Analysis: In impeachment fight, it's Trump vs. Constitution




  • In Politics
  • 2019-10-11 11:44:18Z
  • By Associated Press

NEW YORK (AP) - Donald Trump has spent his time in office trying to bend the conventions of the American presidency to his will. Now he appears to be trying to override a core principle of democracy: that no one is above the law.

Faced with an impeachment inquiry, Trump has openly defied the core constructs of the Constitution. He chafes at the idea of co-equal branches of government and rejects the House's right to investigate him.

He has deployed a convoluted logic in which he has declared that the courts can't investigate him because as president he cannot be charged with a crime but also that Congress cannot impeach him because its inquiry is politically illegitimate.

It's a "heads he wins, tails you lose" formulation.

"It's anathema to his character and his life story to be checked and balanced by anything," said presidential historian Jon Meacham, a professor at Vanderbilt University. "The Constitution was formed to contain appetite. And we now have the president who is driven entirely by appetite."

In a scathing eight-page letter this week, the Republican president's lawyers served notice there will be no cooperation with the impeachment inquiry.

Trump's White House has ignored document requests and subpoenas. It readily invokes executive privilege - going so far as to argue that the privilege extends to informal presidential advisers who never held White House jobs. And his team all but dares Democrats to hold them in contempt.

The impeachment standoff follows a pattern Trump has established throughout his presidency as he has jettisoned experienced advisers and flouted conventions.

The fact that he survived the special counsel's Russia investigation without paying much of a political penalty left him all the more emboldened.

One day after Robert Mueller's faltering testimony brought an end to that threat, Trump unleashed a new one by asking Ukraine's president to investigate his political foe Joe Biden. That prompted the fast-moving impeachment inquiry that Trump now resists.

After two weeks of a listless and unfocused response to the impeachment probe, the White House letter to Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi this week was a declaration of war.

While it was filled with dubious legal arguments, its intent was clear: Trump would not play ball, claiming that the game was rigged against him.

As for all the subpoenas flying from House Democrats, an exasperated Trump said Thursday, "You're running a country, I just don't think that you can have all of these people testifying about every conversation you've had."

And as for the Democrats, Trump claimed Wednesday they're the ones playing dirty "because they have a tiny margin in the House."

"They have eviscerated the rules," he said. "They don't give us any - any fair play. It's the most unfair situation people have seen."

The Constitution gives the House "the sole power of impeachment." But it confers that authority without providing any guidelines, which the White House has seized upon in demanding that Pelosi call for a vote to authorize the inquiry as happened in the last two impeachment inquiries.

No vote is required, and Trump's strategy risks further provoking Democrats in the impeachment probe, setting up court challenges and the potential for lawmakers to draw up an article of impeachment for obstructing their investigations.

"The president does not have all-consuming power," said Nick Ackerman, a member of the Watergate prosecution team that investigated President Richard Nixon. "We play by certain rules, and we expect the rule of law to apply. We don't have checks and balances if he ignores them. That itself is an impeachable offense, which is what Nixon faced."

It is unclear whether Democrats would wade into a lengthy legal fight with the administration over documents and testimony or if they would just move straight to considering articles of impeachment.

Trump, for his part, has never been one to rely on legality or logic in making his arguments.

In the last week alone, he called for the impeachment of Sen. Mitt Romney and Rep. Adam Schiff - events that can't occur - and in part justified his decision to withdraw U.S. troops from Syria, leaving the Kurds vulnerable to Turkish attacks, by saying the Kurds did not assist at Normandy during World War II.

Since taking office, he has taken repeatedly taken unilateral action to defy Congress and push the limits of his own power, declaring a national emergency so he could divert funds for a border wall and taking executive action to try to halt immigration from several Muslim-majority nations.

Trump on Thursday punctuated a tweet about unfair media coverage with four words that seemed to sum up his entire viewpoint of the American system: "Oh well, I'm President!"

The Constitution was built to withstand tests like this.

"Both the strength of the American system and one of its most frustrating aspects is that it's incredibly difficult to do anything quickly, particularly bad things, which the founders believed would happen more often than good things," Meacham said. "Checks and balances were created so one bad actor could not dominate the proceedings. We now have that bad actor."

___

EDITOR'S NOTE - Jonathan Lemire has covered politics and the White House for The Associated Press since 2013.

___

Follow Lemire on Twitter at http://twitter.com/@JonLemire

COMMENTS

More Related News

Republican Critics, Fearing Trump, Toe an Anti-Impeachment Party Line, for Now
Republican Critics, Fearing Trump, Toe an Anti-Impeachment Party Line, for Now

SAN ANTONIO -- Republican activists who gathered over Texas barbecue here last week said they were stunned when Rep. Will Hurd, the rare Republican in Congress who is willing to publicly criticize President Donald Trump, joined every other member of his party in voting against holding public impeachment

Feud Between Trump Advisers Underscores a White House Torn by Rivalries
Feud Between Trump Advisers Underscores a White House Torn by Rivalries
  • World
  • 2019-11-12 13:40:40Z

WASHINGTON -- President Donald Trump's chief of staff and former national security adviser clashed in court Monday. Two new books describe how top aides to the president secretly plotted to circumvent him. And nearly every day brings more testimony about the deep internal schism over the president's effort to pressure Ukraine for domestic political help.In the three years since his election, Trump has never been accused of running a cohesive, unified team. But the revelations of recent days have put on display perhaps more starkly than ever the fissures tearing at his administration. In the emerging picture, the Trump White House is a toxic stew of personality disputes, policy...

Judge dismisses Trump lawsuit against NY officials, House committee over taxes
Judge dismisses Trump lawsuit against NY officials, House committee over taxes

A federal judge on Monday issued another blow to President Donald Trump and his ongoing effort to avoid having his tax records turned over to Congress. U.S. Judge Carl Nichols granted a motion to dismiss a lawsuit that Trump filed in July over the TRUST Act in New York, which gave Congress the authority to retrieve tax information from New York residents.

Fox News Contributor Causes Scene When She Names Alleged Whistleblower on Air
Fox News Contributor Causes Scene When She Names Alleged Whistleblower on Air

Fox News contributor Mollie Hemingway caused a scene on Sunday morning when she purposely named the alleged whistleblower at the center of the impeachment inquiry against President Trump, seemingly breaking the network's policy of identifying the person.Amid a concerted effort by Trump's allies to publicly out the whistleblower who filed the complaint about Trump's infamous July 25 call with the Ukrainian president, right-wing media outlets have touted an online report purportedly sharing the identity of the person. Mainstream media outlets and social media platforms, meanwhile, have refrained from spreading the person's name.Fox News had reportedly also instructed its employees to not...

In Seeking to Join Suit Over Subpoena Power, Mulvaney Goes Up Against the President
In Seeking to Join Suit Over Subpoena Power, Mulvaney Goes Up Against the President

TUSCALOOSA, Ala. -- Even in a White House of never-befores, this may be one of the more head-spinning: The president's chief of staff is trying to join a lawsuit against the president.Mick Mulvaney works only about 50 steps from the Oval Office as he runs the White House staff, but rather than simply obey President Donald Trump's order to not cooperate with House impeachment investigators, he sent his lawyers to court late Friday night asking a judge whether he should or not.To obtain such a ruling, the lawyers asked to join a lawsuit already filed by a former White House official -- a lawsuit that names "the Honorable Donald J. Trump" as a defendant along with congressional...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply

Comments

Top News: Politics