President Joe Biden is urging Congress to pause the gas and diesel taxes for three months through September in an effort to provide much-needed relief to motorists being punished at the pump.
The national average price of gas hit a record $5 a gallon in June, and it's expected to increase into the summer with higher demand as travel heats up.
However, some experts say that halting the federal gas tax - which currently sits at 18.4 cents per gallon - might not be as beneficial as you'd think and are calling for other forms of relief.
"The average adult in the U.S. uses about one gallon of gasoline per day," says Jay Zagorsky, senior lecturer in markets, public policy and law at Boston University.
"If President Biden is able to push through a gas tax holiday, the typical adult will save a bit less than $6 a month. In a time when inflation is over 8%, an extra $6 will not make much difference."
Too many Americans are still missing out on cheaper car insurance
How to turn your spare change into a diversified portfolio
Millions are struggling to crawl out of debt in the face of rising interest rates. Know your options
Looking for substantial savings
President Biden is hoping to enact a temporary halt to the federal gas and diesel tax without gutting the Highway Infrastructure Fund, which supports the construction and maintenance of critical highways and public transportation.
"The president believes that we can afford to suspend the gas tax to help consumers while using other revenues to make the Highway Trust Fund whole for the roughly $10 billion cost," the White House says.
For now, it is unclear how Congress will draw money from other funds and what impact that will have.
"Giving a gas tax holiday and making up for the revenue loss by using general funds takes a finely targeted tax and turns it into a mess," Zagorsky argues.
He suggests putting more attention toward fixing road infrastructure, since potholes and other examples of poor maintenance can result in vehicles getting lower gas mileage and car owners racking up expensive repair bills.
Gas may hit $6 a gallon soon
Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, says there may be some psychological relief from the gas tax holiday - but agrees that the financial relief is small.
"Everyone would rather pay less than pay more," De Haan says. "But I do have some concerns."
De Haan says the price of gas is as high as it is due to greater demand and lower supply. Freezing the gas tax could increase consumer demand for gas, pushing the price even higher.
JPMorgan analysts have already predicted the price of gas could top $6 this summer.
Gas prices tend to be higher in the warmer months due to more Americans hitting the road for their vacations. Summer-blend fuel is also more costly to produce since it takes longer and yields less gasoline per barrel of oil compared to winter-blend fuel.
The White House acknowledges that a gas tax holiday will not relieve high costs on its own but may provide Americans some breathing room during the Russia-Ukraine war, which has crimped the global supply of oil.
De Haan suggests indirect relief would be the best approach and recommends sending out a $50 or $100 check that Americans don't necessarily need to use toward gas. This could help alleviate inflationary pressures for everyone, not just motorists.
"If they need it for gas, they'll be wise and save it. And that won't maybe have as profound an impact on gasoline demand while still offering some sort of relief."
Biden calls on state and local governments
While the president meets with Congress to discuss a potential gas tax holiday, he's calling for state and local governments to do what they can to help motorists as well, whether this means "suspending their own gas taxes or helping consumers in other ways."
Some states have already taken action: Connecticut and New York have temporarily suspended their state gas taxes, while Illinois and Colorado have delayed planned tax and fee hikes.
Other states and local leaders are considering options like state gas tax pauses, rebates and relief payments. The average state gas tax in the U.S. is around 26 cents per gallon.
"Depending on how a rebate is designed, a rebate card could be more closely targeted towards struggling households by, say, only sending rebates to households with incomes below a particular cutoff," suggests Erich Muehlegger, associate professor of economics at the University of California, Davis.
However, Muehlegger adds that struggling households may not even use much gasoline, especially if they rely on public transportation instead - in which case, the rebate cards would not provide much relief anyway.
Rebate cards that are directly tied to gas consumption could also add to the existing problem of high demand and low supply.
What to read next
US is only a few days away from an 'absolute explosion' on inflation - here are 3 shockproof sectors to help protect your portfolio
A TikToker paid off $17,000 in credit card debt by 'cash stuffing' - can it work for you?
Don't be duped by doomsayers, JPMorgan says - the S&P 500 will rebound to 4,900. Here are 3 stocks it's using to bet on a bounce.
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.