'An emergency moment': Abortion rights advocates want bigger response from Biden to Texas law

  • In Politics
  • 2021-09-08 20:56:46Z

WASHINGTON - The steps President Joe Biden took early in his administration to reverse his predecessor's policies on reproductive health issues drew howls from abortion opponents.

But Biden, whose positions on abortion issues have evolved over the years, still faced some skepticism from abortion rights advocates about his commitment to their cause. One worrisome sign had been the administration's avoidance of the word "abortion" in favor of more generic phrases like "reproductive health" and "women's health access."

Biden now faces his biggest test yet of that commitment in his response to a new Texas law that bans the procedure after about six weeks of pregnancy - and is expected to be copied by other GOP-led states.

Biden did, for the first time since his inauguration, use the word "abortion" in his statements condemning the law, which the Supreme Court allowed to go into effect last week. He's also called the law "almost un-American" for its reliance on private citizens to sue abortion providers and anyone involved in "aiding and abetting" abortions.

And his team met Friday with women's rights and reproductive health leaders to discuss how to fight the statue.

Marcela Howell, president and CEO of In Our Own Voice: National Black Women's Reproductive Justice Agenda, said that while she believes Biden is supportive of reproductive rights, he needs to be doing more - especially from the bully pulpit.

"Extraordinary circumstances call for extraordinary action," she said, "and it's time for him to demonstrate that in a much bigger way."

Actions activists want the administration to embrace include: Suing Texas. Meeting with Texas women impacted by the law. Easing restrictions on medication abortion. Endorsing legislation the House is taking up to codify the Supreme Court's 1973 Roe v. Wade decision establishing abortion rights.

The Texas law also increases pressure on Biden to back changes to the filibuster and to the makeup of the Supreme Court.

"I think they were getting the full picture of the urgency and responding appropriately," said Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights, who attended the meeting with White House officials.

Texas abortion law: What to know about the law banning abortions once heartbeat is detected

More: Texas abortion law the latest in a pattern of restrictions from GOP-controlled Legislature

Biden, an observant Catholic, has long wrestled with the issue as his positions have evolved along with the Democratic Party's increasing unanimity on abortion rights.

Most recently, Biden last year reversed his decades-long support for the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits federal funding for most abortions.

US President Joe Biden speaks with a priest as he leaves St.
US President Joe Biden speaks with a priest as he leaves St.  

Soon after taking office, Biden allowed federal funds to flow again to international groups that provide or refer patients for abortion services and moved to undo restrictions on U.S. clinics that provide abortion counseling or services. His first budget request did not include the Hyde Amendment.

Biden, who says he personally opposes abortion, frames his views in the context of one of his top priorities: creating a more equitable society for people of color and other marginalized groups.

But the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops is working on a document that could rebuke Catholic politicians for receiving Communion if they support abortion rights.

Facing heat from conservative Catholics over his actions, White House press secretary Jen Psaki sparred last week with a reporter from EWTN Global Catholic Network. The reporter asked how Biden can support abortion when "his own Catholic faith teaches that abortion is morally wrong."

"Well, he believes that it's a woman's right, it's a woman's body, and it's her choice," Psaki told the male reporter. "I know you've never faced those choices, nor have you ever been pregnant. But for women out there who have faced those choices, this is an incredibly difficult thing."

Joe Biden's faith-based `equity agenda': Why it's getting pushback from religious conservatives

White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki talks to reporters at the White House on Thursday, September 2, 2021.
White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki talks to reporters at the White House on Thursday, September 2, 2021.  

The next day, White House officials met virtually with 11 leaders of women's rights and reproductive health organizations.

Advocates hopeful, but details remain unclear

Fatima Goss Graves, president and CEO of the National Women's Law Center, said she was pleased that the administration committed to using every tool at its disposal to respond.

"And that was the thrust of the meeting," Goss Graves said. "What does that mean in practice, in this time of both constitutional crisis and a literal public health emergency on the ground where people who need care are at risk of not getting it?"

The answer, however, is still unclear.

Attorney General Merrick Garland said in a statement Monday that the department will enforce a 1994 law prohibiting threats, physical obstruction or property damage to try to prevent someone from seeking or providing reproductive health services at a clinic.

But he didn't detail how that would work. And Psaki said Wednesday the Justice Department and Department of Health and Human Services are still evaluating their options.

Goss Graves said she expects "ongoing updates."

"We will be watching closely to ensure that becomes a reality," she said. "This is one of those moments where people will be asking, 'What side of history were we on? Where were our leaders when there was this effort to totally undermine our access to care and our fundamentally protected rights?' "

Northup, of the Center for Reproductive Rights, has urged the Justice Department to take every possible action, including suing Texas, enjoining the law and considering criminal prosecutions for the deprivation of civil rights.

"I have full confidence that they will move as soon as they can," she said.

Alexis McGill Johnson, president and CEO of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America, hopes Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris will go to Texas to talk with patients "to understand what is actually happening on the impact of the law."

Planned Parenthood is also pushing the administration to get behind the Women's Health Protection Act, legislation to block restrictions on reproductive health services that House Democrats plan to bring to the floor this month.

"We shared our thoughts with the administration on Friday," McGill Johnson said. "All of these things are in conversation."

Of the calls by Planned Parenthood and others for the administration to lift the FDA's restrictions on Mifepristone, a drug used to end an early pregnancy, Psaki said Wednesday that's "a decision that the FDA has to make on their own, based on science."

Abolish the filibuster? Expand the court?

While Biden supports codifying Roe v. Wade, Psaki has demurred when asked if he backs the Women's Health Protection Act as the way to do it.

"We're still looking at whether that's a vehicle we're going to support," she said Wednesday.

The bigger hurdle for legislative actions is the Senate, where Democrats don't have enough votes to block a filibuster. That's intensifying on Biden the pressure he already faced - over voting rights and other issues - to support changes to the filibuster.

And the Texas law adds significance to the commission Biden has tasked with reviewing the structure and operation of the Supreme Court by early October.

"In the long term, the best way to protect women's rights is to add at least two justices to the Supreme Court," Dan Pfeiffer, a top aide in the Obama administration, recently wrote.

Supreme Court changes?: Biden unveils commission to study options after pressure from progressives

Roe v. Wade: 'Huge numbers' of abortion cases heading to Supreme Court to test limits

Abortion rights activists protest during a demonstration outside the U.
Abortion rights activists protest during a demonstration outside the U.  

Expanding the court and abolishing the filibuster are among the priorities for Tamika Middleton, deputy director of the Women's March who was not a participant in Friday's White House meeting.

The group had already been working with dozens of organizations to mobilize a show of support for abortion rights before the Supreme Court returns in the fall. The court has signaled its readiness to take another look at past abortion rulings by agreeing to consider Mississippi's attempt to ban most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy.

The Texas law added new urgency.

"We knew that we needed to mobilize more quickly," Middleton said of the Oct. 2 event that will include marches in every state.

The response from the administration so far, she said, has not been strong enough to deter other states from passing similar laws.

"This is an emergency moment," she said. "We have to take clear and immediate and strong action."

For Renee Bracey Sherman, founder and executive director of We Testify who was not at the White House meeting, the actions by the administration should start with Biden talking openly about abortions.

Bracey Sherman, whose group helps people who've had abortions share their stories, created a website tracking how long it took Biden to use the word. She found it "absolutely wild" that even the presidential statement recognizing the 48th anniversary of the Roe v. Wade decision did not use it.

"If he truly believes that abortion access is a human right, and that it's a constitutionally protected service, then he should be able to come out and address the country and talk about that, talk about his values, why, as a Catholic man, he believes that people should have access to abortions," Bracey Sherman said. "How can you advocate for something without talking about it?"

Asked last week about Biden's seeming reluctance to use the word until the Texas law went into effect, Psaki declined to say whether that was deliberate.

But her response was an acknowledgement that abortion rights activists are paying close attention to the president's response.

"I think the most important value people should look at is what the president does in his actions and what he fights for," she said. "And I don't think I'm going to have any other assessment beyond that."

More: Texas Gov. Greg Abbott defends abortion law, says state will 'eliminate rape'

More: Texas abortion law written to put providers at a legal disadvantage

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Abortion rights groups want bigger response from Biden to Texas law


More Related News

U.S. business groups criticize Biden
U.S. business groups criticize Biden's Taiwan arms sales policy

U.S. business groups on Tuesday criticized the Biden administration's Taiwan arms sales policy, arguing in a public letter that it was too restrictive and...

House Jan. 6 panel unlikely to call Trump, chairman says
House Jan. 6 panel unlikely to call Trump, chairman says

House investigators are unlikely to call former President Donald Trump to testify about his role in the Jan. 6, 2021 insurrection, relying instead on...

U.S. Sen. Jim Risch, of Idaho, weighs in on Ukraine situation: Putin can smell weakness
U.S. Sen. Jim Risch, of Idaho, weighs in on Ukraine situation: Putin can smell weakness
  • World
  • 2022-05-17 20:44:03Z

"There's only one thing that Putin respects, and that's strength. The main thing he is most disrespectful of is weakness. If you show weakness, he will come ...

Buffalo shooting: Biden rebukes
Buffalo shooting: Biden rebukes 'poison' of white supremacy

The suspect in a mass shooting in New York belongs to "a hateful minority", the president said.

Jill Biden heads to Latin America before hemispheric summit
Jill Biden heads to Latin America before hemispheric summit

Jill Biden will visit Ecuador, Costa Rica and Panama this week to help lay the groundwork as the United States finalizes arrangements for a hemisphere-wide...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

Cancel reply


Top News: Politics