Judges declare Ohio's congressional map unconstitutional

  • In Business
  • 2019-05-03 21:00:20Z
  • By Associated Press

CINCINNATI (AP) - A panel of federal judges ruled Friday that Ohio's congressional districts were unconstitutionally drawn by the Republicans for their political advantage, and it ordered a new map for the 2020 elections.

The ruling, if it stands, could prove an important victory for the Democrats, who are hoping redrawn boundaries will not only help them pick up House seats but also energize voters and boost turnout in this longtime battleground state, helping them defeat President Donald Trump. Republican officials said they would appeal.

The panel unanimously declared the current map an "unconstitutional partisan gerrymander," saying the GOP-controlled Ohio Legislature put the Democrats at a disadvantage by packing lots of them into four districts and scattering the rest across the remaining 12.

"Democratic candidates must run a significantly longer distance to get to the same finish line," the judges wrote in a 301-page ruling.

The Republicans hold a 12-4 advantage in Ohio's congressional delegation under the current map, which went into effect for the 2012 elections.

The Supreme Court, which is already considering a gerrymandering case that could lead to a major decision on how far politicians can go in drawing districts. It involves challenges to congressional maps in North Carolina, drawn by Republicans, and Maryland, created by Democrats.

Republican Attorney General Dave Yost said he will seek to stay the court order while appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court. He also pointed out in an emailed statement that Ohioans have already approved mapmaking reforms that will be in effect for redistricting after the 2020 U.S. Census.

He called the opinion "a fundamentally political act that has no basis whatsoever in the Constitution."

Some Democrats have said that after years of lopsided congressional races, newly competitive districts could generate voter excitement in a state that Trump won in 2016 after Barack Obama carried it twice. And that, in turn, could influence the White House race.

"That could very well change the turnout for the presidential race," said Ohio Democratic Party chairman David Pepper said. "It's a bad day for Republicans in Washington, and it's a bad day for Donald Trump."

The Republican Party state chairwoman called the challenge to the map "a partisan political ploy." Jane Timken said in an emailed statement: "When Democrats can't win at the ballot box, they try to change the rules."

The judges - two nominated by Democratic presidents, one by a Republican - ordered a proposed new map by June 20. They heard arguments in U.S. District Court in Cincinnati in March.

Voters' rights and Democratic groups had sued Ohio Republican officials, saying redistricting after the 2010 census yielded a map that has produced an impenetrable GOP advantage. Among the examples cited was Cincinnati, a Democrat-dominated city split into two districts, both held by Republicans.

Another example was Ohio's 9th Congressional District, which stretches in a long skinny line along Lake Erie and has been dubbed "the Snake on the Lake." The judges described it as "a bizarre, elongated sliver of a district that severed numerous counties."

Attorneys for the Republicans said the map was drawn with bipartisan support. Before it took effect, the GOP held a 13-5 advantage in Ohio's congressional delegation. (Each party later lost one seat when the state's representation in Congress was reduced because of population shifts.)

"This is called democracy in action," said GOP attorney Phil Strach, adding that both parties supported "incumbency protection" - or making it more likely an incumbent will win - because that benefits all Ohioans by giving their delegation more clout in Washington.

In a case similar to Ohio's, a three-judge panel ruled last week that Michigan's congressional and legislative maps were unconstitutionally gerrymandered, and ordered the state Legislature to redraw some districts for 2020. The judges wrote that the GOP created districts in 2011 with the goal of ensuring "durable majorities" for Republicans. Republicans have appealed that ruling.

The lawsuit challenging Ohio's map called it "one of the most egregious gerrymanders in recent history," one that has reliably done its job by allowing the GOP to capture 75% of the seats by winning a little more than half the state's votes.

The longest-serving woman in House history was among the plaintiffs' witnesses. Nineteen-term Rep. Marcy Kaptur of Toledo said her district, the elongated 9th, was "hacked apart," forcing her into a Democratic primary with veteran Rep. Dennis Kucinich of Cleveland in 2012. She won, knocking him out of Congress.


Associated Press writer Julie Carr Smyth in Columbus contributed to this report.


Follow Dan Sewell at https://www.twitter.com/dansewell


More Related News

Trump Sows Doubt on Voting. It Keeps Some People Up at Night.
Trump Sows Doubt on Voting. It Keeps Some People Up at Night.

WASHINGTON -- In October, President Donald Trump declares a state of emergency in major cities in battleground states, like Milwaukee and Detroit, banning polling places from opening.A week before the election, Attorney General William Barr announces a criminal investigation into the Democratic presidential nominee, Joe Biden.After Biden wins a narrow Electoral College victory, Trump refuses to accept the results, won't leave the White House and declines to allow the Biden transition team customary access to agencies before the Jan. 20 inauguration.Far-fetched conspiracy theories? Not to a group of worst-case scenario planners -- mostly Democrats, but some anti-Trump Republicans as well...

Trump claims Jeff Sessions not
Trump claims Jeff Sessions not 'mentally qualified' to be AG as feud escalates

Trump's criticism of his former appointee is just the latest in a yearslong battle with Sessions.

Trump deems churches
Trump deems churches 'essential,' calls for them to reopen
  • World
  • 2020-05-22 18:02:42Z

President Donald Trump said Friday that he has deemed churches and other houses of worship "essential" and called on governors across the country to allow them to reopen this weekend, even as some parts of the nation remain under coronavirus lockdown. "Today I'm identifying houses of worship - churches, synagogues and mosques - as essential places that provide essential services," Trump said during a hastily arranged press conference at the White House. Trump said that, "governors need to do the right thing and allow these very important essential places of faith to open right now, for this weekend."

Joe Biden, in testy interview, says
Joe Biden, in testy interview, says 'you ain't black' if you're undecided over him vs. Trump

Joe Biden, in a testy exchange with radio host Charlamagne tha God, said "you ain't black" if you're undecided on whether to back him or Trump.

Trump attacks Michigan AG after she calls him a
Trump attacks Michigan AG after she calls him a 'petulant child' over mask dispute

Trump said it wasn't Ford's fault he did not wear a mask during much of the tour. "I did put on a mask" out of the view of the news media, he added.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


  • dovsekphszvp
    (2019-06-02 03:06:21Z)


  • hayyxlvjamsg
    (2019-08-24 15:44:56Z)

    b5980k u3808i l5749n VIDEO http://bitly.com/2HpG7Pk watch

  • ixtxvizobtkc
    (2019-08-27 18:38:07Z)

    l4213n b1381h c7760a VIDEO https://00-tv.com/sitemap/sitemap8145.php watch

  • doeonuwlvhyq
    (2019-08-27 22:40:48Z)

    n9637q d11690h h13061q VIDEO https://00-tv.com/sitemap/sitemap4914.php watch

  • uxcnomzazmuf
    (2019-08-27 23:37:20Z)

    x11954f f8342h j9966j VIDEO https://00-tv.com/sitemap/sitemap9617.php watch

  • cialis price
    (2019-11-23 00:15:36Z)

    order cialis europe
    is there a generic for cialis
    cialis pills dosage

  • WkCa.cocz
    (2019-12-01 17:49:16Z)

    cialis 2.5mg pills viagra buy uk no prescription [url=https://topedstoreusa.com/#]buy viagra korea[/url] buy viagra gold coast buy generic cialis generic cialis

  • when will cialis be over the counter
    (2019-12-06 23:13:54Z)

    cheap cialis daily
    cialis without a doctor prescription
    buy tadalafil cheap

  • rdnznll
    (2020-01-23 22:45:47Z)

    [url=https://imdb1.ru/] Добро пожаловать в Акапулько фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • gkjnanf
    (2020-01-24 03:46:46Z)

    [url=http://imdb1.ru/] Хороший лжец фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • vgvaouq
    (2020-01-24 06:20:13Z)

    [url=http://www.bofilm.ru/] Мысленный волк 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском языке. [/url]

  • ujuekxt
    (2020-01-24 19:09:17Z)

    [url=https://www.tvonlayn.ru/] Я иду искать 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • tqnjkln
    (2020-01-25 00:01:23Z)

    [url=https://www.kino-m.com/] Королевский корги 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • skiyloy
    (2020-01-25 02:30:40Z)

    [url=http://www.bofilm.ru/] Рождество на двоих 2019 2020 смотреть онлайн качество 1080. [/url]

  • fzecrmb
    (2020-01-25 04:59:57Z)

    [url=http://www.bofilm.ru/] Сиротский Бруклин 2019 фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • xutsdnt
    (2020-01-25 15:22:39Z)

    [url=https://kino-m.com/] Дамбо 2020 смотреть онлайн качество 1080. [/url]

  • tjonzei
    (2020-01-25 17:55:41Z)

    [url=https://kino-m.com/] Решала. Нулевые фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • debgubo
    (2020-01-25 22:48:05Z)

    [url=https://4serial.com/] Семейка Аддамс 2019 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • tshssyb
    (2020-01-26 01:24:41Z)

    [url=https://www.kino-m.com/] Комната желаний 2020 смотреть онлайн качество 1080. [/url]

  • almfxca
    (2020-01-26 09:05:49Z)

    [url=http://4serial.com/] Я иду искать 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском. [/url]

  • pzhumvl
    (2020-01-26 14:15:15Z)

    [url=http://zfilm2.ru/] Падение ангела 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском. [/url]

  • vflpesx
    (2020-01-26 16:49:17Z)

    [url=https://imdb1.ru/] Белый лебедь 2020 смотреть онлайн качество 1080. [/url]

  • jlndyvh
    (2020-01-26 21:44:23Z)

    [url=http://bofilm.ru/] Амундсен фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн русский. [/url]

  • ietgbex
    (2020-01-28 14:27:05Z)

    [url=https://www.tvonlayn.ru/] Тайная жизнь домашних животных 2 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском языке. [/url]

  • bhfjfgl
    (2020-01-28 21:52:27Z)

    [url=http://zfilm2.ru/] Angry Birds в кино 2020 смотреть онлайн бесплатно 1080. [/url]

  • naluvqb
    (2020-01-29 10:32:22Z)

    [url=https://zfilm2.ru/] Гуцулка Ксеня 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • rparixq
    (2020-01-29 23:04:08Z)

    [url=http://www.bofilm.ru/] Падение ангела 2020 смотреть онлайн 1080. [/url]

  • xttkgdn
    (2020-01-30 11:53:31Z)

    [url=https://www.kino-m.com/] Шазам! фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • dxxfkgg
    (2020-01-30 14:34:09Z)

    [url=https://kino-m.com/] В метре друг от друга 2020 смотреть онлайн качество 1080. [/url]

  • hcjfirp
    (2020-02-01 14:19:36Z)

    [url=http://imdb1.ru/] Тайная жизнь домашних животных 2 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • yqgxxql
    (2020-02-01 19:23:47Z)

    [url=https://www.tvonlayn.ru/] Паразиты 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • afxxkmr
    (2020-02-02 02:53:40Z)

    [url=https://www.wwin-tv.com/] Тебя никогда здесь не было 2020 смотреть онлайн русский. [/url]

  • ulkceko
    (2020-02-02 05:22:37Z)

    [url=https://www.4serial.com/] Загадочное убийство 2020 смотреть онлайн бесплатно 1080. [/url]

  • bhekmzl
    (2020-02-02 08:02:00Z)

    [url=https://00-tv.com/] Тайна Печати дракона: путешествие в Китай 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском. [/url]

  • jozpnof
    (2020-02-02 23:11:26Z)

    [url=https://www.4serial.com/] Шазам! 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском. [/url]

  • xnsxykw
    (2020-02-03 06:57:05Z)

    [url=http://bofilm.ru/] Холоп 2019 фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн hd 1080. [/url]

  • vfbifrags
    (2020-02-10 09:24:23Z)

    differential equations coursework [url=http://courseworkhelpxeg.com/]buy coursework online[/url] coursework service differential equations coursework coursework help university

  • gehtlesorn
    (2020-02-11 15:36:19Z)

    cheap essay writer [url=http://essaywritersrpl.com/]custom written essay[/url] persuasive essay helper essay help help to write an essay

  • fegochews
    (2020-02-12 18:53:55Z)

    buy essay paper [url=http://essayonlinethx.com/]write my essay south park[/url] essay writing service best essay about service do essay writing services work

  • nuloexall
    (2020-02-13 00:19:38Z)

    Levaquin [url=http://gabapentinneurontinax.com/]Epitol[/url] Meclizine Aldactone Sinemet

  • grhresorn
    (2020-02-13 06:25:47Z)

    best college paper writing service [url=http://papersonlinesgo.com/]websites to type papers[/url] write my paper in apa format paper writer services write my math paper

  • bslohAulk
    (2020-02-14 00:33:06Z)

    Finax [url=http://meloxicammobicxn.com/]Kamagra Gold[/url] Casodex Uroxatral Fincar

  • htbgexall
    (2020-02-18 09:09:42Z)

    thesis statement help [url=http://thesissgj.com/]thesis writing service reviews[/url] thesis titles help with thesis statements thesis proposal format

  • gbolfrags
    (2020-02-18 13:07:34Z)

    help with term papers [url=http://termpapernfu.com/]term papers custom[/url] write my term paper for me custom term paper writing do my term paper for me

  • jmbzxix
    (2020-02-18 16:55:01Z)

    [url=http://zfilm2.ru/] Агент Джонни Инглиш 3.0 2020 смотреть онлайн полностью. [/url]

  • vaavnzb
    (2020-02-18 19:22:54Z)

    [url=https://www.wwin-tv.com/] Гурвинек. Волшебная игра 2020 смотреть онлайн на русском. [/url]

  • yetqaww
    (2020-02-18 21:51:10Z)

    [url=https://kino-m.com/] Гуцулка Ксеня фильм 2020 смотреть онлайн 1080. [/url]

  • htoilesorn
    (2020-02-21 07:20:44Z)

    quick cash loan sa [url=http://quickloansrgl.com/]payday loans quick and easy[/url] quick decision payday loans quick cash loans california quick payday loans in sa

  • egbbexall
    (2020-02-26 01:46:07Z)

    fast payday loans inc. fort walton beach fl [url=http://fastcashloansvfl.com/]fast payday loans perry fl[/url] fast cash loan in malaysia fast cash loans with no credit fast cash loans bc

  • hrvyvvi
    (2020-02-26 13:32:39Z)

    [url=http://www.bofilm.ru/] Отпетые мошенницы 2020 смотреть онлайн русский. [/url]

  • egbbexall
    (2020-03-03 14:30:45Z)

    fast cash loans atlanta [url=http://fastcashloansvfl.com/]fast cash loans bad credit australia[/url] get me a payday loan fast fast online payday loans fast cash loans canada

  • bdkafrags
    (2020-03-07 07:45:35Z)

    pfizer viagra [url=https://abigailpharmdx.com/]discount viagra[/url] online order viagra order viagra online generic viagra sildenafil

  • fbhfesorn
    (2020-03-08 10:43:58Z)

    viagra substitute [url=https://emmapharmsr.com/]otc viagra[/url] п»їviagra viagra coupon viagra coupons

  • cxgkpiowjbpy
    (2020-03-13 23:35:18Z)

    ubdnuw find more [url=http://si1denafilfored.com/]viagra usa[/url] look here orpwug discover this info here sidenafil Viagra Generic

  • grbzesorn
    (2020-03-17 03:56:44Z)

    cvs pharmacy store near me [url=https://pharmacystorefvnh.com/]drug store pharmacy technician[/url] п»їcvs pharmacy store kroger pharmacy store hours online pharmacy store

  • yyqdwwbldeai
    (2020-03-29 14:20:40Z)

    uydxxm read moreA… [url=http://si1denafilfored.com/]viagra usa pharmacy[/url] article xrgnyc more generic viagra on line go to website

  • ntaletzoct
    (2020-04-14 00:37:06Z)

    price of cialis https://canadian-drugrbnl.com/# - buying cialis online cialis 20 mg buy online generic cialis online buy 20 mg cialis online

  • ztaletweiv
    (2020-04-14 03:22:36Z)

    viagra coupon [url=https://canadian-drugwqae.com/# ]viagra 100mg cost [/url] viagra 100mg price buy viagra 75mg viagra coupons

  • ntaletalxw
    (2020-04-14 09:59:14Z)

    cheap cialis coupon for cialis order cialis online canada [url=https://canadian-drugrbnl.com/# ]buy cialis usa [/url] buy cialis in uk

  • ycbiwdmokhfd
    (2020-04-23 04:09:30Z)

    mqbhky view publisher site [url=http://si1denafilfored.com/]buy sildenfil[/url] at yahoo tbbsqz online buy sildenafil in usa get more

  • canada viagra
    (2020-04-23 10:12:51Z)

    cheapest generic viagra
    viagra prices
    viagra doses 200 mg

  • amszgunp
    (2020-04-25 13:56:04Z)

    viagra pictures pill viagra online without prescription viagra man king [url=https://viagaramen.com/]where to buy viagra online[/url] viagra intracerebral hemorrhage

  • jihowoax
    (2020-04-25 22:22:14Z)

    female viagra herbal [url=http://viagrapdf.com/]viagra[/url] viagra loss of efficacy

  • ofttiyuq
    (2020-04-25 22:46:24Z)

    viagra works how long young person taking viagra [url=https://viagaramen.com]generic viagra cost[/url] viagra after knee surgery

  • kcmzysym
    (2020-04-26 05:44:20Z)

    how long does viagra work [url=http://viagrapdf.com/]generic viagra online canadian pharmacy[/url] order authentic viagra online

  • vmscftqf
    (2020-04-26 13:11:36Z)

    viagra zu teuer http://viagrapdf.com/ where can i buy viagra in pakistan where to order viagra online forum viagra good or bad for health

  • kydiduoj
    (2020-04-26 13:42:03Z)

    viagra qu est ce que c est pfizer viagra coupon 2020 [url=https://viagaramen.com/]viagra side effects[/url] viagra bei tinnitus

  • musnpcad
    (2020-04-26 18:43:05Z)

    african viagra nigeria https://menviagraus.com/ viagra tablets in india online viagra femenino farmacias ahumada where can i buy viagra in shops

  • ikslataf
    (2020-04-26 21:27:24Z)

    ano ang epekto ng viagra https://viagaramen.com/ - viagra generic canada viagra user experiences

  • bpekhtye
    (2020-04-27 12:49:46Z)

    sildenafil prescription on nhs http://viagrapdf.com/ - viagra online aust viagra jbl [url=http://viagrapdf.com/]real viagra without a doctor prescription[/url] khasiat viagra usa 100mg

  • bxxejnwk
    (2020-04-27 18:18:24Z)

    viagra funny names [url=https://menviagraus.com/]viagra alternative[/url] wirkung viagra alkohol viagra legal kaufen ohne rezept

  • abvqqzcv
    (2020-04-27 20:14:07Z)

    will viagra increase my heart rate why is viagra used to treat erectile dysfunction [url=https://viagaramen.com]buy cheap viagra[/url] msds sildenafil citrate

  • xdbdoxdw
    (2020-04-27 20:15:08Z)

    como fazer viagra caseiro com amendoim http://viagrapdf.com/ - viagra generic name mycoxafloppin buy cheap sildenafil citrate 100mg

  • ixniunrq
    (2020-04-28 03:44:03Z)

    atenolol et viagra http://viagrapdf.com - best place buy viagra online forum generic viagra for sale uk

  • hdaujlek
    (2020-04-28 03:44:07Z)

    viagra montreal pharmaprix https://viagaramen.com/ - how to buy cheap viagra viagra gdzie kupi warszawa

  • irhwtqqc
    (2020-04-28 04:24:52Z)

    el viagra produce taquicardia pesni gruppi viagra [url=https://menviagraus.com]buy viagra online without prescription[/url] sildenafil 50 mg 4 tabletten

  • koayrgfs
    (2020-04-28 14:49:22Z)

    costo del sildenafil en mexico viagra commercial model blue dress [url=https://menviagraus.com]online viagra[/url] france viagra

  • rdttfpfh
    (2020-04-29 00:06:09Z)

    should i use viagra for performance anxiety https://viagaramen.com - recensioni sul viagra generico cheap viagra online 100mg [url=https://viagaramen.com]what is viagra[/url] where to buy viagra in phoenix az

  • ozvkdefl
    (2020-04-29 00:08:31Z)

    onde comprar viagra pela internet http://viagrapdf.com/ - buying viagra in northern ireland viagra prices usa [url=http://viagrapdf.com]is there a generic for viagra[/url] sildenafil medana kupie

  • hvwdmaxt
    (2020-04-29 02:09:51Z)

    viagra coupons 2020 https://menviagraus.com - viagra online purchase canada difference between revatio and viagra [url=https://menviagraus.com]viagra vs viagra[/url]

  • orbyhjvp
    (2020-04-29 09:59:35Z)

    differenza tra revatio e viagra is viagra a competitive inhibitor [url=https://viagaramen.com/]can you buy viagra over the counter[/url] viagra otc india

  • mkshpcel
    (2020-04-29 12:45:09Z)

    viagra mechanism animation generic viagra webmd [url=https://menviagraus.com/]viagra brands[/url] get viagra prescription uk

  • paybqywb
    (2020-04-29 20:08:53Z)

    les indications du viagra [url=http://viagrapdf.com/]generic viagra online pharmacy[/url] que es mas efectivo cialis o sildenafil viagra global sales 2020

  • dyiwoqng
    (2020-04-29 20:10:40Z)

    sildenafil composicion quimica https://viagaramen.com - sildenafil citrate generic vs viagra sildenafil generico farmacias similares [url=https://viagaramen.com/]viagra tablets for sale[/url]

  • mwxgcbox
    (2020-04-30 05:47:26Z)

    melhor viagra feminino https://viagaramen.com - phentermine canadian pharmacy 37.5 viagra pills at gas stations viagra information in hindi

  • mnnizahm
    (2020-04-30 05:50:17Z)

    effet sildenafil sur femme [url=http://viagrapdf.com/]online pharmacy viagra[/url] buy viagra south africa online

  • biqkbbxt
    (2020-04-30 08:44:22Z)

    novaya grupa viagra https://menviagraus.com - cialis und viagra zusammen einnehmen precio sildenafil generico [url=https://menviagraus.com/]generic viagra for sale[/url] definition of viagra tablets

  • rprweuos
    (2020-04-30 15:34:57Z)

    sildenafil naturalny http://viagrapdf.com - viagra 100mg online india buy pfizer viagra in australia [url=http://viagrapdf.com]viagra generic date[/url]

  • ibagpapn
    (2020-04-30 19:09:44Z)

    viagra cialis heartburn [url=https://menviagraus.com/]erectile dysfunction exercises[/url] viagra cialis levitra wirkungsdauer use viagra to get pregnant

  • vywsuvpc
    (2020-05-01 01:08:39Z)

    wchodzi viagra do baru [url=https://viagaramen.com]viagra online[/url] priapism viagra

  • Royal CBD
    (2020-05-14 03:43:55Z)

    Appreciate the recommendation. Let me try it out.

  • kskmlywu
    (2020-05-21 01:47:39Z)

    effect of viagra tablet [url=https://usabuyes.com/#]cvs generic viagra price[/url] brand viagra online australia cheapest brand viagra viagra power pill


Top News: Business