...

India's misunderstood maharajahs




  • In Business
  • 2021-09-27 01:44:36Z
  • By BBC
Fateh Singh
Fateh Singh  

India's maharajahs or rulers of princely states are commonly viewed through stereotypes of elephants, dancing girls, and grand palaces. Historian Manu Pillai revisits their legacy.

If you look beyond the bejewelled figures, palaces and opulent courts, you'll notice something telling about India's maharajahs: that they have largely been scorned and mocked, or treated with voyeuristic curiosity.

The British, in their day, cast "native" princes as decadent figures, more interested in frivolous sex and fancy dress than in government.

One white officer, for example, loudly proclaimed the typical maharajah as "monstrous and bloated in bulk, hideous and disgusting in appearance" and "decked with earrings and necklaces" like a dancing girl. Unlike white men, these were not manly figures of authority, but effeminate "scoundrels".

The stereotype held for decades. In 1947, Life magazine joined the chorus through a statistical exercise which declared that the average maharajah had "11 titles, three uniforms, 5.8 wives, 12.6 children, five palaces, 9.2 elephants, and not less than 3.4 Rolls Royce cars".

Chamarajendra Wadiyar of Mysore took on industrial projects, including one of the world
Chamarajendra Wadiyar of Mysore took on industrial projects, including one of the world's biggest dams  

It was all droll and entertaining, even if the numbers are misleading. After all, of the supposed total of 562 "states", most were microscopic estates with little political relevance.

To lump 100-odd bona fide princes, ruling over millions, with glorified landlords and aristocrats owning a few square kilometres of real estate, not only watered down their status, it also reduced them to a caricature: something akin to equating Queen Elizabeth with a country squire.

The fact, however, is that princely territories - spread over two-fifths of the Indian subcontinent and not under direct colonial control but linked through treaties and agreements with the Raj as vassals - featured rulers who were anything but the stereotype of glitter and parade.

  • Maharajah's daring act of anti-colonial dissent

  • The lavish lifestyle of India's royalty

As Life acknowledged in the same piece, Cochin's maharajah was more likely to be found bent over a Sanskrit manuscript than in the lap of a concubine, while Gondal's recently deceased ruler was a trained doctor.

The big states were not ruled by "tin-pot" dictators drowning in wine and orgies, but by serious political figures, who saw their kingdoms as legitimate political spaces.

Of course, the charge of princely eccentricity has some truth - one maharajah saw a Scottish regiment and immediately dressed his brown soldiers in kilts and pink tights, while another is said to have believed he was Louis XIV reborn among Punjabis.

But India's princes hardly held a monopoly over such idiosyncrasies. British monarchs had just as colourful pasts, as did elected politicians; in fact, even a man like Lord Curzon - among the stuffiest viceroys sent to India - had it in him to once play tennis stark naked.

Sayaji Rao Gaekwad of Baroda emerged as one of the sharpest princely critics of British imperialism
Sayaji Rao Gaekwad of Baroda emerged as one of the sharpest princely critics of British imperialism  

The image of the maharajahs as "self-centred fools", then, not only misses the more interesting story but actively conceals it, as I discovered while researching my new book.

Mysore's prince in southern India had elephants but also presided over a regime obsessed with industrialisation.

In Baroda, in the west, a journalist found that the maharajah there allocated $5 to every 55 of his subjects for education, as opposed to $5 per 1000 people in British India.

Meanwhile Travancore, in present-day Kerala, was celebrated as a "model state" for investments in schools, infrastructure, and much else.

Indeed, it was in the princely territories that many early discussions on constitutionalism took off in India.

So why is it that we only talk of harems, flashy cars, and sex scandals, when we think about the princes?

  • The Indian queens who modelled for a vaccine

  • The Indian princess who became a South Korean queen

For one, it was a convenient line for the Raj, presenting colonial officials as well-meaning, upright nannies, struggling to discipline a band of spoilt (brown) schoolchildren. To acknowledge that brown men could not only govern, but also in many cases, beat the British would expose the empire's so-called mission to "civilise".

The story also plays down the paranoia and fragility which defined the Raj: though the princes were formally "pillars of the empire", in practice they were restive partners, forever testing their overlords.

Baroda, for instance, was the source of revolutionary anti-British literature, printed under such innocent titles as "Vegetable Medicines". Mysore would not tolerate the local press going after its royal family, but coolly allowed editors to criticise the Raj.

Jaipur's rulers cheerfully fudged their accounts, concealing millions in revenue to avoid paying a higher tribute. Besides, multiple rulers provided financial support to the nationalist Congress Party in its fight for independence. Curzon, in fact, was convinced even in the 1920s that there were many "Phillipe Égalités" (after a Bourbon prince who supported the French Revolution) among the princes, with an "ardent sympathy" for the nationalist cause.

Odd though it may sound now, for much of the freedom struggle, the princes were actually seen as heroes.

Krishnaraja Wadiyar III of Mysore
Krishnaraja Wadiyar III of Mysore  

The achievements of the bigger states brought pride to nationalists - including Mahatma Gandhi - dismantling as they did the racist trope that "natives" could not rule themselves.

But by the 1930s and 1940s things changed. In many principalities, often due to their own success in widening access to education, demands emerged for democratic representation. On the eve of the British withdrawal from India, many maharajahs became violently repressive, tarnishing their wider legacy.

The poor reputation the princes are saddled with today - where it does not stem solely from colonial stereotypes - comes from this endnote to their story.

But if history gives any lessons, it is that everything is more complex than it appears.

And this is true of the maharajahs also, among whom were deft modernisers and shrewd politicians - a detail for too long hidden behind stale talk of dancing girls and elephants.

Manu Pillai is a historian and the author of False Allies: India's Maharajahs in the Age of Ravi Varma

You might also be interested in:

COMMENTS

More Related News

UK foreign minister to discuss security, defence ties with India
UK foreign minister to discuss security, defence ties with India

Truss will discuss developing security and defence tech and strengthening defence-related trade with India, according to the statement from the British...

How newcomer River plans to fill a gap in India
How newcomer River plans to fill a gap in India's competitive EV two-wheeler market

Two wheelers have long been a cornerstone of life in India - their smaller size and affordability making these traditionally gas and diesel-powered vehicles a go-to means of navigating the traffic-jammed streets of the country's most populous cities. Now, a new startup called River has come out of stealth with an electric two-wheeler scooter -- and accompanying subscription services -- designed to appeal to modern-day consumers looking for an affordable, yet stylish vehicle that can be used for work, play and every task in between. River, founded in late 2020 by Aravind Mani and Vipin George with $2 million in backing from Maniv Mobility and TrucksVC, has grown to 42 people in its short...

COP26: India says coal will be mainstay in leaked report
COP26: India says coal will be mainstay in leaked report

India has been lobbying the UN against completely moving away from coal ahead of the climate summit.

India hits 1B vaccine doses, worries about gap between shots
India hits 1B vaccine doses, worries about gap between shots
  • World
  • 2021-10-21 04:35:06Z

India has administered 1 billion doses of COVID-19 vaccine, officials said Thursday, passing a milestone for the South Asian country where the delta variant ...

India celebrates 1 billion COVID-19 vaccine doses with song, film
India celebrates 1 billion COVID-19 vaccine doses with song, film
  • US
  • 2021-10-21 02:26:55Z

India is set to administer one billion COVID-19 vaccine doses by early Thursday, an important milestone after a slow start, even as a recent drop in...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

  • Jack Smith
    (2021-09-27 03:43:58Z)

    You can get analog or digital wireless meat thermometer exporter. A digital one will display the temperature in numerals, kind of like a digital watch. An analog one uses a more classic face, similar to a clock.

    An ethoxylation degree of 3–5 produces quite hydrophobic surfactants, excellent as emulsifiers and for greasy stain removal; nonionic surfactant Isomeric Alcohol Ethoxylates manufacturers are usually considered to be kinetically slower than anionics, and there is a limit to the use of nonionic surfactants in certain areas (such as North America) where short wash cycles are the norm.

    Use of additives not labeled as "oxygen sensor safe" can damage your VW Oxygen Sensor factory.

    TECHNOFLEKS LIYYCY 300/500 V and TECHNOFLEKS LiYYCYżo 300/500 V are flexible, overall shielded cables designed for wet or dry locations and intended for control, protection and monitoring systems or power supply, all in power engineering. The cables are also intended for wiring industrial plants, such as production lines, air-conditioning equipment etc.

    RPET is made out of recycled plastic bag materials. wholesale rpet bag means that by simply using one of these rPET recycled plastic shopping bags

    china oem linear light is defined as a linear shape luminaire (opposed to square or round). These luminaires long optics to distribute the light over a more narrow area than with traditional lighting. Usually, these lights are long in length and are installed as either suspended from a ceiling, surface mounted to a wall or ceiling or recessed into a wall or ceiling.

    REPLY

Top News: Business