Beijing's legal influence triggers disquiet in Hong Kong financial sector

  • In Business
  • 2019-12-13 02:04:27Z
  • By Reuters
Beijing\'s legal influence triggers disquiet in Hong Kong financial sector  

By Sumeet Chatterjee

HONG KONG (Reuters) - When China's top legislature criticized a Hong Kong court's rejection of a face mask ban there, some global firms began to fear the potential for mainland interference in commercial contracts, lawyers and finance executives said.

Hong Kong's vaunted rule of law is widely seen as a major factor for global financial institutions who make the former British colony their regional home and using it as their main trade and other dispute resolution center.

"Against the backdrop of what's happening in Hong Kong, this development doesn't really give us any comfort about the future of high-value commercial contracts," said a Hong Kong-based executive at a leading global auditing and consultancy firm, who declined to be named because of the sensitivity of the matter.

"Many of our clients, who have been in Hong Kong for many decades, have started to have that angst now," the executive added. "They are internally discussing what does this mean and whether it would make sense to have a plan B in place for critical contracts."

The concerns stem from a statement last month from the legislative affairs commission of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress questioning the power of Hong Kong's High Court, which had overturned a ban on face masks.

The ban was part of a government effort to rein in pro-democracy unrest that started in June.

The committee's statement said Hong Kong courts had no power to rule on the constitutionality of the city's laws, the official Xinhua news agency reported.

In response, the Hong Kong Bar Association said the statement was "legally incorrect" and undermined the "the high degree of autonomy granted to under the Basic Law", the document that outlines the extent of Hong Kong's freedoms and autonomy.

Hong Kong's government has appealed the court ruling. The next hearings are on Jan 9-10, a spokesman for the Department of Justice said in a statement to Reuters on Tuesday.

"Under 'One Country, Two Systems', Hong Kong is part of China but retains our own systems and way of life," it said.

"The Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government is not only fully committed to providing a level-playing field for business to thrive, but also safeguarding our rule of law and protecting the freedom and rights of all people living and conducting business, working or just visiting Hong Kong."


Global banks, wealth and asset managers, and insurers book billions of dollars in revenue every year in Hong Kong, the bulk of it flowing from China.

Senior executives at global financial firms have privately mentioned greater legal and social freedoms in Hong Kong compared with mainland China as one of the reasons behind making the city their main regional centers.

Rating agency Fitch said on Thursday Hong Kong's role in global finance was intact despite the protests and social unrest.

But that may change if "political uncertainty continues, a factor underscored by an ongoing debate regarding the Hong Kong courts' authority to conduct constitutional review of the Basic Law," it said, referring to the face mask decision.

A group of treasurers from about a half-dozen global companies with Hong Kong operations met this month and discussed booking high-value transactions in Singapore or elsewhere, said a senior banker who facilitated the meeting.

The banker, like the other financial industry and legal sources in this article, declined to be identified because of the sensitivity of the matter.

The concerns at the routine half-yearly gathering were fueled by more than six months of protests, as well as worries about Beijing's influence over the local judicial system, said the banker, who works at a global lender.

A senior official at a Hong Kong government-backed financial body told Reuters that some global firms had expressed concern to the agency about Beijing's influence after the National People's Congress (NPC) committee statement.

"Our attitude in the past has been - oh well, these things (the NPC remarks) come along periodically and muddy the waters, but they don't come along that often," said a corporate lawyer with an global law firm in Hong Kong.

"The thing about the NPC is that their interpretations are so cack-handed - just zero appreciation for the legal issues - you can tell the whole thing is being driven by a political imperative."

(Reporting by Sumeet Chatterjee; additional reporting by Alun John and Greg Torode. Editing by Gerry Doyle)


More Related News

China extends Lunar New Year holiday as new virus toll rises
China extends Lunar New Year holiday as new virus toll rises
  • World
  • 2020-01-27 01:04:26Z

China on Monday expanded sweeping efforts to contain a viral disease by postponing the end of this week's Lunar New Year holiday to keep the public at home and avoid spreading infection as the death toll rose to 80. Hong Kong announced it would bar entry to visitors from the mainland province at the center of the outbreak. Increasingly drastic anti-disease efforts began with the Jan. 22 suspension of plane, train and bus links to Wuhan, a city of 11 million people in central China where the virus was first detected last month.

Hong Kong bars Hubei residents from entering city as coronavirus fears intensify
Hong Kong bars Hubei residents from entering city as coronavirus fears intensify

Hong Kong authorities on Sunday barred residents of China's Hubei province, the center of the coronavirus outbreak, from entering the city, in response to mounting pressure to enact preventative measures to contain the spreading epidemic. The ban includes those who have been in the province in the past 14 days but excludes Hong Kong citizens. Earlier a group of protesters set alight the lobby of a newly built residential building in Hong Kong that authorities planned to use as a quarantine facility for the coronavirus outbreak.

Hong Kong Disneyland and Ocean Park to be closed from Sunday to help prevent spread of virus: CCTV
Hong Kong Disneyland and Ocean Park to be closed from Sunday to help prevent spread of virus: CCTV

Hong Kong's popular amusement parks Disneyland and Ocean Park are closed from Jan. 26 to help prevent the spread of a deadly coronavirus that broke out in the Chinese city Wuhan, state media CCTV reported on Sunday. Business is going on as usual at the hotels inside Hong Kong Disneyland, however, CCTV reported. The Shanghai government said on Friday that Shanghai Disneyland will be closed from Saturday.

Hong Kong declares Wuhan virus outbreak an
Hong Kong declares Wuhan virus outbreak an 'emergency'

Hong Kong on Saturday declared a new coronavirus outbreak as an "emergency" -- the city's highest warning tier -- as authorities ramped up measures to reduce the risk of further infections. Of the five people who have tested positive for the virus in Hong Kong so far, four arrived via a newly built high-speed train terminal which connects with the mainland. Lam held emergency meetings with health officials on Saturday morning after returning from Davos.

Protest violence won
Protest violence won't work, leading Hong Kong activist says

Escalating protest violence is not the way to bring about change, Hong Kong democracy activist Jason Ng has said, urging demonstrators to embrace non-violent means in the struggle to throw off a feared tightening of Beijing's control. With the movement in a less frenetic and ferocious stage after seven months of unrest, Ng, who is also a lawyer, said people in Hong Kong were taking time to process what had happened and reflect on the way forward. Speaking to AFP in an interview in Barcelona, Ng said he hoped the protests would return to the non-violent ethos that had characterised the Umbrella Revolution, the mass pro-democracy demonstrations of 2014.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Business