Germany Won't Enlist in Macron's European Army

  • In World
  • 2019-11-12 05:00:02Z
  • By Bloomberg

(Bloomberg Opinion) -- Now that German leaders have responded to French President Emmanuel Macron's provocative remarks concerning the future of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, an unusually wide public rift has emerged between France and Germany. At its root, it's about France's leadership ambitions, to which Germany is opposed without itself wanting to lead.

"We do want a strong and sovereign Europe," Foreign Minister Heiko Maas wrote in an op-ed article in the weekly Der Spiegel on Sunday. "But we need it as part of a strong NATO, and not as a substitute."

That doesn't just mean Maas is keen to preserve Europe's, and Germany's, transatlantic alliance regardless of U.S. President Donald Trump's relative lack of interest in it - simply because Europe cannot defend itself without U.S. help today. Maas insisted that "when Europe is one day able to defend its own security, we should still want NATO." And, directly answering Macron's musings about improving relations with Russia as the alliance with the U.S. erodes, the German minister declared that "Germany will not tolerate any special arrangements, not vis-à-vis Moscow and not on any other matters," because it takes the security of Poland and the Baltic states to heart.

These are strong statements, especially coming from Maas. He's a member of the Social Democratic Party, which is less pro-U.S. and pro-NATO than its senior partner in Germany's governing coalition, Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democratic Union. But on the points Maas made in his article, the German government appears to be united. Merkel, too, has criticized Macron's vision more sharply than on any other matter since his election in 2017, calling it a "sweeping attack."

"We must bring the European part of NATO closer together," Merkel said on her regular Sunday podcast. That, she added, was what the European Union defense project, known as Permanent Structured Cooperation, or Pesco, is all about.

That's an approach radically different from Macron's. To him, the EU defense project is about strategic sovereignty. To German politicians, it's largely an efficiency project aimed at harmonizing European countries' defense industries, cutting the number of different defense systems used by member states' armies, and centralizing the development of new weapons such as warplanes and tanks.

This German vision is consistent with the Framework Nations Concept, adopted by NATO in 2014. It's a mechanism for voluntary defense cooperation built around specific nations' projects, such as Germany's own idea of coordinating the development of defense capabilities, or the U.K.'s work on a multinational rapid response force. Under the concept, pretty much any cooperation projects, even those including non-NATO members such as Sweden and Finland, can take place under NATO's umbrella.

With NATO providing such a flexible platform, it's often not obvious why any other defense cooperation programs are necessary. NATO and the EU have agreed to coordinate their activities, anyway, and it's evident from progress reports on that effort that this creates a lot of duplicative bureaucratic activity such as cross-participation in working groups. The same exercises under the program get two different names, one for the EU and one for NATO.

But especially from the French point of view, NATO isn't the best platform for joint procurement programs, because outside it, Europeans can keep out U.S. competition. Involving NATO also means dealing with the U.S. as the organization's military leader. France, as the country with the strongest military in the EU, likes to exercise leadership, too. Which is perhaps the best explanation for Macron's European Intervention Initiative, an attempt at coordinating European countries' strategic thinking that isn't even part of EU defense cooperation.

Germany doesn't have France's military ambitions. It's a low defense spender because higher expenditure is politically unpopular. The Bundeswehr's combat readiness is constantly in question, and there's all the weight of history on the shoulders of German leaders. So German politicians see their function in maintaining European security differently than Macron does, even if they, too, refer to "leadership."

"As a country at the centre of Europe, Germany must play a central, mediatory and balanced role - within Europe and vis-a-vis the United States," Maas wrote. "If we do not assume this leadership role, nobody will."

Being a mediator, though, is not the same as being a leader. An unambitious, compromise-minded Germany won't compete with Macron's cocky France, but it'll be a drag on Macron's security strategizing, getting in the way as he tries to provoke the U.S. with talk of strategic autonomy or flirt with Russia. It'll provide the reliably boring alternative, and that's probably for the best: Any machine in which Macron designs the sporty engine needs German-made brakes.

To contact the author of this story: Leonid Bershidsky at

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Tobin Harshaw at

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

Leonid Bershidsky is Bloomberg Opinion's Europe columnist. He was the founding editor of the Russian business daily Vedomosti and founded the opinion website

For more articles like this, please visit us at

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.


More Related News

As Britain bans Huawei, U.S. pressure mounts on Europe to follow suit
As Britain bans Huawei, U.S. pressure mounts on Europe to follow suit

Britain's decision to ban China's Huawei from its 5G network increases further pressure on EU countries to impose stricter limits on the world's largest telecoms equipment maker just as the company expands its footprint across Europe. Prime Minister Boris Johnson announced the Huawei ban on Tuesday, frustrating Beijing but pleasing Washington, which had pushed Britain to reverse a January decision to grant Huawei a limited role in its 5G rollout.

UK demands the public wear face coverings in shops
UK demands the public wear face coverings in shops
  • World
  • 2020-07-14 10:09:04Z

Britain's government will demand people wear face coverings in shops as it seeks to clarify its message after weeks of prevarication amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Health Secretary Matt Hancock is expected to tell the House of Commons on Tuesday that anyone failing to comply with the order could face a fine of up to 100 pounds ($125). The order comes into effect on July 24, giving shops and the police time to prepare.

Concern grows in Balkans at rising coronavirus cases
Concern grows in Balkans at rising coronavirus cases

The numbers may still be modest, but the Balkans, one of the poorest regions in Europe with the most fragile medical infrastructure, is bracing against a surge in coronavirus infections. Several European countries have imposed restrictions, such as a two-week quarantine on travellers from Bulgaria and Romania, or a negative coronavirus test result on arrival. In Serbia, the situation is worse than in April, epidemiologist Predrag Kon said on the national broadcaster RTS, particularly in Belgrade where the health system is at saturation point.

EU should draw up list of medicines to be produced in Europe, says German health minister
EU should draw up list of medicines to be produced in Europe, says German health minister
  • US
  • 2020-07-13 09:24:25Z

The European Union should draw up a list of active substances used in medicines whose production should be brought back to Europe to reduce dependency on China, German Health Minister Jens Spahn said on Monday. Spahn told a news conference in Berlin it was not a question of shifting the production of all drugs back to Europe but that the goal was to reduce dependency on China. "It should not be up to China to decide whether we have sufficient protective masks," Spahn said, adding Germany wants to push forward efforts towards more independence during its EU Council Presidency, which began on July 1.

Polish president wins 2nd term after bitter campaign
Polish president wins 2nd term after bitter campaign

Polish President Andrzej Duda declared victory Monday in a runoff election in which he narrowly won a second five-year term, acknowledging the campaign he ran was often too harsh as he appealed for unity and forgiveness. The close race followed a bitter campaign between Duda and Warsaw Mayor Rafal Trzaskowski that was dominated by cultural issues. The government, state media and the influential Roman Catholic Church all mobilized in support of Duda and sought to stoke anti-Semitism, homophobia and xenophobia in order to shore up conservative support.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: World