Better Buy: General Electric vs. Boeing

  • In Business
  • 2019-05-25 23:54:00Z
  • By Lee Samaha, The Motley Fool

After both companies reported eventful first-quarter earnings, it's time to turn our attention to the question of which stock is the better buy, General Electric (NYSE: GE) or Boeing (NYSE: BA)? So far in 2019, the two companies have somewhat disappointed from an operational perspective, but despite the setbacks, both stocks are up handsomely -- at the time of writing, Boeing is up nearly 11%, and GE is up nearly 31% on a year-to-date basis. What are investors to make of this, and which stock is a better pick for long-term investors?

Buy neither if you're worried about the 737 MAX

I'll cut to the chase. Neither stock is worth buying if you don't believe the Boeing 737 MAX is going to get back in service. The grounding of the airplane in the wake of two crashes within six months and the need to upgrade the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation Systems (MCAS) software and achieve certification has hit both companies, and if the 737 MAX doesn't get back into service, both companies face a threat to their future earnings prospects.

Image source: Getty Images.

The 737 MAX grounding is a significant threat to Boeing

Alongside the Airbus A320 aircraft family, the Boeing 737 family is the workhouse of the civil aviation industry. While Boeing still produces the legacy 737 aircraft, the newer, more efficient 737 MAX was expected to comprise 90% of 737 deliveries in 2019.

Simply put, Boeing's first priority should be, and is, getting it back into service. While it will be extremely hard for Airbus to ramp A320 family production in order to take advantage, any airline opting for a legacy 737 will be buying an inferior plane to the 737 MAX and the Airbus A320 NEO -- Boeing would surely have to discount heavily on the legacy 737 in order to attract orders. There's no way around it. Boeing desperately needs the 737 MAX back in service.

General Electric also needs the 737 MAX

The same conclusion applies to GE. The company's joint venture with Safran Aircraft Engines, CFM International, produces the LEAP engine, which is the sole engine option on the 737 MAX. CFM also competes with United Technologies' Pratt & Whitney for engine orders on the Airbus A320 NEO. However, it's not feasible for Airbus to ramp A320 NEO production in order to significantly take orders that could be lost on the 737 MAX, and anyway, CFM still has to compete with Pratt & Whitney's engine.

Simply put, the LEAP engine for the 737 MAX, and more importantly the future revenue stream from its aftermarket/service revenue, is the single most important element of GE aviation's future segment revenue. In turn, this makes it the most important product for GE.

GE CEO Larry Culp flagged it up as a new risk during the recent earnings call and mentioned Safran

The 200 million euro figure is large enough, but it fades into insignificance compared to the potential lost revenue if the 737 MAX is grounded for a long time.

If you are confident in the 737 MAX returning soon...

In this case, Boeing is probably a better buy.

On a positive note for both companies, the civil aviation market remains strong. From United Technologies, through Honeywell International and GE itself, all of the major industrials with aviation exposure reported strong aftermarket demand in the first quarter. This suggests a strong underlying market for Boeing.

Moreover, the sell-off in Boeing's stock looks a little harsh. Boeing has lost nearly $48 billion in enterprise value (market cap plus net debt) since the start of March. Based on the average of its enterprise value to earnings before interest and tax (EBIT) multiple since then and now (around 19.3 times), it appears the market is assuming a $2.5 billion hit in earnings from the 737 MAX debacle. Although it's very hard to know exactly what the final figure will be, the $2.5 billion appears to be an overly harsh assessment at this point.

Turning to GE, Culp has done a good job of rebuilding confidence in the accuracy of management's guidance, and the first-quarter earnings report showed some signs of improvement. However, the reality is that GE is still to report a tangible improvement in its power segment -- notably in its gas power transactional services, an area where GE is expecting revenue and margin improvement in the next couple of years.

Boeing is a better buy

All told, a swift resolution to the 737 MAX issue probably brings about more upside for Boeing, so the aviation giant wins on that front. For GE in general, the company needs to demonstrate some progress on its power segment turnaround before investors can be fully convinced about the stock. That's a risk that hangs over the stock with or without the 737 MAX issue being resolved.

Lee Samaha owns shares of Honeywell International. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.


More Related News

New accountability report finds NASA has been paying Boeing huge bonuses for failing
New accountability report finds NASA has been paying Boeing huge bonuses for failing

Between its various ongoing Mars missions, orbiters studying asteroids and other planets, and a Moon trip on the horizon, NASA spends a lot of money. Boeing, which has contracts with NASA to build the rocket for its Space Launch System (SLS) is a big recipient of that cash, and a new government accountability report reveals that NASA has not only been paying more and more despite Boeing falling way behind on its deadlines, it's actually also been paying the company bonuses for its performance. As Ars Technica explains, the new government report is somewhat troubling, especially when you consider that the SLS program has now fallen well behind schedule. The Space Launch System has been in...

'Sully' Sullenberger blasts U.S. aircraft certification process, says 737 MAX pilots need new simulator training

Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, who in 2009 landed a US Airways flight safely on the Hudson River in New York, told a congressional panel on Wednesday that pilots of the now-grounded Boeing 737 MAX should get new simulator training before the plane returns to service. Sullenberger, who has blasted Boeing Co and the Federal Aviation Administration for their roles in the two 737 MAX crashes since October that killed 346 people, also said the U.S. system of certifying new aircraft is not working. "Our current system of aircraft design and certification has failed us," he said.

Boeing may rebrand the 737 Max so people are willing to fly in it again
Boeing may rebrand the 737 Max so people are willing to fly in it again

Boeing has a serious problem on its hands. After a pair of fatal crashes that claimed hundreds of lives, the company's 737 Max jetliner has been seriously tarnished. Nobody really wants to fly on the planes, even if Boeing can figure out how to keep them from killing people, and that means the hundreds of planes sitting around in storage right now may have a tough road ahead.Now, Boeing says it might have a plan for dealing with the complete loss of public trust in the 737 Max line, and it could be as simple as just changing its name. As Bloomberg reports, Boeing CFO Greg Smith noted the possibility of a name change in an interview during the Paris Air Show this week."I'd say we're...

Boeing signs first deal for 737 Max jet since deadly crashes
Boeing signs first deal for 737 Max jet since deadly crashes

Boeing is selling its 737 Max planes again. The company announced at the Paris Air Show on Tuesday that International Airlines Group, the parent company of British Airways and other carriers, signed a letter of intent for 200 Boeing 737 aircraft. Boeing said it's the first sale of the jetliner since the crash of an Ethiopian Airlines 737 Max in March.

Boeing's troubled 737 MAX gets huge vote of confidence from IAG

US aircraft giant Boeing got a welcome vote of confidence in its beleaguered 737 MAX plane on Tuesday when International Airlines Group, owner of British Airways, said it wanted to buy 200 of the planes. It was a coup for Boeing since up to now IAG has been a longtime client of Airbus for its single-aisle jets, used on some of its most popular routes. "We have every confidence in Boeing and expect that the aircraft will make a successful return to service in the coming months having received approval from the regulators," IAG's chief Willie Walsh said in a statement.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Business

Hit "Like"
Don't miss any important news
Thanks, you don't need to show me this anymore.