...

How patients talk about cancer with family, friends and doctors




  • In Health
  • 2021-08-18 13:49:22Z
  • By The Conversation
Communication about cancer works best when the patient is invited to express fears and concerns.
Communication about cancer works best when the patient is invited to express fears and concerns.  

Cancer is no longer spoken of only in a whisper. Today, the disease - although still dreaded, still terrifying - is routinely and openly discussed in all media.

Yet in more intimate settings - as when patients privately discuss a cancer diagnosis or treatment with doctors, partners, family and friends - most patients are quiet and passive when raising their concerns and expressing their feelings.

I am a professor in the School of Communication at San Diego State University and director of the Center for Communication, Health & the Public Good. For more than 30 years I've studied cancer communication between patients and those close to them.

Until now, little was known about these interactions, even though tens of millions of Americans - nearly 40% - will receive a cancer diagnosis sometime during their lifetime. My analysis reveals new and often surprising insights into how people communicate when navigating their way through cancer. Some of these insights could be used to improve patient coping and care.

A woman wearing a tight cap speaks on her smartphone.
A woman wearing a tight cap speaks on her smartphone.  

The family phone calls

I began to study these interactions in 1988, when a family donated to me 61 recorded telephone conversations taking place over 13 months.

The recordings are the first natural history of one family's 13-month cancer journey, from diagnosis to death of a loved one. These are conversations primarily between the patient, her spouse and her son.

This is an excerpt from the mother talking with the son for the first time since her diagnosis. She had just told him the diagnosis was "real bad."

During emotional moments like this, speakers may not know what to say, or how to say it. Very few words are spoken. And despite the stereotype that conversations about cancer are extremely emotional, family members typically are stoic.

Avoiding strong emotions can help patients and family members better ask and respond to questions about key information: What did the doctor say about mom's condition? Are the test results back? If so, what do they mean? These types of discussions become the family's "new normal."

My research shows that families dealing with cancer often live in a chronic state of flux; they do not know how the future will unfold. At the same time, they invest considerable efforts in hoping for the best and maintaining a "state of readiness" for dealing with unexpected troubles and emergencies.

A patient in his hospital bed talks to his spouse and a doctor.
A patient in his hospital bed talks to his spouse and a doctor.  

The video recordings

My team and I also studied nearly 200 video recordings of interviews between patients and their oncologists at a comprehensive cancer clinic. The interviews were filmed over a two-year period.

We soon discovered that meeting with a medical team is very different from the phone conversations between families.

In a clinical setting, time constraints are necessary. Conversations with doctors can confuse and intimidate, especially when medical jargon is used to explain complex details about cancer. Patients tend to subordinate themselves to medical authority by remaining quiet and asking few questions.

There are moments, however, when patients actively resist, challenge or express disappointment with a doctor's statements:

A recent study reveals that doctors treat "stable cancer" as good news; the majority of patients do not.

A woman sits on a couch as another woman speaks to her.
A woman sits on a couch as another woman speaks to her.  

Discussing fear, hope and pain

When meeting with doctors, patients sometimes withhold important information about their illness. They often raise concerns indirectly. Doctors may find it difficult to discern what they are alluding to or hinting about; a patient's needs may not be fully acknowledged, much less actually addressed.

For example, when patients raise fears about the cancer, the majority of doctors may briefly acknowledge their distress - but they are minimally receptive to their concerns. When patients search for hope and positive news, doctors provide brief responses and even shift topics away from such inquiries. When patients discuss their pain, only on rare occasions do doctors ask them to elaborate or display personal concern for their discomfort.

In those cases in which doctors do provide immediate and detailed responses to a patient's questions, an irony arises: These answers often increase a patient's anxieties and uncertainties. Usually that's because they can't understand the doctor's technical descriptions - or because they haven't yet accepted the fact that much about cancer is still unknown.

Still, most encounters are not dark and foreboding. When doctors invest the time to invite patients to elaborate on their concerns, and respond with empathy and compassion, a partnership is created. Problems are confronted; healing is pursued together. Patients feel heard, understood and respected.

[Over 100,000 readers rely on The Conversation's newsletter to understand the world. Sign up today.]

Observations from these phone and video recordings just scratch the surface of what can be learned. More research may help develop approaches that provide reassurance to patients and counter the relentless fears they face. But already there are some things we know: A cancer diagnosis is more about life and hope than death and despair. And compassionate communication is essential for patients trying to accept their condition and heal their illness.

This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit news site dedicated to sharing ideas from academic experts. It was written by: Wayne A. Beach, PhD, San Diego State University.

Read more:

  • Is the developed world we've created giving us cancer?

  • Every cancer patient should be prescribed exercise medicine

  • Does eating dairy foods increase your risk of prostate cancer?

Wayne A. Beach, PhD has received funding from the American Cancer Society, the National Cancer Institute, and several philanthropic organizations.

COMMENTS

More Related News

20 Business Practices That Are Unethical AF But Actually Pretty Common
20 Business Practices That Are Unethical AF But Actually Pretty Common

An intern is not free labour.View Entire Post ›

Kerala floods: Dozens missing in deadly India disaster
Kerala floods: Dozens missing in deadly India disaster

Heavy rains cause rivers to overflow in Kerala, washing away homes and trapping people under debris.

Why 2.3 million US children could miss out on expanded tax credit
Why 2.3 million US children could miss out on expanded tax credit

About 67 million US children are eligible for new benefits, but some of the most vulnerable are missing out.

How a massacre of Algerians in Paris was covered up
How a massacre of Algerians in Paris was covered up
  • World
  • 2021-10-16 23:08:57Z

French police killed up to 300 people in 1961, throwing some of them into the River Seine to drown them.

US says it will pay the family of the 10 Afghans killed in a failed drone strike and help them relocate to US
US says it will pay the family of the 10 Afghans killed in a failed drone strike and help them relocate to US

The 10 Afghans, including seven children, were killed in error by a US drone strike on August 29 during the US troop withdrawal.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Health