случаях может быть предоставлена реабилитация и развлекательные мероприятия. Пансионаты могут быть общественными или частными и обычно имеют высокую оплату за жилье и услуги.
    сеть пансионатов

    http://images.google.ca/url?q=https://pansionat-rnd.ru/ http://maps.google.com/url?q=https://pansionat-rnd.ru/ http://images.google.com.bh/url?q=https://pansionat-rnd.ru/ http://www.google.dj/url?q=https://pansionat-rnd.ru/ http://cse.google.jo/url?q=https://pansionat-rnd.ru/

  • Owvhhk
    (2023-01-26 15:03:00Z)

    gambling site poker online for money tadalafil over counter

  • Kkuunu
    (2023-01-27 08:18:12Z)

    desyrel pills suhagra 50mg generic aurogra ca

  • Drhyhk
    (2023-01-28 02:40:30Z)

    pay for assignments essay writing ivermectin 4 tablets price

  • Ahobxg
    (2023-01-28 13:05:20Z)

    sildenafil next day delivery usa sildalis cost lamictal cost

  • Molugj
    (2023-01-29 13:18:00Z)

    order deltasone pills order deltasone 20mg generic amoxicillin pills

  • Xhfbku
    (2023-01-29 18:19:39Z)

    viagra 100mg sildenafil 100mg pills for men generic for cialis

  • Tljvli
    (2023-01-31 01:30:44Z)

    online casinos usa roulette online free order tadalafil 40mg for sale

  • Iaoweu
    (2023-01-31 02:26:40Z)

    azithromycin 500mg over the counter azithromycin 250mg canada neurontin 600mg for sale

  • Wdiwam
    (2023-02-01 16:24:21Z)

    play casino buy generic modafinil modafinil 200mg for sale

  • Knfhfa
    (2023-02-01 20:11:48Z)

    lasix canada cost doxycycline 200mg order plaquenil 200mg generic


Top News: World