Donald Trump, the President Who Would Be King, Just Got Slapped by the Courts

  • In World
  • 2019-10-09 18:01:28Z
  • By The Daily Beast
Donald Trump, the President Who Would Be King, Just Got Slapped by the Courts
Donald Trump, the President Who Would Be King, Just Got Slapped by the Courts  

From the looks of things, the 45th president's campaign to avoid impeachment is failing, his bid to self-coronate turning to dust. The mist of prosecution is in the air.

As the Supreme Court returns from its summer vacation, Donald Trump was rudely reminded that he is neither king nor sovereign, and that a sitting president is not immune from criminal investigation. Rather, he who dwells in the White House simply sits atop a co-equal branch of government, and is expected to obey the law. Apparently, l'état, ce n'est pas lui.

Just as the American public has swung solidly behind the House's impeachment inquiry, the president ordered Gordon Sondland, the U.S. ambassador to the EU, not to testify before Congress. All this after a federal district judge-Victor Marrero, a 78-year-old native of Puerto Rico-on Monday ruled that Trump's claim of blanket immunity in the face of a grand jury subpoena was "repugnant to the nation's governmental structure and constitutional values."

Judge Throws the Book at Trump's 'I'm Above the Law' Defense

Marrero ordered that Trump's accountants deliver eight years of his federal tax returns to the Manhattan District Attorney's Office in response to a grand jury subpoena. Nancy Pelosi and Adam Schiff aren't The Donald's only headaches: Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr., who appears determined to see this fight through after letting the Trumps off the hook before, is his newest nightmare.

A review of Judge Marrero's decision reveals that American history was something to be ignored by Trump's legal eagles. The fact that Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton were subject to criminal investigation mattered little to Trump, and that Nixon's vice president, Spiro Agnew, was prosecuted while still in office was no big deal. Likewise, that Nixon had to turn over the infamous Watergate tapes didn't seem to register. All that stuff was so not "modern presidential" and too inconvenient to be bothered with.

Rather, as the House of Trump saw things, a "domain" existed where "not only the President, but, derivatively, relatives and persons and business entities associated with him in potentially unlawful private activities, are in fact above the law." That sounds like the legal theory of a mob crime family.

Fortunately, the court was having none of it. Instead, Judge Marrero labeled Trump's position one that the "Founders rejected at the inception of the Republic, and that the Supreme Court has since unequivocally repudiated."

At this moment, Trump must be experiencing a serious bout of Putin and Erdogan envy.

To be sure, this is not the first time Trump has tried to shroud himself in an invisibility cloak. Indeed, from the looks of things, Trump has a problem keeping his arguments coherent. According to William Consovoy, Trump's lawyer, Congress is barred from investigating the president because that is a proper function of law enforcement, not Congress, and in turn, law enforcement may not investigate President Trump because he is immune from prosecution. Let that sink in.

Last spring, Consovoy told a different federal judge that Congress was powerless to hold the president's feet to the fire, and that Watergate and Whitewater were examples of congressional overreach. As for a congressional oversight committee's subpoena to Trump's accountants, it was stepping over a line.

Who cares if the Constitution gives Congress pride of place and enumerates its powers in Article I? In Trumpworld numbers don't matter unless Trump says they do, until he doesn't.

Then and now, a court has rejected Trump's arguments. As for Trump's beef with Congress' subpoena, we await an appellate decision. As for DA Vance's investigation, within minutes of Trump's latest loss, his lawyers had filed an emergency appeal with the Second Circuit. The song remains the same, yet this is all brand new terrain.

Prior presidents tussled with Congress and prosecutors, and claimed executive privilege, not wholesale immunity from scrutiny. In the end, they understood that America and the Constitution were far larger than them.

On Sunday night, Trump also branded Speaker Pelosi treasonous. We have seen this movie before. In Gladiator, Commodus jailed his opponents in the Senate. Suffice to say, we were not entertained.

Right now, the issue of whether a sitting president can be prosecuted in a state court is unanswered and unresolved. Vance isn't Bill Barr, the current U.S. attorney general and the second coming of Roy Cohn.

Trump has reason to be scared. New York State is not bound by the internal Justice Department opinion that tied Robert Mueller's hands. And Schiff has announced that Ambassador Sondland's no-show would be considered an act of obstruction and that Sondland was withholding personal texts of interest.

Trump's life just got even more complicated. Heavy is the head that wears the crown.

Read more at The Daily Beast.

Get our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!

Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.


More Related News

Trump Call
Trump Call 'Less Than Perfect,' Defense Says: Impeachment Update

(Bloomberg) -- Donald Trump's defense lawyers resume their presentation at 1 p.m. Monday after opening their arguments Saturday by saying House managers failed to prove the president should be removed from office.Here are the latest developments:Trump Call 'Less Than Perfect,' Defense Says (7:45 p.m.)Former independent counsel Robert Ray said Trump's July 25 call with Ukraine's president was "less than perfect," but that doesn't mean it's an impeachable abuse of power.It would have been better for Trump to have pursued an investigation "through proper channels," said Ray, a member of Trump's legal team."While the president certainly enjoys the power to do otherwise, there is consequence...

Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace Tears Into Conservative Pundit:
Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace Tears Into Conservative Pundit: 'Get Your Facts Straight!'

Sparks flew Monday on the Fox News set between Fox News anchor Chris Wallace and conservative contributor Katie Pavlich, with Wallace demanding his colleague get her "facts straight" after Pavlich insisted that certain witnesses had not been called in the impeachment trial.Moments before President Donald Trump's defense team began its arguments in the Senate impeachment trial, Pavlich noted during Fox's pregame coverage that while Republican senators are now weighing whether to call former National Security Adviser John Bolton following his bombshell claims, the House should have presented a more thorough case."The Senate is not the House, the House did not come with a complete case, and...

Democrats demand Bolton testify after NYT report Trump directly told him Ukraine aid tied to investigations
Democrats demand Bolton testify after NYT report Trump directly told him Ukraine aid tied to investigations

President Donald Trump told John Bolton he wanted to freeze military aid to Ukraine until it investigated his Democratic rivals, a report said.

Senate should remove Trump, majority of independent voters say in Fox News poll
Senate should remove Trump, majority of independent voters say in Fox News poll

Overall, 50% of registered voters said in a Fox News poll that President Trump should be convicted and removed in the Senate; 44% said he should not.

Senate floor belongs to Trump team as defense case opens
Senate floor belongs to Trump team as defense case opens

The floor of the U.S. Senate now belongs to President Donald Trump's lawyers as they push the Republican-led chamber for an acquittal on charges that he abused his power and obstructed Congress. The president's attorneys will begin their arguments Saturday in the impeachment trial and are expected

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: World